1. las analogías en la formulación de la teoría electromagnética de la luz de maxwell

24
Las analogías en la formulación de la teoría electromagnética de la luz de Maxwell Analogies in the Formulation of Maxwell’s Electromagnetic Theory of Light Vladimir Cachón Guillén En-claves del Pensamiento, vol. VII, núm. 14, julio-diciembre, 2013, pp. 11-33. Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey Campus Ciudad de México Distrito Federal, México En-claves del Pensamiento, ISSN (Versión impresa): 1870-879X [email protected] [email protected] Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey Campus Ciudad de México México

Upload: alexander-montellano

Post on 11-Apr-2016

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Una gran analogía de un gran profesor del campus UNAM.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

Las analogías en la formulación de la teoría electromagnética de la luz de Maxwell 

Analogies in the Formulation of Maxwell’s Electromagnetic Theory of Light 

Vladimir Cachón Guillén 

En-claves del Pensamiento, vol. VII, núm. 14, julio-diciembre, 2013, pp. 11-33. Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey Campus Ciudad de

México Distrito Federal, México

En-claves del Pensamiento, ISSN (Versión impresa): 1870-879X

[email protected] [email protected]

Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey Campus Ciudad de México

México

Page 2: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento!"#$%"&''!"()*+",-!"./01%231415*675"89,:!";;+",,2::+,,

LAS ANALOGÍAS EN LA FORMULACIÓN DE LA TEORÍA ELECTROMAGNÉTICA 

DE LA LUZ DE MAXWELL

VLADIMIR CACHÓN GUILLÉN*

Resumen

E<=5"=7#6#.%"<5"45(=7#"5("0%<"3%<";71*57%<"#7=>4/0%<"35"?#*5<"@057A"B#CD500"<%675"0#<"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"*#G(H=14#+"IJ/H"005KL"#"B#CD500"#"5<471617"<%675"

5<=5"=5*#!"M"4L*%"1(N/M57%("5("H0"0#<"4174/(<=#(41#<"=54(%0LG14#<"35"</"=15*­;%O"P!"<%675"=%3%!"I4L*%"0%G7L!"#";#7=17"350"5*;05%"35"#(#0%G>#<"*54Q(14#<!"5(=5(357"0#"(#=/7#05F#"35"0%<"4#*;%<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<"M"4%(45617"/(#"=5%7>#"/(1R4#3#"350"*#G(5=1<*%!"0#"5054=71413#3"M"0#"0/FO"S5"5C;0%7#"50";7%45<%"475#­=1K%"35"B#CD500"M"<5"1(=5(=#"3571K#7"35"H0"#0G/(#<"4%(40/<1%(5<")=105<"<%675"0#"*#(57#"5("T/5"<5"U#45"415(41#+

Palabras claveV"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#!"4#*;%"5054=7%*#G(H=14%!"=505G7#E>#"</6*#71(#!"B#CD500!"WU%*;<%(!"X#7#3#M+

Abstract

WU1<"#7=1405"E%4/<5<"%("=U5"=D%"R7<="?#*5<"@057A"B#CD500";#;57<"%("*#G(5=14"01(5<"%E"E%745+"YU#="=%%A"B#CD500"=%"D71=5"#6%/="=U1<"1<</5!"#(3"U%D"313"=U5"=5­4U(%0%G14#0"4174/*<=#(45<"%E"U1<"=1*5"1(N/5(45"U1*O"Z(3!"%K57"#00!"U%D"313"U5"

[" \%45(=5"350"]#6%7#=%71%"35"̂ <=/31%<"S%41#05<"35"0#"@15(41#!"\5;#7=#*5(=%"35"_1%0%G>#"̂ K%0/=1K#!"X#4/0=#3"35"@15(41#<!"`aZB!"BHC14%!"bK0#31*174GcM#U%%+4%*d+

En-Claves14-book.indb 11 04/11/13 14:54

Page 3: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

,8" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

*#(#G5"=%"/(357<=#(3!"=U7%/GU"=U5"/<5"%E"*54U#(14#0"#(#0%G15<!"=U5"(#=/75"%E"5054=7%*#G(5=14"R503<"#(3"*#(#G5"=%"6/103"#"/(1R53"=U5%7M"%E"*#G(5=1<*!"5054­=7141=M"#(3"01GU=O"'="1<"5C;0%753"=U5"475#=1K5";7%45<<"%E"B#CD500f<"*1(3!"#(3"=U5(!"1="1<"#==5*;=53"=%"1(E57"<%*5"/<5E/0"4%(40/<1%(<"#6%/="=U5"D#M"<415(45"1<"3%(5+

Key wordsV"]1(5<"%E"E%745!"5054=7%*#G(5=14"R503!"</6*#71(5"=505G7#;UM!"B#CD500!"WU%*;<%(!"X#7#3#M+

Contemplado desde muy lejos en la historia de la humanidad –digamos que desde diez mil años a partir de ahora– debe haber poca duda de que se 

!"#$%&'()(*+,-'+'.+/'!/"+0*$+$%1#%2!)3%4"+&'.+siglo XIX es el descubrimiento realizado por Maxwell de las leyes de la electrodinámica.

Richard Feynman1

Introducción

I@L*%"<5"50#6%7#("0#<"G7#(35<"=5%7>#<"415(=>R4#<O"^0";7%605*#"U#"%4/;#3%"#"(/*57%<%<"R0L<%E%<"35"0#"415(41#"#0"*5(%<"35<35"Y1001#*"YU5DU500!8 a principios del siglo XIX+"\5<35"5(=%(45<!"(/*57%<%<"R0L<%E%<"5"U1<=%71#3%75<"35"0#"415(41#!""4%*%"g/U(!:"h%;;57-"%"]#A#=%<i"U#("#;%7=#3%"K#01%<#<"jM"#"K545<"4%(=7#­314=%71#<j"=5%7>#<";#7#"35<5(=7#$#7"0#"31(Q*14#"35"0#"1(K5<=1G#41L("415(=>R4#+^("5<=5"#7=>4/0%"jM"#"31E575(41#"35"0#<";57<%(#013#35<"41=#3#<j"(%"6/<4#*%<"

U#00#7"/(#"75<;/5<=#"G5(57#0"#"5<=#";75G/(=#+"J/575*%<!"5("4#*61%!"5(4%(­=7#7"/(#"75<;/5<=#"#"/("4#<%")(14%!";57%"T/5"=/K%"75;574/<1%(5<"G1G#(=5<4#<V"I4/Q0"E/5"0#"31(Q*14#"350"35<4/671*15(=%!";%7";#7=5"35"B#CD500!"35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#"35"0#" 0/FO"h#7#"500%!"(%<"5(E%4#75*%<"5("0%<"3%<";71*57%<"#7=>4/0%<"T/5"B#CD500"5<47161L"<%675"50"=5*#"35"0#<"líneas de fuerza —un con­45;=%"T/5"35<;/H<"3571K#7>#"5("50"35"campo"5054=7%*#G(H=14%j"M"T/5"10/<=7#("

,  k+"X5M(*#(!"The Feynman Lectures  on Physics!" K%0+" I."B#<<#4U/<5=<!"Z31<<%(2Y5<05M!",lm-!";+",,+

8" Y+"YU5D500!"History of the Inductive Sciences!",n:o!"35"0#"T/5"5C1<=5"/(#"53141L("E#4<1*10#7";/6014#3#";%7"@#*6713G5"`(1K57<1=M"h75<<!"89,9+

:" S%675"=%3%"5("50"M#"40Q<14%"W+"g/U(!"5)+'$3(-!3-()+&'+.)$+('4".-!%"#'$+!%'#362!)$7+BHC14%!"FCE!",lm8+

-  h%7"5.5*;0%!"g+"h%;;57!"8/'+5"1%!+"9+:!%'#3%2!+;%$!"4'(<+"a/5K#"P%7A!"p/=4U1(<%("q"@%+!",lil+i" ^("*/4U#<"35"</<"%67#<!";57%"<%675"=%3%"5("'+"]#A#=%<!"=$!(%3"$+2."$>2!"$?+.)+0'3"&"."16)+

&'+."$+@("1()0)$+&'+%#4'$3%1)!%>#+!%'#362!)7+B#3713!"Z01#(F#!"8998+

En-Claves14-book.indb 12 04/11/13 14:54

Page 4: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" ,:

4L*%"0#<"4174/(<=#(41#<"#4#3H*14#<!";%0>=14#<"M"=54(%0LG14#<!"#<>"4%*%"0#"*/M";57<%(#0"E%7*#"T/5"4#3#"415(=>R4%"=15(5";#7#"4%(<=7/17"=5%7>#<!"<5"1*6714#("5("una compleja trama en donde es difícil ponderar el peso que tiene cada uno 

35"5<=%<"E#4=%75<+^<=5"4#<%!"=#*61H(!"(%<"<17K5";#7#"4/5<=1%(#7"/(%"35"0%<"*1=%<"T/5"<5"5*­

;05#("4%("E754/5(41#"5("50"#*615(=5"#4#3H*14%V"50"35"T/5"0#"415(41#"#K#(F#"primero como ciencia pura!"*531#(=5"%6<57K#41%(5<"M"5C;571*5(=%<"T/5"4/0­minan en teorías #6<=7#4=#<"j(%7*#0*5(=5"#;%M#3#<"5("E%7*/0#41%(5<"*#­=5*Q=14#<j!"M"T/5"5<=#<"=5%7>#<!"4%("50"=15*;%!"3571K#("%"*#3/7#("5("ciencia aplicada M"5("(/5K#<"=54(%0%G>#<!"4%*%"<1" 0#";#7=5"=5L714%2#6<=7#4=#"356157#"17"<15*;75";71*57%"M!"35<;/H<!"</<"#;014#41%(5<"=54(%0LG14#<+"Z"4%(=1(/#41L("K575*%<"T/5"0#"31(Q*14#"35"35<4/671*15(=%<"5<"*/4U%"*Q<"4%*;05.#"T/5"5<=%!"M"T/5"5<=#"<54/5(41#"135#0"(%"<5"#./<=#"#"0#"75#013#3"U1<=L714#!"#0"*5(%<"(%"5("50"4#<%"350"T/5"(%<"%4/;#75*%<+

Surge el interés de Maxwell por el electromagnetismo

^0"=7#6#.%"=5L714%2*#=5*Q=14%"35"?#*5<"@057A"B#CD500";57*1=1L"/(#"35"0#<"<>(­=5<1<"*Q<"1*;%7=#(=5<"35"0#"E><14#+"Z(=5<"35"H0!"0#"5054=71413#3!"50"*#G(5=1<*%"M"0#"L;=14#"<5"4%(<1357#6#("=75<"4#*;%<"35"5<=/31%"=%=#0*5(=5"31<=1(=%<"M"<5;#­7#3%<+"S1("5*6#7G%!"G7#41#<"#"</"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#!"U%M"<5"05<"4%(<1357#"31E575(=5<"*#(1E5<=#41%(5<"35"/("*1<*%"E5(L*5(%+h57%"I4L*%"<5"005GL"#"5<=%O"J/1FQ"0#";71*57#";75G/(=#"T/5"356#*%<";0#(­

=5#7(%<"5<"IT/H"U#4>#"B#CD500!"35"5(=7#3#!"=7#6#.#(3%"5("50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"*15(=7#<"5<=/31#6#"E><14#"5("0#"̀ (1K57<13#3"35"@#*6713G5!"5("3%(35"(%"RG/7#6#"5("0%<";0#(5<"35"5<=/31%O"^0";71*57"505*5(=%"35"0#"75<;/5<=#"5<"T/5!"5("5<5"*%*5(=%!"B14U#50"X#7#3#M"U#6>#" 0%G7#3%!"4%("</<" 1(K5<=1G#41%(5<!"<1=/#7" 0#"5054=71413#3"4%*%"/(%"35"0%<";7%605*#<"45(=7#05<"35"0#"E><14#+"p#6>#"35*%<­=7#3%"T/5"<5"=7#=#6#"35"/(#";7%;153#3"4#7#4=57><=14#"35"=%3%"=1;%"35"*#=571#!"M"T/5"5<=#6#">(=1*#*5(=5"750#41%(#3#"4%("50"4%*;%7=#*15(=%"E><14%"M"T/>*14%"35"0%<"4/57;%<"*#=571#05<+m"a%"%6<=#(=5!"5<=5"(/5K%";7%605*#"#)("(%"U#6>#";57*5#3%"0%<";0#(5<"35"5<=/31%"35"0#<"/(1K57<13#35<"350";#><+"@%(=7#"0%"T/5";%37>#"47557<5!"50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"(%"57#"/("4#*;%"35"5<=/31%"=>;14%"5("0#<";71(41;#05<"/(1K57<13#35<!"4%*%"@#*6713G5!"5("0#"T/5"0#"4#7757#"35"X><14#"5("0%<"

m" `(#"5C;%<141L("750#=1K#*5(=5"675K5!";57%"7#F%(#605*5(=5"4%*;05=#!"<%675"5<=5"=5*#"#;#7545"5(V"X+"@Q(%K#<!"r?#*5<"@057A"B#CD500s!"5("Historia de la física+"B/741#!"`(1K57<13#3"35"B/741#!"899i+"P";#7#"/(#"5C;%<141L("*Q<"#*;01#";/535"K57<5"Y+"_57A<%(!"Las teorías de los campos de fuerza desde Faraday hasta Einstein. B#3713!"Z01#(F#!",lni+

En-Claves14-book.indb 13 04/11/13 14:54

Page 5: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

,-" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

#$%<"41(4/5(=#<"350"<1G0%"XIX"<5"5(E%4#6#!"<%675"=%3%!"#0"5<=/31%"35"0#"*54Q(14#"4505<=5!"0#"L;=14#"M"0#"U137%31(Q*14#+o"Z";5<#7"35"5<=%!"U#M"5K135(41#"35"T/5"*15(=7#<"B#CD500"5<=/31#6#"5("@#*6713G5"5<=#6#"#0"4%7715(=5"35"#0G/(%<"35"0%<"=7#6#.%<";1%(57%<"5("5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"75#01F#3%<";%7"X#7#3#M!";%7"/("0#3%!"M"35"0%<"005K#3%<"#"4#6%";%7"Y1001#*"WU%*;<%(!"#"T/15("4%(%41L"5(",ni9"tM"T/5"*/4U%"*Q<"=#735!"5(",nl8!"<57>#"(%*67#3%"6#7L("g50K1("35"]#G<"M"4%(%413%"35<35"5(=%(45<"4%*%"0%73"g50K1(u+W7#<"U#657"=57*1(#3%"</<"5<=/31%<"*#=5*Q=14%<"5("@#*6713G5!"#";71(41;1%<"

35",ni-!"5" 1(N/13%";%7" 0%<"5C;571*5(=%<"<%675"4%7715(=5<"50H4=714#<"M" 0>(5#<"*#G(H=14#<"35"X#7#3#M!"B#CD500" 5(K1L"/(#" 4#7=#"#"WU%*;<%("jT/5"U#6>#"5<=#3%" =7#6#.#(3%"5("5<=%<" =5*#<j"<%0141=Q(3%05"T/5";/3157#"G/1#705" 5("50"estudio de estos fenómenos:

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ambridge JournalO"S1"/<=53"=15(5"5("0#"4#65F#"#0G/(#"75<;/5<=#"#"5<=#<"4/5<=1%(5<!"=75<"35"(%<%=7%<"5<=#7>#*%<"G/<=%<%<"35"7541617";%7"5<471=%"</<"4%(<5.%<+n

P#"E/57#";%7"0#"75<;/5<=#"35"WU%*;<%("%";%7"1(141#=1K#";7%;1#!"B#CD500"4%­*5(FL"</"1(K5<=1G#41%(5<"05M5(3%"0%<"Experimental Researches in Electricity!"35"X#7#3#M+"]%<"5C;571*5(=%<"35"X#7#3#M";0#(=5#6#("/(#"G7#("4#(=13#3"35";7%605­*#<"#"75<%0K57!"#35*Q<"35"0%<"750#=1K%<"#"0#"750#41%(5<"5(=75"0#"5054=71413#3"M"0#"*#=571#+"Z;5(#<"/("#$%"35<;/H<!"5("%=7#"4#7=#"#"WU%*;<%("E54U#3#"5("e05(#17"50",:"35"<5;=15*675"35",nii!"B#CD500"jT/5"#$%"M"*531%"#=7Q<";7Q4=14#*5(=5"(%"<#6>#"*#M%7"4%<#"35"0#"5054=71413#3"M"50"*#G(5=1<*%j"754%(%4>#"0%"<1G/15(=5V

J/5713%"WU%*;<%("vwx"U5"%6=5(13%"*/4U%"35"=1"5("=5*#<"50H4=714%<!"31754=#­*5(=5"#0"1G/#0"T/5"#"=7#KH<"35"0#"1*;75(=#"M"50"531=%7!"M"=#*61H("U5"/=101F#3%"

o  S+"S4U#EE57!"rWU5"]#173"%E";UM<14<s!"5("Nature!"()*. -o,!"89,,!";;+"8nl28l,+n" k5;7%3/413#"5("X+"@Q(%K#<!"op. cit+! ;+",:+

En-Claves14-book.indb 14 04/11/13 14:54

Page 6: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" ,i

%=7#<"#M/3#<!" M" 05>3%" 0%<" =75<" K%0)*5(5<"35" 1(K5<=1G#41L("35"X#7#3#M+"B1"1(=5(41L("#0"U#457"5<=%"57#!"(#=/7#0*5(=5!"<#657" 0%"T/5"<5"U#"U54U%"5(" 0#"415(41#"50H4=714#!"*#=5*Q=14#"M"5C;571*5(=#0!"5"1(=5(=#7"4%*;75(357"5<=%"35"/(#"*#(57#"7#41%(#0!"#M/3Q(3%*5"35"4/#0T/157"(%41L("T/5";/315<5"#=%7(100#7"5("*1"4#65F#+l

Z"5<=%<";7%605*#<"=5L714%<";0#(=5#3%<";%7" 0%<"5C;571*5(=%<"35"X#7#3#M!"Schaffer,9"#$#35"/(#"4174/(<=#(41#" =54(%0LG14#"T/5";#7545"U#657" ./G#3%"/(";#;50"1*;%7=#(=5!"M"5<"T/5"./<=%"5("0%<"#$%<"5("T/5"B#CD500"<5"1(=575<#6#";%7"0%<"5C;571*5(=%<"50H4=714%<"M"*#G(H=14%<"35"X#7#3#M!"0#"@%7%(#"671=Q(14#"5<=#6#"*/M"1(=575<#3#!";%7"*%=1K%<";%0>=14%<!"5("0%G7#7"0#"/(1R4#41L("35"0#<"4%*/(14#­41%(5<"35"=%3%"</"'*;571%!";#7#"0%"4/#0"5<=#6#";0#(5#3%"50"=5(313%"35"4#605<"=505G7QR4%<"1(=57%45Q(14%<+"̂ <=5";7%M54=%"1*;014#6#"6/<4#7"*#(57#<"35"75<%0K57"(/5K%<";7%605*#<!"4%*%"0#";7%;#G#41L("35"0#<"<5$#05<"5054=7%*#G(H=14#<"#"=7#KH<"35"G7#(35<"31<=#(41#<!"0#"4%(R#61013#3"35"0%<"1(<=7/*5(=%<"35"*53141L("M"50"#(Q01<1<"35"0#<"E/57F#<!"75<1<=5(41#<"M"4%7715(=5<"5("4#605<"=5(313%<"5("50"E%(3%"350"%4H#(%+^(",ni:!"X#7#3#M"U#6>#"<13%"=5<=1G%"35"0%<"4#=#<=7LR4%<";7%605*#<"4#/<#3%<"

;%7"50"75=7#<%"5("0#<"<5$#05<"5("0#<"0>(5#<"35"4#605"=5(313#<"5(=75"]%(375<"M"B#(4U5<=57";%7"/(#"4%*;#$>#"35"=50HG7#E%<+"^("/(#"4%(E575(41#"T/5"1*;#7=1L"/(%<"*5<5<"35<;/H<"5(" 0#"k%M#0" '(<=1=/=1%(!,, empleó su propia teoría de  la 1(3/441L("*#G(H=14#";#7#"*%<=7#7" 4L*%"50"#G/#"<#0#3#"#4=/#7>#"350"*1<*%"*%3%"T/5"0#"4/6157=#"5C=571%7"35"/("4%(35(<#3%7"<%675"0%<"4#605<"</6*#71(%<!"1(475*5(=#(3%"</"4#;#41=#(41#!"31<*1(/M5(3%"0#"1(3/441L("M!";%7"4%(<1G/15(=5!"75=7#<#(3%"0#<"<5$#05<"=%3#K>#"*Q<+B#CD500"M"WU%*;<%(";75<=#7%("*/4U#"#=5(41L("#"5<=#"4%(E575(41#"35"X#­

7#3#M"M"#"</<"1*;014#41%(5<";#7#"0#"=505G7#E>#"</6*#71(#+"Z;5(#<"/(%<"*5<5<"35<;/H<!"WU%*;<%(" M#" U#6>#" 35<#77%00#3%"/(#" EL7*/0#" T/5" 750#41%(#6#"50"75=7#<%"5("0#<"<5$#05<"4%("0#"0%(G1=/3"35"0%<"4#605<!"0#"4/#0"75</0=#6#"35"G7#("K#0%7"54%(L*14%";#7#"0%<"1(K57<1%(1<=#<"350"(/5K%"M"#*6141%<%";7%M54=%"35"/(17"e7#("_75=#$#"4%("a%7=5#*H714#"*531#(=5"50"=5(313%"35"/(#"0>(5#"35"i"999"A*+"a%"5<"4#</#0"T/5!";#7#",nim"WU%*;<%("M#"<5"U#6>#"4%(K57=13%"5("31754=1K%"35"/(#"35"0#<";71(41;#05<"4%*;#$>#<"35"=5(313%"35"4#605<"=7#(<#=0Q(=14%<"M"5("/(#"#/=%713#3"754%(%413#"5("<1<=5*#<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<"tM"5("0%<"#$%<"<1G/15(=5<"<5"U#7>#"*100%(#71%"4%("0%"T/5"G#(#7>#"5(";#=5(=5<"M"5("4%(</0=%7>#<"=505G7QR4#<u+

l  h+"B+"p#7*#(!"53+!"8/'+:!%'#3%2!+5'33'($+)#&+A)@'($+"9+B)0'$+C.'(D+E)FG'..!"K%0+"I"t,n-m2,nm8u+"@#*6713G5!"@#*6713G5"`(1K57<1=M"h75<<!",ll9!";+":,l+

,9  S+"S4U#EE57!"op. cit+!";;+"8nl28l,+,,  Ibid.!";+"8l9+

En-Claves14-book.indb 15 04/11/13 14:54

Page 7: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

,m" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

B15(=7#<"5<=%"%4/77>#!"5(",nim!";%4%"35<;/H<"35" 0#"*/57=5"35"</";#375!"B#CD500"<5"U#6>#"4%(K57=13%"5(";7%E5<%7"35"R0%<%E>#"(#=/7#0" t50"(%*675"T/5"<5"05"3#6#"#"0#"415(41#"U#<=#"R(#05<"350"<1G0%"XIXu ,8 en el Marischal College de Z657355(!"M"5<=#6#"=7#6#.#(3%"5("50"*%350%"35"X#7#3#M"35"0#"1(3/441L("5054­=7%*#G(H=14#+"\%<"#$%<"*Q<"=#735"<5"4#<L"4%("g#=U571(5"B#7M"\5D#7!"U1.#"350"31754=%7"350"B#71<4U#0"@%005G5+B#CD500";5(<#6#"T/5"57#"(545<#71#"/(#"=5%7>#"*#=5*Q=14#"T/5"/(1R4#7#"0#"

#441L("35"0#"5054=71413#3"5<=Q=14#!"0#"#=7#441L("#*;571#(#!"0#<"4%7715(=5<";57*#­(5(=5<"M"0#"1(3/441L("5054=7%*#G(H=14#+"@%("5<=5"%6.5=1K%"5("*5(=5!"4%*5(FL"#"pensar en el electromagnetismo como algo dependiente de un medio de trans­

*1<1L("N/13%!"4%*%"50"H=57!,:"%"/("4#*;%!"4/M%"5<=7H<"M"=5(<1L("E/57#"4#;#F"35"#0*#45(#7"5(57G>#"M"35"=7#(<*1=17"</"#441L("#"/(#"K50%413#3"R(1=#+"S/";71*57"#7=>4/0%"#0"75<;54=%!";/6014#3%"5(",nii!"E/5"ry("X#7#3#Mf<"]1(5<"%E"X%745s+"Z";#7=17"35"5<=5";71*57"#7=>4/0%"<%675"50"=5*#"05"=%*L"#"B#CD500"41(4%"#$%<"35"#73/%"=7#6#.%"0%G7#7"T/5"</"*%350%"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"M"</<"54/#41%(5<"E/57#("4%(<1<=5(=5<"4%("0%"T/5"U#<=#"5<5"*%*5(=%"<5"<#6>#"35"5<=5"E5(L*5­(%!";71*57%"5("0#"7541H("1(<=1=/13#"`(1K57<13#3"35"Z657355(!"M"35<;/H<"5("50"g1(Gf<"@%005G5"35"]%(375<!"5("3%(35"%6=/K%"50";/5<=%"35";7%E5<%7"35"R0%<%E>#"(#=/7#0"5(",nm9+"^0"75</0=#3%"35"5<=5"5<E/57F%"E/5"On Physical Lines of Force!";/6014#3%"5(",nm,+S4U#EE57"U#"U54U%"(%=#7"T/5!"#"31E575(41#"35"</<"4%(=5*;%7Q(5%<"5("X7#(­

41#"M"Z05*#(1#!" 0%<"R0L<%E%<"(#=/7#05<"671=Q(14%<"57#("53/4#3%<";#7#";5(<#7"5("=H7*1(%<"*54Q(14%<"<%675"0#"E><14#!"4%(";%05#<!"6%*6#<"M"01G#<!"M"35<;/H<"5C=7#;%0#7"5<=#"*#(57#"35";5(<#7"#0"̀ (1K57<%+"z<=5"E/5"50"5(E%T/5"T/5"#;75(31L"B#CD500"*15(=7#<"5<=/K%"5("@#*6713G5"M"E/5!";%7"500%!"50"T/5"5*;05L"5("</<"#7=>4/0%<"35",nii"M",nm,+S1("5*6#7G%!"M"#";5<#7"35"<#657"T/5"B#CD500"E/5"53/4#3%"5("@#*6713G5"

;#7#";5(<#7"5("0#"E><14#"6#.%"50"5(E%T/5"35"0#"*54Q(14#"40Q<14#"35"a5D=%(!"#";71*57#"K1<=#";/535";#75457"5C=7#$%"T/5";5(<#7#"T/5"%6=5(37>#"#0G)("75</0=#3%"(%K53%<%"/=101F#(3%"/("*%350%"*54Q(14%";#7#"/("E5(L*5(%"(%"*54Q(14%"4%*%"50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%+"a%"%6<=#(=5!"H<#"57#";7541<#*5(=5"</"1(=5(41L(V"#"0%"0#7G%"

,8" ^0"=H7*1(%"rR0%<%E>#"(#=/7#0s"(%"E/5"</<=1=/13%";%7"0#";#0#67#"r415(41#s"U#<=#"T/5"0%";7%;/<%"Y1001#*"YU5D500"top. cit+!",n:ou";57%"#)("#<>"50"(/5K%"=H7*1(%"=#73L"5("35<;0#F#7"#0"#(=571%7!"T/5"U#6>#"<13%"5*;05#3%"35<35"0%<"=15*;%<"35"'<##4"a5D=%("M"0#"k5K%0/41L("415(=>R4#+

,:" ^0";5(<#7"T/5"5C1<=>#"/("*531%"{50"00#*#3%"rH=57s{"T/5";57*1=>#"0#"=7#(<*1<1L("=#(=%"35"0#"0/F"t50"éter luminíferou"4%*%"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"t;%<1605*5(=5"*531#(=5"/("<5G/(3%"=1;%"35"H=57u!"E/5"#0G%"4%*)(*5(=5"#45;=#3%";%7"0#"*#M%7>#"35"0%<"415(=>R4%<"U#<=#",l9i!"4/#(3%"̂ 1(<=51("35*%<=7L"4%("</"#7=>4/0%"<%675"50"5E54=%"E%=%50H4=714%"T/5!"<1"</;%(5*%<"T/5"0#"0/F"5<=Q"E%7*#3#";%7"4/#(=%<!"5(=%(45<"75</0=#"=%=#0*5(=5"1((545<#71%"1(K%4#7"0#"5C1<=5(41#"350"H=57"%"35"4/#0T/157"%=7%"*531%"35"=7#(<*1<1L(+

En-Claves14-book.indb 16 04/11/13 14:54

Page 8: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" ,o

35"5<=%<"3%<"=7#6#.%<"B#CD500"5*;05#"50"r*H=%3%"35"#(#0%G>#<s!"1(<;17#3%"5(";#7=5";%7"0#"#(#0%G>#"T/5"WU%*;<%("U#6>#"5<=#605413%"5(=75"50"4#0%7"M"0#"5054­=71413#3+,-"B#CD500"4%*;75(3>#"T/5"0#<"#(#0%G>#<"5(=75"E5(L*5(%<"05";57*1=>#("/(#"G7#("N5C161013#3!"1(40/<%"<1";7%3/4>#("=5%7>#<";%4%"K57%<>*105<";57%"T/5"05"671(3#6#("<1<=5*#<"*#=5*Q=14%<"*/M"40#71R4#3%75<"#0"#;014#70%<"#"0%<"E5(L*5(%<"T/5"=7#=#6#"35"5<=/31#7!"#0"*1<*%"=15*;%"T/5"(%"0%"#=#6#("#"0#<"5C;014#41%(5<"35"/(#"=5%7>#"M#"5C1<=5(=5+,i"h%7"0%"=#(=%!"(%"5<"T/5"B#CD500"r;5(<#7#s"T/5"50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"E/57#"/("E5(L*5(%"*54Q(14%!"<1(%"T/5"al hacerlo parecer, mediante analogías, como un fenómeno mecánico";%3>#("35<4/6717<5";71(41;1%<"*#=5*Q=14%<"T/5";57*1=157#("4%*;75(3570%"*5.%7+

Sobre las líneas de fuerza de Faraday

B#CD500"<5"U#6>#"4%(K5(413%"35"T/5"0#"(%41L("35"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"*#G(H=14#"35"X#7#3#M,m"5C;014#6#"*5.%7"50"*#G(5=1<*%"T/5"0#"4%(45;41L("35"45(=7%<"35"E/57F#!"#/(T/5"5("5<=#";75E575(41#"<L0%"4%1(413>#("X#7#3#M!"WU%*;<%("M"H0"*1<*%+"]#"G7#("*#M%7>#"35"0%<"E><14%<"35"0#"H;%4#!"1(N/13%<";%7"0#"5(<5$#(F#"35"0#"*54Q(14#"40Q<14#"5("0#<"/(1K57<13#35<"M!"4%(475=#*5(=5!";%7"50"*%3%"5("T/5"a5D=%("U#6>#"#(#01F#3%"0#"G7#K53#3!";75E57>#";5(<#7"5("0#"#=7#441L("*#G(H=14#"4%*%"/(#" E/57F#"T/5"<5"4%(45(=7#6#"5("/(";/(=%!"5("50"45(=7%"350"*#=571#0"*#G(H=14%!"M"T/5"#4=/#6#"#"31<=#(41#"<%675"%=7%<"*#=571#05<+"h#7#"5<=%<"E><14%<!";%7"=#(=%!"50"E5(L*5(%";71*#71%"#"5<=/31#7"57#"0#"(#=/7#05F#"35"5<=%<"45(=7%<"35"E/57F#+"X#7#3#M!";%7"50"4%(=7#71%!";7%;%(>#"T/5"50"*#G(5=1<*%"#4=/#6#"*531#(=5"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"T/5"4/67>#("0#"31<=#(41#"5(=75"#*6%<"*#=571#05<!"M"T/5"0#"31<=716/41L("35"5<=#<"E/57F#<"5("50"5<;#41%"57#"50"E5(L*5(%";71*#71%!"M"(%"0#"(#=/7#05F#"35"0%<"45(=7%<"#075353%7"35"0%<"4/#05<"5<=#<"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"<5"#G7/;#6#(+,o

,-  S5G)("#3*1=5"H0"*1<*%!"KH#<5"?+"@+"B#CD500!"ry("X#7#3#Mf<"]1(5<"%E"X%745s!"5("Transactions of the Cambridge Philosophical Society!"()*+",9!",nim!";+",io+

,i" &H#<5"0#"5C;014#41L("T/5"U#45"35"</"*H=%3%"50";7%;1%"B#CD500"tibid+!";;+",ii2,imu+,m  El concepto de líneas de fuerza magnética!"%"<1*;05*5(=5"líneas de fuerza!"E/5";7%;/5<=%";%7"

X#7#3#M"5(",n:lV"rh%7"4/7K#<"*#G(H=14#<"T/157%"35417"0#<"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"*#G(H=14#"T/5!"#/(T/5"5<=H("*%31R4#3#<";%7"0#"M/C=#;%<141L("35";%0%<!"<5"*#(1R5<=#("*531#(=5"01*#3/7#<"35"U1577%|"%"#T/500#<"4%("0#<"T/5"/(#"#G/.#"*#G(H=14#!"*/M";5T/5$#!"E%7*#7>#"/(#"=#(G5(=5s"+

,o" &H#<5"50"rk5</*5(s"U54U%";%7"50";7%;1%"B#CD500"<%675"</"ry("X#7#3#Mf<"]1(5<"%E"X%745s!"M"T/5!"#/(T/5"(%"005GL"#";/6014#7<5!"#;#7545"75;7%3/413%"5("p#7*#(!"op. cit.!";+":i:"M"5("?+"B+"SQ(4U5F"k%(!"rB#CD500!"</"K13#"M"</"%67#s!"5("?+"@+"B#CD500!"Materia y movimiento+"_#7450%(#!"@7>=14#!"899m!";+"-i+

En-Claves14-book.indb 17 04/11/13 14:54

Page 9: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

,n" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

h#7#" 5<=/31#7" 35"*#(57#" =5L714#" 5<=5" E5(L*5(%!"B#CD500" 5<47161L" ry("X#7#3#M}<"]1(5<"%E"X%745s!"T/5"<5";/6014L"5(",nim,n en los Transactions of the Cambridge Philosophical Society+"^0"%6.5=1K%"35"B#CD500"5("5<=5"#7=>4/0%"57#"35<#77%00#7"0#<"135#<"35"X#7#3#M"35(=7%"35"/(#"=5%7>#"*#=5*Q=14#"350"5054=7%­*#G(5=1<*%+"h#7#"500%!"5*;05L"/("5(E%T/5"4%*;05=#*5(=5"31<=1(=%"#"0%<"T/5"<5"4%(%4>#("5("</"H;%4#+"̀ =101FL"j4%*%"U#4>#"WU%*;<%(j"/(#"1(=57;75=#41L("35"0%<"E5(L*5(%<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<"5("E/(41L("35"0#"5C1<=5(41#"35"/("*531%"4%*%"50"H=57!"0%"4/#0"05";57*1=>#"/=101F#7"*%350%<"*#=5*Q=14%<"5("0%<"T/5";%3>#"#;014#7"0#<"05M5<"35"a5D=%(+"^("5<=5"#<;54=%!"</"1(=57;75=#41L("57#"31<=1(=#"#"0#"35"X#7#3#M"jT/5"(%"#;50#6#"#0"H=57j!";57%";5(<#6#"T/5"57#";75E571605+h#7#"#(#01F#7"0%<"E5(L*5(%<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<!"B#CD500"5*;05L"/(#"<5715"

35"#(#0%G>#<"10/<=7#=1K#<+"^<"35417!"5<=#60541L";#75413%<"M"=7#6#.L"<%675"500%<";#7#"K1</#01F#7"35"*5.%7"*#(57#"0%<"E5(L*5(%<"T/5"35<4716>#!"#/(T/5"(%";75­=5(3>#"3571K#7"/(#"=5%7>#"(/5K#"#";#7=17"35"5<=#<"#(#0%G>#<!"M#"T/5"=#*;%4%";75=5(3>#"T/5"H<=#<"E/57#("E><14#*5(=5"K573#357#<+"@%(475=#*5(=5!"#0"5*;05#7"0#"#(#0%G>#"T/5"M#"U#6>#"U54U%"WU%*;<%("5(=75"5054=71413#3"M"N/.%"4#0%7>R4%!"B#CD500"5<=#6#"4%(<415(=5"35"T/5"r(%"3565*%<"4%(40/17"35"0#"<1*101=/3";#741#0"35"#0G/(#<"35"0#<"750#41%(5<"35"0%<"E5(L*5(%<"350"4#0%7"M"0#"5054=71413#3"T/5"5C1<=5"/(#"<1*101=/3"75#0"5(=75"0#<"4#/<#<"35"#*6%<"E5(L*5(%<+"]#"<1*101=/3"5<"5(=75"750#41%(5<!"(%"5(=75"0#<"4%<#<"750#41%(#3#<s+,lh57%!"#/(T/5"0#<"#(#0%G>#<"57#("<L0%"10/<=7#=1K#<!"./G#7%("/(";#;50"E/(3#­

*5(=#0"5("5<=5"#7=>4/0%+"h#7#"4%*;75(357"0#"U5/7><=14#"350"*H=%3%"#(#0LG14%"35"B#CD500"75K1<5*%<"#0G/(#<"35"0#<";71(41;#05<+&5#*%<!"5(";71*57"0/G#7!"</"#(#0%G>#"*54Q(14#";#7#"0#<"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#+"

B#CD500"(%<"5C;014#"T/5!"<1"005(#*%<"35"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"50"5<;#41%"T/5"7%35#"/("1*Q(!"4%*%"U1F%"X#7#3#M!"r%6=5(37>#*%<"/("*%350%"G5%*H=714%"35"0%<"E5(L­*5(%<"E><14%<"T/5"(%<"1(314#7>#("0#"3175441L("35"0#"E/57F#!";57%"(%"</"1(=5(<13#3"5("4/#0T/157";/(=%!";#7#"0%"4/#0"(545<1=#7>#*%<"35"%=7%"*H=%3%s+"]#"<%0/41L("T/5"<5"05"%4/771L"#"B#CD500"E/5"r4%(<1357#7"5<=#<"4/7K#<"(%"4%*%"<1*;05<"0>(5#<!"<1(%"4%*%"R(%<"=/6%<"35"<5441L("K#71#605"T/5"=7#(<;%7=#("/("N/13%"1(4%*;75<1605s+"^("4/#0T/157";/(=%"350"4#*;%"*#G(H=14%!"0#"*#G(1=/3"M"0#"3175441L("35"0#"E/57F#"5<=#7>#"5(=%(45<"75;75<5(=#3#";%7"0#"3175441L("M"*#G(1=/3"350"N/13%"1*#G1(#71%!"4%(=5(13%"35(=7%"35"=/6%<"35"31<=1(=%"31Q*5=7%+

,n" ]#" ;71*57#" ;#7=5" 35" 5<=5" #7=>4/0%" E/5" 05>3#" ;%7"B#CD500" #(=5" 0#"S%4153#3"X10%<LR4#"35"@#*6713G5"50",9"35"31415*675"35",nii!"M"0#"<5G/(3#"50",,"35"E56757%"35",nim+

,l" ^<=5"4%*5(=#71%" 0%"U1F%"*/4U%"35<;/H<!"5("?+"@+"B#CD500!"A Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism+"]%(375<!"@0#75(3%("h75<<!",no:!";57%"75R71H(3%<5"#"0#"*1<*#"#(#0%G>#"35"WU%*;<%("T/5!"5("5E54=%!"=/K%"5("*5(=5"#0"5<471617"ry("X#7#3#Mf<"]1(5<"%E"X%745s+

En-Claves14-book.indb 18 04/11/13 14:54

Page 10: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" ,l

k5K1<5*%<"#U%7#"</"#(#0%G>#"*54Q(14#"35"0#"5054=71413#3+"]#"4#7G#";%<1=1K#"<5"4%(<1357#"4%*%"/(#"E/5(=5"35"N/13%!"4/M#"4#(=13#3"35;5(35"35"</"1(=5(­<13#3+"]#"4#7G#"(5G#=1K#"<57>#"/("sumidero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r</45315(3%"*54Q(14#*5(=5s"5("</"</;/5<=%!"<1("1*;%7=#7"5("5<=5"*%*5(=%"<1"5<#<";7%;153#35<"57#("/("=#(=%"5C=7#$#<+^("/(#"=57457#"#(#0%G>#!"B#CD500"#(#01FL"0#"#441L("35"0%<"3150H4=714%<89 supo­

(15(3%"T/5"50"N/13%"tT/5"(%";%<55"1(5741#u"N/>#"#"=7#KH<"35"/("*531%"75<1<=5(=5"T/5"5.574>#"<%675"H<=5"/(#"E/57F#";7%;%741%(#0"#"</"K50%413#3+"\5"5<=5"*%3%!"K#71#(3%"0#"75<1<=5(41#"350"*531%";%7"50"T/5"31<4/77>#"50"N/13%!"%6=/K%"/(#"#(#­0%G>#"*54Q(14#"35" 0#"#441L("35" 0%<"*#=571#05<"3150H4=714%<"M"31#*#G(H=14%<V8, 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

(%"<L0%"10/<=7#7"<1(%"4%*;75(357"*5.%7"0#<";7%;153#35<"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%!"

89" `("3150H4=714%"5<"/("*#=571#0"T/5"5<"/("*#0"4%(3/4=%7"35"0#"5054=71413#3";57%"T/5!"#"31E575(41#"35"0%<"*#=571#05<"#1<0#(=5<!";%<55"0#";7%;153#3"35"T/5"#0"<57"<%*5=13%"#"/("4#*;%"50H4=714%"5C=57(%";/535"5<=#605457<5"5("H0"/("4#*;%"50H4=714%"1(=57(%+"̂ 0"=H7*1(%"E/5"4%(45613%";%7"Y1001#*"YU5D500"5("75<;/5<=#"#"/(#";5=141L("35"X#7#3#M+

8,  El diamagnetismo es una propiedad de algunos materiales que consiste en ser repelidos por 

/("1*Q("t5<!";%7"0%"=#(=%!"0#";7%;153#3"%;/5<=#"#"<57"#=7#>3%";%7"/("1*Q(u+"]#"35<4/671L"X#7#3#M"5(",n-i!"#0"%6<57K#7"T/5"/("=7%F%"35"61<*/=%"57#"75;5013%";%7"#*6%<";%0%<"35"/("1*Q("t0%"T/5"</G57>#"T/5"50"4#*;%"*#G(H=14%"350"1*Q("5<=#6#"G5(57#(3%"/("4#*;%"*#G(H=14%"5("50"61<*/=%!";57%"35"<5(=13%"%;/5<=%u+

En-Claves14-book.indb 19 04/11/13 14:54

Page 11: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

89" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

M"5*;05#(3%"/(#"*54Q(14#"(5D=%(1#(#";#7#"75;75<5(=#7" 0%"T/5"%4/77>#"t<1("importar si físicamente sucedía realmente"35"5<5"*%3%u!";/3%"(%"<L0%"3571K#7"(/5K%<"#<;54=%<"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%!"<1(%"=7#<0#3#7"*Q<"#350#(=5"</"4%*­;%7=#*15(=%"#"/(" 05(G/#.5"*#=5*Q=14%+"^<=%")0=1*%" 0%" 75#01FL"5(" 0#"<5G/(3#";#7=5"350"#7=>4/0%!"5("0#"<5441L("=1=/0#3#"ry("X#7#3#Mf<"5054=7%=%(14"<=#=5s+"^("5<=#"<5441L("B#CD500"35<#77%00L"0#";71*57#"K57<1L("350"<1<=5*#"35"54/#41%(5<"T/5"35<47165("0#<"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"50H4=714#<"M"*#G(H=14#<"M"T/5!"#$%<"35<;/H<"M"4%("*/4U#<"=7#(<E%7*#41%(5<!"3571K#7>#"5("</<"E#*%<#<"54/#41%(5<"<%675"50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%+"^("5<=#"K57<1L(!"<1("5*6#7G%!"B#CD500"=%3#K>#"(%"U#6>#"35<#77%00#3%" 50" 4%(45;=%" 35" r35<;0#F#*15(=%" 50H4=714%s!" 4/M#" 3571K#3#" 4%("75<;54=%"#0"=15*;%"4%(<=1=/M5"0#"r4%7715(=5"35"35<;0#F#*15(=%s!"/("4%(45;=%"#0"T/5"005G#7>#"5("0%<"<1G/15(=5<"#$%<+

Sobre las líneas físicas de fuerza

B#CD500"=5(>#"<L0%"8l"#$%<"4/#(3%"#;#7541L";/6014#3#"0#";71*57#";#7=5"35"On Physical Lines of Force!"5("*#7F%"35",nm,!";%7"The London, Edinburgh and ;-H.%#+A/%."$"@/%!).+E)1)I%#'+)#&+B"-(#).+"9+:!%'#!'788 Este artículo represen­=L!"4%("=%3#";7%6#61013#3!"50";#<%"*Q<"1*;%7=#(=5"5("0#"/(1R4#41L("=5L714#"T/5"0%G7#7>#"3/7#(=5"0%<"<1G/15(=5<"#$%<+"S1("5*6#7G%!"5("H0"(%"#;#7545"=%3#K>#"</"4%(45;=%"35"%(3#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#!"<1(%"T/5"j4%*%";%35*%<"%6<57K#7"5("0#"RG/7#",j"B#CD500"<1G/5";5(<#(3%"5("0#<"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"35"X#7#3#M"*Q<"615("5("E/(41L("35"/(#"<5715"35"5(G7#(#.5<"T/5"G17#6#("M"35"7/53#<"M"5<E57#<"T/5"=7#(<*1=>#("0#"#441L("35"0#"E/57F#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#+

88" ]#";71*57#";#7=5"<5";/6014L"5("50"()*57%"35"*#7F%"35",nm,!"0#"<5G/(3#"5("50"35"#6710"350"*1<*%"#$%!"0#"=57457#"U#<=#"5(57%"35",nm8!"M"/(#"4/#7=#"M")0=1*#";#7=5"#0"*5<"<1G/15(=5+"]#"31E575(41#"5("=15*;%<"5(=75"0#";71*57#"M"0#"=57457#";#7=5<"75</0=#7Q"7505K#(=5"5("</"4%(=5(13%"M"5("5<=#"U1<=%71#!"4%*%"5C;014#75*%<"*Q<"#350#(=5"5("50"=5C=%+

En-Claves14-book.indb 20 04/11/13 14:54

Page 12: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" 8,

X1G/7#",+"'0/<=7#41L("%71G1(#0"35"B#CD500"5("On Physical Lines of Force!";#7=5"II+

`(#"35" 0#<";71(41;#05<" 01*1=#41%(5<"T/5"U#6>#("#E54=#3%"#"ry("X#7#3#Mf<"]1(5<"%E"X%745s"57#"</"1(4#;#413#3"35"=7#=#7"0#<"4%(5C1%(5<"5(=75"0%<"4#*;%<"50H4=714%<!"4#*;%<"*#G(H=14%<"M"4%7715(=5<"50H4=714#<+"h#7#"</;57#7"5<=5";7%­605*#!"5("5<=#"%4#<1L("B#CD500"354131L"35.#7"35"0#3%"0#<"#(#0%G>#<"10/<=7#=1K#<!"M"35<#77%00#7"/("*%350%"*54Q(14%"35"5<=%<"E5(L*5(%<"T/5"E/57#"=5L714#*5(=5"K1#605"M"T/5"05";57*1=157#"5<=#605457"0#<"4%(5C1%(5<";5(315(=5<+"̂ ("5<=5"<5(=13%!"U#M"/(#"31E575(41#"E/(3#*5(=#0"5(=75"0#<"#(#0%G>#<"5*;05#3#<"5("ry("X#7#3#Mf<"]1(5<"%E"X%745s"M"0#<"(/5K#<"#(#0%G>#<"*54Q(14#<"T/5"B#CD500"K#"#"/=101F#7"5("On Physical Lines of Force+"^("50";71*57"4#<%!"<5"U#6>#"=7#=#3%")(14#*5(=5"35"#(#0%G>#<"10/<=7#=1K#<+"ZU%7#!"4%("</<"1(475>605<"*%350%<"*54Q(14%<!"B#CD500"U#"3541313%"4%(<=7/17!"*531#(=5"#(#0%G>#<!"*%350%<"T/5"356>#("4%(<1357#7<5"4%*%"4#(313#=%<"#"/(#"r=5%7>#"K573#357#s+"P"5<=#6#"4%(<415(=5"35"T/5"=#*61H(";%3>#("75</0=#7"E#0<%<w";57%"U#6>#("<13%"31<5$#3%<";#7#"T/5"=/K157#("0#";%<1­61013#3"35"75</0=#7"K573#357%<!"#0"*5(%<"5("50"<5(=13%"35"35<471617"0#"#/=H(=14#"75#013#3"E><14#+"h%7"4%(<1G/15(=5!"M"4%*%"U#"<5$#0#3%"#354/#3#*5(=5"SQ(4U5F"k%(!8:"50"5<=#=/<"%(=%0LG14%"35"#*6%<"#7=>4/0%<"5<"*/M"31E575(=5+B#CD500"5C;014#"</"%6.5=1K%"M"0#"7#FL("350"5*;05%"35"</"*H=%3%"#(#0LG14%"

del modo siguiente:

8:" ?+"B+"SQ(4U5F"k%(!"rB#CD500!"</"K13#""</"%67#s!"5("op. cit.!";+"-l+

En-Claves14-book.indb 21 04/11/13 14:54

Page 13: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

88" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

B1"%6.5=1K%"5("5<=5"#7=>4/0%"5<"40#71R4#7"50"4#*1(%"vwx"1(K5<=1G#(3%"0%<"75</0­=#3%<"*54Q(14%<"35"4157=%<"5<=#3%<"35"=5(<1L("M"*%K1*15(=%"5("/("*531%!"M"4%*;#7Q(3%0%<"4%("0%<"E5(L*5(%<"%6<57K#3%<"350"*#G(5=1<*%"M"0#"5054=7141­3#3+"Z0"<5$#0#7"0#<"4%(<54/5(41#<"*54Q(14#<"35"5<=#<"U1;L=5<1<!"5<;57%"<57"35"#0G/(#"/=1013#3"#"#T/500%<"T/5"4%(<1357#("5<=%<"E5(L*5(%<"4%*%"35613%<"#"0#"#441L("35"/("*531%!";57%"T/5"3/3#("35"0#"750#41L("35"5<=#"U1;L=5<1<"4%("0#<"05M5<"5C;571*5(=#05<"M#"5<=#605413#<!"0#<"4/#05<"U#("<13%"G5(57#0*5(=5"5C;75<#3#<"5*;05#(3%"%=7%"=1;%"35"U1;L=5<1<+8-

Z0"1G/#0"T/5"WU%*;<%(!"B#CD500"475>#"T/5"50"4#*;%"5054=7%*#G(H=14%"5<­=#6#"realmente"4%(<=1=/13%";%7"/("H=57"</6%731(#3%"#"0#<"05M5<"35"0#"*54Q(14#"(5D=%(1#(#+8i"h%7"0%"=#(=%!"356>#"=5(57"/("*54#(1<*%"M"H<=5"57#"</<45;=1605"35"<57"35<4/6157=%+"h#7#"50"*%*5(=%"35"0#";/6014#41L("35"5<=5"(/5K%"#7=>4/0%!"B#CD500"K5>#"0#<"#(#0%G>#<"*54Q(14#<"T/5"U#6>#"5*;05#3%"5("</"#7=>4/0%"#(=5­71%7"4%*%"1(</R415(=5<!"M"05";#754>#"T/5"<1"615("05"U#6>#("<57K13%";#7#"10/<=7#7"M"5(=5(357"*5.%7"0#<"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"35"X#7#3#M!"(%";7%;%741%(#6#("/(#"=5%7>#"G5(57#0"35"0%<"E5(L*5(%<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<+"h%7"4%(<1G/15(=5!"</"(/5K#"*5=#"57#"755C#*1(#7"5<=%<"E5(L*5(%<"6#.%"/(";/(=%"35"K1<=#"*54Q(14%!";57%"#U%7#"5(E%4Q(3%<5"5("T/H"E/57F#<"%"*%K1*15(=%<"5("50"H=57"tT/5"<57K>#"35"*531%"35"=7#(<*1<1L(u";%3>#("3#7"4/5(=#"35" 0%<" E5(L*5(%<"%6<57K#3%<!"5(";#7=14/0#7"35"0%<"4#*;%<"*#G(H=14%<+"P!"35"<57";%<1605!"6/<4#7>#"0#"*#(57#"35"T/5"5<=5"*%350%"*54Q(14%"05"#M/3#7#"#"4%(54=#7"50"E5(L*5(%"35"0#"#=7#441L("*#G(H=14#"4%("0%<"E5(L*5(%<"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%!"35"0#<"4%7715(=5<"1(3/413#<"M"4%("50"35"0#"0/F!"5("/(#"<%0#"=5%7>#"/(1R4#3%7#+8mZ0"4%*5(F#7"#"35<#77%00#7"</"*%350%"*54Q(14%";#7#"5C;014#7"50"4#*;%"35"

4#7G#!"B#CD500"j#0";#75457j"(%"=5(>#"135#"35"T/H"54/#41%(5<"16#"#"5(4%(=7#7!"(1"<1"<57>#"4#;#F"35"35<#77%00#7"/(#"=5%7>#"/(1R4#3%7#+"h57%"5<=#6#"4%*;05=#­*5(=5"<5G/7%!"#0"*5(%<!"35"3%<"4%<#<V"35"0#<"=75<"05M5<"35"0#"*54Q(14#"35"a5D=%("M"35"T/5"0#"5C;014#41L("=5(>#"T/5";#<#7";%7"/(#"=5%7>#"35"4#*;%<+"S/"E5"5("#*6#<"4%<#<"05"671(3L"/(";7%G7#*#";#75413%"#0"35"WU%*;<%(V"5C;014#7"=%3%"5("=H7*1(%<"35"/("H=57"</;531=#3%"#"0#<"05M5<"35"a5D=%(+B#CD500"<#6>#!"(#=/7#0*5(=5!"T/5"=%3#"=5%7>#"4%7754=#" =15(5"T/5"<57"4%(­

<1<=5(=5"4%("0%<"U54U%<"5C;571*5(=#05<!"M"=#*61H("<%<;54U#6#"T/5"0#"=5%7>#"4%7754=#"356>#";#75457"5C=7#$#!";/5<=%"T/5"(1(G)("1(=5(=%"7#41%(#0";75K1%"U#­6>#"3#3%"4%("0#"=5%7>#"#354/#3#+"\5"*%3%"T/5"<5";57*1=1L"#"<>"*1<*%";7%6#7"

8-  ?+" @+"B#CD500!" ry("hUM<14#0" ]1(5<" %E" X%745s!" 5("8/'+ 5"#&"#J+ =&%#H-(1/+ )#&+;-H.%#+Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science!"()*+"8,!",nm,!";;+",m,2,oi!"8n,28l,!"::n2:-i|"M"()*+"8:!";;+",828-!"ni2li+"t^<=#"41=#";57=5(545"#"0#";#7=5"I!";+",m8+u

8i  X+"@Q(%K#<!"op. cit+!"4#;+"8+8m  ?+"@+"B#CD500!"ry("hU<14#0"]1(5<"%E"X%745s!"5("op. cit.!";#7=5"I!";+",m8+

En-Claves14-book.indb 22 04/11/13 14:54

Page 14: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" 8:

4/#0T/157"U1;L=5<1<"T/5"E/57#"4%(<1<=5(=5"4%("</<"3%<";75*1<#<"t0#"*54Q(14#"35"a5D=%("M"0#"5C1<=5(41#"35"4#*;%<u+"B#CD500";5(<#6#"T/5!"#/(T/5"(%"3157#"4%("</<"#(#0%G>#<"4%("50"*54#(1<*%"4%7754=%!";%3>#"5(4%(=7#7"/(%"T/5"E/57#"0%"</R415(=5*5(=5";#75413%"#0"K573#357%"4%*%";#7#";%<557"#0G/(#<";7%;153#35<"5("4%*)(+"h%7"5<=#"7#FL(!"M"/(15(3%"</"1*#G1(#41L("#"</"E#41013#3"*#=5*Q=14#!"<5"=%*L"0#"01657=#3"35"1*#G1(#7"*54#(1<*%<"1*;%<1605<"M"35<4#6500#3%<"T/5!"<1("5*6#7G%!";/3157#(";%<557"#0G/(#<";7%;153#35<"4%7754=#<!"#(Q0%G#<"#"0#<"350"*54#(1<*%"K573#357%!"4/#0T/157#"T/5"H<=5"E/57#+Z0" ;#75457!"B#CD500" =#*;%4%" 5<=#6#" <#=1<E54U%" 4%(" </<" 54/#41%(5<" 35"

,nim+"h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p#6>#!"#35*Q<!"/(#"7#FL(";%357%<#";#7#"47557"T/5"50"H=57";%<5>#"5<=#<";7%;153#35<V"0#"K50%413#3"R(1=#"35"0#"0/F+"P"<1"615("H<=#"<5"=7#(<*1=>#";%7"medio de un éter luminífero!"T/5"(%"(545<#71#*5(=5"5<=#6#"750#41%(#3%"4%("50"4#*;%"5054=7%*#G(H=14%!"#"B#CD500"05"4%<=#6#"=7#6#.%"47557"5("0#"5C1<=5(41#"35"3%<"H=575<"</;57;/5<=%<!"/(%";#7#"0#"0/F"M"%=7%";#7#"50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%+"X1(#0*5(=5!"5<=#6#"50"35<4/671*15(=%"35"X#7#3#M"35"0#"7%=#41L("*#G(H=14#"35"0#"0/F";%0#71F#3#!"T/5"35*%<=7#6#"0#"5C1<=5(41#"35"/(#"750#41L("5(=75"0#"0/F"M"50"*#G(5=1<*%+"h%7"0%"=#(=%!"0%"(#=/7#0"57#"#<1G(#7"#"/("*1<*%"H=57"0%<"5E54=%<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<"M"0%<"0/*1(%<%<+"P"<1"5<=5"H=57";7%3/4>#"/(#"K50%413#3"R(1=#";#7#"0#"0/F!"356>#";%7"=#(=%"%4#<1%(#7"/(#"K50%413#3"=#*61H("R(1=#";#7#"0#"1(­3/441L("5054=7%*#G(H=14#+^0";7%605*#"35"B#CD500"57#"3#7"4%("/("*%350%"350"H=57"350"4#*;%"5054=7%­

*#G(H=14%"T/5"1(4%7;%7#7#"0#"*#<#"M"50#<=1413#3"(545<#71#";#7#"0#"K50%413#3"R(1=#"M"005G#7!"35"<57";%<1605!"#"E%7*/0#7"/(#"=5%7>#"T/5";/3157#"/(1R4#7"0#"5054­=71413#3!"50"*#G(5=1<*%"M"0#"0/F+P"E/5"50";7%;1%"X#7#3#M"T/15("#;%7=L"0#"135#"<%675"0#"T/5"B#CD500"4%*5(FL"

#"=7#6#.#7"5("</"*%350%"*54Q(14%+"X#7#3#M"U#6>#"314U%"T/5"0#"31<=716/41L("35"0#<" 0>(5#<"*#G(H=14#<" 35" E/57F#";%3>#" 35=57*1(#7<5" </;%(15(3%"T/5"5C1<=5"=5(<1L("#"0%"0#7G%"35"0#<"0>(5#<"M"/(#";75<1L("5(=75"500#<+"B#CD500!"5(=%(45<!"<5" ;75G/(=L" T/H" 5C;014#41L("*54Q(14#" ;%3>#" ;7%3/417" 5<=#" 35<1G/#03#3" 35";75<1%(5<"5("/("N/13%"%!";%7"#(#0%G>#!"5("/("*531%"*LK10+"]#"40#K5"0#"5(4%(=7L"5("0%<"=7#6#.%<"35"WU%*;<%(!"3%(35"<5"5<=#6054>#"0#"(545<13#3"35"</;%(57"/("

En-Claves14-book.indb 23 04/11/13 14:54

Page 15: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

8-" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

*%K1*15(=%"=/76/05(=%"5("=%7(%"#"0#<"0>(5#<"*#G(H=14#<"35"E/57F#"5("/("*531%"31#*#G(H=14%!";/5<";5(<#6#"T/5"H<=#"57#"0#")(14#"E%7*#"35"5C;014#7"0#"7%=#41L("35"0#"0/F"%6<57K#3#";%7"X#7#3#M+"B#CD500"U1F%"</M#"0#"135#"35"0%<"75*%01(%<"*#G(H=14%<"M"354131L"#;014#70#"#"=%3#<"0#<"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#!"=#(=%"5("50"5<;#­41%"4%*%"5("/("*531%"*#=571#0+"^<=#"G5(57#01F#41L(";57*1=>#"/(#"5C;014#41L("*54Q(14#"#0";7%605*#"35"0#"35<1G/#03#3"35";75<1%(5<!"=#(=%"#"0%"0#7G%"35"0#<"0>(5#<"4%*%"5(=75"500#<+^(" </<"353/441%(5<!"B#CD500" 1(=7%3/.%" /(#"U1;L=5<1<" T/5" 75</0=L" <57" 35"

G7#("K#0%7"U5/7><=14%V"T/5"0#<"*#<#<"35"0%<"75*%01(%<"*#G(H=14%<"35;5(3>#("35"0#";57*5#61013#3"*#G(H=14#"350"*531%"M!";%7"0%"=#(=%!"0#"5(57G>#"350"4#*;%"*#G(H=14%"j5<"35417!"0#"5(57G>#"41(H=14#"35"5<=%<"75*%01(%<j"57#"/(#"E/(41L("35"0#"4%(<=#(=5"35";57*5#61013#3+^0"<5G/(3%";#<%"5("0#"4%(<=7/441L("350"*%350%"T/5"5<=#6#"6/<4#(3%!"57#"

5(4%(=7#7"/(#"#(#0%G>#"*54Q(14#"35"0#"4%7715(=5"50H4=714#"T/5"5<=#6054157#"/(#"750#41L("5(=75"H<=#"M"50"*#G(5=1<*%+"]#"<%0/41L("1(G5(1%<#"35"B#CD500"4%(<1<=1L"5("</;%(57"T/5"0#"5054=71413#3"5<=Q"4%(<=1=/13#";%7"6%01=#<!"%";#7=>4/0#<"tK57"0#"RG/7#"8u!"T/5"<5;#7#("#"/(%<"75*%01(%<"*#G(H=14%<"35"%=7%<!"4%(<1357#(3%"#"H<=%<"4%*%"6#77#<"N5C1605<"4%("/(#"</;57R415"7/G%<#+"^0"7#F%(#*15(=%"35"B#CD500"5<"=#("<%7;75(35(=5"T/5"4%(K15(5"75;7%3/4170%V

S/;%(15(3%"T/5"<5#"4%7754=#"0#"5C;014#41L("35"0#<"0>(5#<"35"E/57F#"*531#(=5"75*%01(%<"*%054/0#75<!"I;%7"T/H"/(#"35=57*1(#3#"31<=716/41L("35"75*%01(%<"</;%(5"/(#" 4%7715(=5" 50H4=714#O"`(#" 75<;/5<=#" <#=1<E#4=%71#" (%<" E#4101=#7>#"*/4U%"50"4#*1(%"U#41#"0#"<%0/41L("350"K573#357%";7%605*#!"T/5"(%"5<"<1(%"4%(=5<=#7"#"0#";75G/(=#V"IT/H"5<"0#"4%7715(=5"50H4=714#OB5"U#"4%<=#3%"*/4U%"#45;=#7"0#"5C1<=5(41#"35"75*%01(%<"#"=7#KH<"35"=%3%"

/("*531%!"G17#(3%"4%3%"4%("4%3%"5("0#"*1<*#"3175441L("5("=%7(%"#"5.5<";#7#­050%<+"]#<";%741%(5<"4%(=1G/#<"35"3%<"75*%01(%<"4%(<54/=1K%<"3565("*%K57<5"5("3175441%(5<"%;/5<=#<|"M"5<"31E>410"4%*;75(357"4L*%"50"*%K1*15(=%"35"/(#";#7=5"350"*531%";/53#"4%5C1<=17"4%("/("*%K1*15(=%"4%(=7#71%"35"0#";%741L("4%(=1G/#!"5"1(40/<%";7%3/4170%+]#")(14#"135#"T/5"*5"U#"#M/3#3%"#"4%(45617"5<=5"=1;%"35"*%K1*15(=%<"5<"

T/5"0%<"75*%01(%<"5<=Q("<5;#7#3%<";%7"/(#"4#;#"35";#7=>4/0#<"G17#(3%"4#3#"/(#"#075353%7"35"</";7%;1%"5.5!"5("3175441L("%;/5<=#"#"0#"35"0%<"75*%01(%<!"35"E%7*#"T/5"0#<"</;57R415<"35"4%(=#4=%"5(=75";#7=>4/0#<"M"75*%01(%<"=15(5("50"*1<*%"<5(=13%"35"*%K1*15(=%+^("*54Q(14#!"4/#(3%"<5"T/1575"T/5"3%<"7/53#<"G175("5("0#"*1<*#"31754­

41L(!"<5"4%0%4#"5(=75"500#<"%=7#"7/53#"T/5"5(G7#(5"4%("#*6#<!"M"T/5"<5"00#*#"r;1$L("0%4%s+"]#"U1;L=5<1<"T/5"</G157%"<%675"0%<"75*%01(%<"5<"T/5"5(=75"4#3#"3%<"75*%01(%<"4%(=1G/%<"<5"1(=57;%(5"/(#"4#;#"35";#7=>4/0#<"T/5"#4=)#"4%*%"

En-Claves14-book.indb 24 04/11/13 14:54

Page 16: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" 8i

;1$L("0%4%|"35"5<=#"E%7*#"4#3#"75*%01(%"=15(35"#"U#457"T/5"</<"K541(%<"<5"*/5K#("5("0#"*1<*#"3175441L(+vwx"h%7"0%"=#(=%!"M"35"#4/573%"#"5<=#"U1;L=5<1<!";#7545"<57"T/5"0#"4%7715(=5"

50H4=714#"T/53#"75;75<5(=#3#";%7"0#"=7#(<E575(41#"35"0#<";#7=>4/0#<"*LK105<"1(=57;/5<=#<"5(=75"0%<"KL7=145<"K541(%<+"h%35*%<"4%(45617"T/5"5<=#<";#7=>­4/0#<"<%("*/M";5T/5$#<"4%*;#7#3#<"4%("50"=#*#$%"35"0%<"KL7=145<!"M"T/5"/(#"G7#("4#(=13#3"35"KL7=145<"4%("=%3%"M"</<";#7=>4/0#<"4174/(3#(=5<!"T/53#("4%(=5(13%<"5("/(#")(14#"*%0H4/0#"4%*;05=#"350"*531%+8o

X1G/7#"8+"]%<"75*%01(%<"*#G(H=14%<"35"B#CD500"5("On Physical Lines of Force+

^0"=57457";#<%"5("0#"4%(<=7/441L("35"</"*%350%"*54Q(14%"E/5"</;%(57"T/5"5<=%<"75*%01(%<"*#G(H=14%<"5<=#6#("3%=#3%<"35"50#<=1413#3+"̂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j#0"1G/#0"T/5"X#7#3#Mj"135L"/(#"=5%7>#"35"4#*;%"35"

4#7G#+"P!"4%*%"K575*%<"#"4%(=1(/#41L(!"0#"#3%;41L("35"5<=#"135#"35"4#*;%<"35"4#7G#"05"#;%7=#7>#"#"</"=5%7>#"#0G/(%<"35"0%<"75</0=#3%<"*Q<"%71G1(#05<+

8o  Ibid+!";#7=5"II!";;+"8n:28ni+

En-Claves14-book.indb 25 04/11/13 14:54

Page 17: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

8m" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

La teoría electromagnética de la luz

^("50"K57#(%"35"#T/50",nm,"B#CD500"K1#.L"#"</<";%<5<1%(5<"5("^<4%41#!"#;#­75(=5*5(=5"<#=1<E54U%"35"</"#(#0%G>#"*54Q(14#"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"M"35"0#"U1;L=5<1<"T/5"U#6>#"E%7*/0#3%";#7#"0%<"4#*;%<"35"4#7G#+"h57%"5("0%<"<1G/15(=5<"*5<5<" E/5"4#*61#(3%"</"4%*;75(<1L("<%675" 0#<" 1*;014#41%(5<"35"</";7%;1%"=7#6#.%+B15(=7#<"#=5(3>#"</<"=1577#<"M";5(<#6#"5("</<"*%350%<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<!"

5("50"K57#(%"35"5<5"*1<*%"#$%"0%<";7%605*#<"=H4(14%<"35"0#"=505G7#E>#"%4/;#­6#("0#"#=5(41L("35"0%<"E><14%<"671=Q(14%<+"\5<;/H<"35"0%<"35<#<=7%<%<";71*57%<"1(=5(=%<" 35" =5(357" /(" 4#605" =7#(<#=0Q(=14%!8n" 0#"Z<%41#41L("_71=Q(14#";#7#" 50"ZK#(45"35"0#"@15(41#"5<=#60541L"/("4%*1=H"T/5"<5"5(4#7G#7>#"35"R.#7"0%<"5<=Q(­3#75<"35"75<1<=5(41#"50H4=714#"T/5";57*1=157#("T/5"0#"753"35"4#605<"E/(41%(#7#"#;7%;1#3#*5(=5+"B#CD500"<5"/(1L"#"5<=5"4%*1=H!"#0" 1G/#0"T/5"%=7%<"E><14%<!"M";7%(=%"0%<"(/5K%<"0#6%7#=%71%<"/(1K57<1=#71%<"35"5(<5$#(F#"35"E><14#"5("0#"e7#("_75=#$#"5<=#6#("35314#3%<"#"U#457"*53141%(5<"5054=7%*#G(H=14#<!"1(40/M5(3%"50"0#6%7#=%71%"3171G13%";%7"WU%*;<%(!"5("e0#<G%D!"M"50"0#6%7#=%71%"@#K5(31<U!"5("@#*6713G5!"3171G13%";%7"B#CD500+^<=#(3%"5("^<4%41#!"5<5"K57#(%"35",nm,!"<1G/1L"=7#6#.#(3%"5("</"*%350%"

*54Q(14%";#7#"5C;014#7"50"E/(41%(#*15(=%"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"4%("6#<5"5("5(G7#(#.5<!"6%01=#<"M"75*%01(%<"*#G(H=14%<!"M"E/5"5(=%(45<"j5("/(%"35"</<"*/4U%<"35<=500%<"475#=1K%<j"4/#(3%"<5"31%"4/5(=#"35"T/5"5<=5"*531%"N/13%"~356>#"=7#(<*1=17"</"#441L("#"=7#KH<"35"%(3#<"=7#(<K57<#05<�^0"*54#(1<*%"T/5"M#"U#6>#"135#3%";#7#"5C;014#7"0#"750#41L("5(=75"50"4#*;%"

*#G(H=14%"M"0#"4%7715(=5"50H4=714#"57#"50"<1G/15(=5V"0#"4%7715(=5"50H4=714#"57#"50"*%K1*15(=%"35"0#<";#7=>4/0#<"50H4=714#<"t0#<"6%01=#<"T/5"7%35#("0%<"U5CQG%(%<"35"0#"RG/7#"8u|"4/#(3%"/(#";#7=>4/0#"<5"*%K>#!"7%F#6#"0#<";#7535<"350"75*%­01(%"*#G(H=14%"4%(=1G/%"t0#<"4H0/0#<"U5C#G%(#05<"35"0#"RG/7#u"M"0%";%(>#"5("*%K1*15(=%+"]#"7%=#41L("35"5<=5"75*%01(%";7%K%4#6#"0#"7%=#41L("35"=%3#<"0#<";#7=>4/0#<"50H4=714#<"T/5"5<=#6#("5("4%(=#4=%"4%("H0+"^<=#<";#7=>4/0#<!"#"</"K5F!"#0"G17#7"7%F#6#("4%(=7#"0%<"75*%01(%<"5("4%(=#4=%"4%("500#<!";7%K%4#(3%"</"G17%!"M"#<>"</45<1K#*5(=5!"U#<=#"T/5"=%3%"50"5<;#41%"<5"005(#6#"35"75*%01(%<"

8n" ^("50";71*57" 1(=5(=%!"5(",nio!"50"4#605"<5"75K5(=L"50";71*57"3>#+"X/5"75;#7#3%"M"K%0K1L"#"7%*;57<5+"^("50"<5G/(3%"1(=5(=%!"50"K57#(%"<1G/15(=5!"<5"7%*;1L"5("=75<"%4#<1%(5<!"#"31E575(=5<"31<=#(41#<+"̂ ("/("=57457"1(=5(=%!"<5"0%G7L";%7"R("/("5*;#0*5"5C1=%<%!"M"50";71*57"*5(<#.5"E/5"5(K1#3%";%7"0#"k51(#"&14=%71#"#0";75<135(=5"?#*5<"_/4U#(#("50",m"35"#G%<=%"35",nin!";57%"0#"4%*/(14#41L("5(=75"e7#("_75=#$#"M"a%7=5#*H714#"<L0%"3/7L"/(#<"<5*#(#<!"M"50"89"35"%4=/675"50"4#605"35.L"35"E/(41%(#7!"35<;/H<"35"U#657<5"K/50=%"4#3#"K5F"*Q<"05(=#"0#"=7#(<*1<1L("tU#41#"50"R(#0!"50"5(K>%"35"/("*5(<#.5"35"*531#";QG1(#"35"=5C=%"75T/57>#"*Q<"35"/("3>#u+

En-Claves14-book.indb 26 04/11/13 14:54

Page 18: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" 8o

*#G(H=14%<"5("*%K1*15(=%+"h%7" 0%"=#(=%!"/(#";#7=>4/0#"50H4=714#"4%("01657=#3"35"*%K1*15(=%"5("/("4%(3/4=%7!";7%3/417>#"/("4#*;%"*#G(H=14%"#075353%7"350"4#605+h57%!"#0";75G/(=#7<5"T/H"%4/7717>#"<1"0#"4%7715(=5"50H4=714#"350"4#605"31<*1(/>#!"

<5"31%"4/5(=#"35"T/5"5<=%"1*;014#7>#"j5("</"*%350%"*54Q(14%j"T/5"0#<";#7=>4/0#<"50H4=714#<"4%*5(F#7>#("#"*%K57<5"*Q<"35<;#41%!"U#415(3%"T/5"0%<"75*%01(%<"*#G(H=14%<"#3M#45(=5<";573157#("=#*61H("K50%413#3+"^<=%"<1G(1R4#6#"T/5"<5";75<5(=#7>#"/(#"31E575(41#"35"K50%413#3"5(=75"0%<"75*%01(%<"4%(=1G/%<"#0"4#605"M" 0%<"<1G/15(=5<!"4%("50" 75</0=#3%"35"T/5" 0#<";#7=>4/0#<"T/5"T/53#6#("5(=75"#*6%<" =5(357>#("#" ;%(57<5"5("*%K1*15(=%w"^<=#" 31E575(41#" 35" K50%413#3!";5(<L"B#CD500!"T/53#7>#"#6<%7613#"1(141#0*5(=5";%7"/(#"31<=%7<1L("50Q<=14#"35"0%<"75*%01(%<!"35E%7*#(3%"</"4%(=%7(%+"̂ (=%(45<!"5<=%<"75*%01(%<"35E%7*#3%<"5.57457>#("/(#"E/57F#"<%675"0#<";#7=>4/0#<"T/5"<5"*%K>#("*Q<"35";71<#!"31<*1­(/M5(3%"</"K50%413#3+"P"35"5<=5"*%3%";#<#7>#";%7"=%3%"50"4#*;%"/(#"%(3#"35"35<;0#F#*15(=%"35"0#<";#7=>4/0#<"50H4=714#<"M"/("4#*;%"*#G(H=14%"K#71#605+\5"5<=5"*%3%!"B#CD500"353/.%"T/5"U#67>#"%(3#<"35"35<;0#F#*15(=%"=7#(<­

K57<#0" ;#7#"50" 5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%!" M" T/5" 4/#0T/157" 4#*61%"5(" 0#<" 4%7715(=5<"50H4=714#<"%"5("0%<"4#*;%<"<5"*%K57>#"5("50"H=57"=7#(<*1<%7";7541<#*5(=5"#<>!"5("%(3#<"T/5"0%"U#7>#("K167#7+"^("5<=5"*%*5(=%"tK57#(%"35",nm,u"=%3#K>#"(%"U#6>#"4%(45613%"T/5"50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"5<!"5("<>"*1<*%!"/(#"%(3#w";57%"M#"5<=#6#"4574#"35"4%*;75(3570%+"P!"#/(T/5"=#*;%4%"U#6>#";%313%";7%6#7"#)("T/5"0%<"E5(L*5(%<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<"=15(5("0#"*1<*#"(#=/7#05F#"T/5"0#"0/F!"0#"4%(5C1L("05"75</0=#6#"4#3#"K5F"*Q<"5K135(=5+"h57%"I4L*%";7%6#70%O@%*%"U5*%<"*5(41%(#3%!"/(%"35"0%<";71(41;#05<";7%605*#<"=5L714%<"T/5"

005KL"#"B#CD500"#"4%(<=7/17"</"(/5K%"*%350%"U#6>#"<13%"50"35"35<#77%00#7"/(#"=5%­7>#"5("0#"4/#0"0#"1(3/441L("tT/5"U#<=#"5<5"*%*5(=%"<5"U#6>#"4%(<1357#3%"4%*%"/("5E54=%"1(<=#(=Q(5%u"=/K157#"/(#"K50%413#3"R(1=#+"h#7#"#<5G/7#7"0#"K50%413#3"(%"1(<=#(=Q(5#!"B#CD500"U#6>#"3%=#3%"#"</"*54#(1<*%"35"*#<#"M"35"50#<=141­3#3+"Z35*Q<"jM"4%*%"U5*%<"K1<=%j"U#6>#"0%G7#3%"135(=1R4#7"*/4U#<"35"0#<";7%;153#35<"4%(%413#<"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"4%("/("*%350%"*54Q(14%"T/5"05";57*1=>#"3571K#7"EL7*/0#<"*#=5*Q=14#<+"Z<>"T/5";5(<L"T/5"<1"0%G7#6#"353/417"0#"K50%413#3"35"0#<"%(3#<"5("50"*54#(1<*%"#";#7=17"35"5<=#<";7%;153#35<!"5(=%(45<"=5(37>#"/(#";7531441L("T/5"<57>#"4%(=7#<=#605"4%(" 0%<"3#=%<"5C;571*5(=#05<!"1(35;5(315(=5*5(=5"350"*54#(1<*%"1(K5(=#3%";#7#"353/4170#+B#CD500"=7#6#.L"5("500%"M!"4%("#M/3#"35"0#"*54Q(14#"(5D=%(1#(#!"35"</"G7#("

U#61013#3"*#=5*Q=14#"M"35"/(#"<5715"35"#</(41%(5<8l logró calcular la velocidad 

8l" Z<>!" ;%7" 5.5*;0%!" </;/<%" T/5" 0#"*#<#" 35" 0#<" 6%01=#<" 50H4=714#<" M" </" 50#<=1413#3" 57#("35<;7541#605<!"M"T/5"=%3#"0#"*#<#"M"=%3#"0#"50#<=1413#3"5<=#6#("5("0%<"75*%01(%<+"h#7#"/(#"5C;%<141L("*Q<"35=#00#3#"35"0#"*#(57#"5("T/5"005GL"#"</<"54/#41%(5<+"tX+"@Q(%K#<!"op. cit.!";;+"8m2:9+u

En-Claves14-book.indb 27 04/11/13 14:54

Page 19: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

8n" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

35"0#<"%(3#<"5("*531%<"35"=7#(<*1<1L("35"31E575(=5<"35(<13#35<!"#";#7=17"35"*53141%(5<"35"0#6%7#=%71%"35"0#<"E/57F#<"5054=7%<=Q=14#<"M"5054=7%*#G(H=14#<+"\5"75G75<%!"5("]%(375<!"4%*;#7L"</<"75</0=#3%<"4%("0#<"%6<57K#41%(5<"5054=7%­*#G(H=14#<"75#01F#3#<"U#4>#"/(%<"#$%<"5("Z05*#(1#"M";7%6L"5<%<"3#=%<"5("</<"54/#41%(5<+"h#7#"</"<%7;75<#!"~0%<"75</0=#3%<"35"5<#<"%6<57K#41%(5<"31E57>#("5("(%"*Q<"35"/(",�"350"K#0%7";#7#"0#"K50%413#3"35"0#"0/F"T/5"<5"U#6>#"35=57*1(#3%"5("h#7><"U#4>#"3%45"#$%<�"S/<"4Q04/0%<"05"3#6#("T/5"0#"K50%413#3"35"=7#(<*1<1L("350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"<57>#"35":,9"o-9"A*�<5G+"M"Z7*#(3"p1;;%0M=5"X1F5#/:9 U#6>#"4#04/0#3%"0#"K50%413#3"35"0#"0/F"5(":,-"nin"A*�<5G+r]#"4%1(4135(41#"(%"5<"*57#*5(=5"(/*H714#s!"5<47161L"#"X#7#3#M"5("50"%=%$%"

35"#T/50",nm,+"Z;#75(=5*5(=5"0#"0/F"57#"/(#"K167#41L("350"*1<*%"*531%"tIM"350"*1<*%"=1;%Ou"T/5"57#"75<;%(<#605"35"0#"=7#(<*1<1L("350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%+"~\5"(1(G/(#"*#(57#";%3>#"<57"/(#"<1*;05"4%1(4135(41#�"h57%!"<1"0#"0/F"57#"/(#"%(3#"{4%*%"U#6>#"35*%<=7#3%"@U71<=1##("p/MG5(<"35<35"50"<1G0%"XVII{"IT/57>#"35417"5<=%"T/5"50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"=#*61H("<5"=7#(<*1=>#";%7"%(3#<!"<%675"50"*1<*%"H=57"T/5"U#4>#"K167#7"0#"0/F"#"0#"*1<*#"K50%413#3O"B#CD500!"T/5"5<=#6#"preparando la tercera parte de On Physical Lines of Force!"#<5(=LV

]#"K50%413#3"35"0#<"%(3/0#41%(5<"=7#(<K57<#05<"5("(/5<=7%"*531%"U1;%=H=1­4%!"4#04/0#3#"#";#7=17"35" 0%<"5C;571*5(=%<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<"35" 0%<"S75<+"g%0U7#/<4U"M"Y5657!"4%1(4135" =#("5C#4=#*5(=5"4%(" 0#"K50%413#3"35" 0#" 0/F"4#04/0#3#"#";#7=17"35"0%<"5C;571*5(=%<"L;=14%<"350"S7+"X1F5#/!"T/5"31E>410*5(=5"podemos evitar la inferencia de que la luz consiste en ondulaciones trans­versales del mismo medio que es la causa de los fenómenos magnéticos y eléctricos+:,

h57%!"I;%3>#"<57"T/5"#*6%<"E5(L*5(%<"5<=/K157#("*/4U%"*Q<"5<=754U#­*5(=5"750#41%(#3%<"T/5"0%"T/5"M#"1(314#6#"50"U54U%"35"<57"=7#(<*1=13%<";%7"50"*1<*%"*531%"M"#"0#"*1<*#"K50%413#3O"a/5K#*5(=5!"B#CD500"<%<;54U#6#"T/5"0#"4%1(4135(41#"5("K50%413#35<"1(314#6#"*/4U%"*Q<"T/5"/("*531%"35"=7#(<*1<1L("4%*;#7=13%+"\5"5<=5"*%3%!"M"=7#6#.#(3%"5("</<"54/#41%(5<"#U%7#"=#(=%";#7#"

:9" X1F5#/"75#01FL"</"5C;571*5(=%"35"*53141L("5(",n-l+"`("7#M%"35"0/F"<5"3171G>#"#"/("5<;5.%"#"415(=%<"35"*5=7%<"35"31<=#(41#+"^("</"=7#M54=%"35"0#"E/5(=5"U#41#"50"5<;5.%!"50"7#M%";#<#6#"#"=7#KH<"35"/("5(G7#(#.5"7%=#=%71%+"Z"4157=%"(1K50"35"7%=#41L(!"50"7#M%";#<#7>#"#"=7#KH<"35"/("%71R41%"5("</"4#*1(%"35"<#013#"M!";%7"%=7%!"5("</"4#*1(%"35"75G75<%+"h57%"#"(1K505<"01G57#*5(=5"*5(%75<!"50"7#M%"<5";7%M54=#7>#"5("/(%"35"0%<"315(=5<"M"(%";#<#7>#"#"=7#KH<"35"0#"7/53#+"@%(%415(3%"0#"31<=#(41#"U#41#"50"5<;5.%!"50"()*57%"35"315(=5<"350"5(G7#(#.5!"M"50">(3145"35"7%=#41L(!"<5";%3>#"4#04/0#7"0#"K50%413#3"35"0#"0/F+"X1F5#/"0#"4#04/0L"5(":,-"nin"999"*�<+"S/"K50%413#3"75#0"5("50"K#4>%!"4%*%"U%M"<5"05"4%(%45!"5<"35"8l"ol8!-in"*�<+

:,  ?+"@+"B#CD500!"op. cit+!";#7=5"III!";+"88+

En-Claves14-book.indb 28 04/11/13 14:54

Page 20: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" 8l

50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"4%*%";#7#"0#"0/F!"B#CD500"4%*5(FL"0#"*#M%7"/(1R4#41L("=5L714#"35"0#"U1<=%71#"35"0#"E><14#"35<35"'<##4"a5D=%(+\/7#(=5" 0%<"<1G/15(=5<"3%<"#$%<"B#CD500"<5"5<E%7FL";%7" =7#(<E%7*#7"</"

*%350%"35"5(G7#(#.5<!" 75*%01(%<"M"6%01=#<"*LK105<"5("/(#" =5%7>#"31(Q*14#"G5(57#0"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%+"h%7"R(!" 0#"=5%7>#"T/53L"4%*;05=#*5(=5"35­<#77%00#3#"5(",nm-"M"0#";/6014L"#0"#$%"<1G/15(=5"6#.%"50"=>=/0%"35"K+;<#)0%!).+Theory of the Electromagnetic Field+"^("5<=5"#7=>4/0%"B#CD500"U1F%"#0";7%;1%"*531%"5054=7%*#G(H=14%"</.5=%"35"#(Q01<1<"/=101F#(3%"0%<";71(41;1%<"G5(57#05<"35"0#"31(Q*14#"t35"#U>"50"=>=/0%"r`(#"=5%7>#"31(Q*14#"350"4#*;%"5054=7%*#G­(H=14%su+"P"5<"#T/>"4/#(3%"M#"/=101F#"50"4%(45;=%"35"%(3#<"5054=7%*#G(H=14#<!"5("0/G#7"35"<1*;05*5(=5"0>(5#<"%"4#*;%<"35"E/57F#!"M"5("3%(35"755*;0#F#"=%=#0*5(=5"</"#(=571%7"5(E%T/5"*54Q(14%";%7"/("7#F%(#*15(=%"*Q<"#6<=7#4=%"M"*#=5*Q=14%";#7#"35<471617"50"4%*;%7=#*15(=%"35"0%<"4#*;%<"5054=7%*#G(H­=14%<"5("50"5<;#41%+@574#"350"R(#0"350"4#;>=/0%"VI de K+;<#)0%!).+8/'"(<+"9+3/'+=.'!3("0)1#'3%!+

Field!"35<;/H<"35"/(#"67100#(=5"35*%<=7#41L("*#=5*Q=14#"5("T/5"0%G7#"/(17"0#<"54/#41%(5<"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"4%("0#<"35"0#"=7#(<*1<1L("35"0#"0/F!"B#CD500"5<47161L!" =71/(E#0*5(=5" r]#"4%(4%73#(41#"35" 0%<" 75</0=#3%<";#7545"35*%<=7#7"T/5"0#"0/F!" 0#"5054=71413#3"M"50"*#G(5=1<*%"<%("*#(1E5<=#41%(5<"35"0#"*1<*#"</<=#(41#!"M"T/5""0#"0/F"5<"/(#";57=/76#41L("5054=7%*#G(H=14#"T/5"<5";7%;#G#";%7"50"4#*;%"<1G/15(3%"05M5<"5054=7%*#G(H=14#<s+:8

Corolario

Z";5<#7"35"0#"U#F#$#"1(=5054=/#0"M"35"0#<"5(%7*5<"1*;014#41%(5<"35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#"35"0#"0/F"35"B#CD500!"G7#41#<"#"0#"4/#0"<5"0%G7L"0#"/(1R4#41L("=5L714#"*Q<"1*;%7=#(=5"35"0#"E><14#"35<35"0#"k5K%0/41L("@15(=>R4#!"#0"4%0%4#7"6#.%"0#"*1<*#"5C;014#41L("=5L714#"0%"T/5"U#<=#"5(=%(45<"U#6>#("<13%"4%(<135­7#3%<"=75<"31E575(=5<"=1;%<"35"E5(L*5(%<!"0#"=5%7>#"35"B#CD500"E/5"#45;=#3#"M"4%*;75(313#"<L0%"35"*#(57#"*/M"G7#3/#0";%7"</<"4%(=5*;%7Q(5%<+::

:8  ?+" @+"B#CD500!" rZ"\M(#*14#0" WU5%7M" %E" =U5" ^054=7%*#G(5=14" X1503s!" 5("Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society!"4#;+"VI+

::" S1("5*6#7G%!"0#"=505G7#E>#"./GL"/(#"K5F"*Q<"#"E#K%7"35"B#CD500!"M";#7#"0#"3H4#3#"35"0%<"<5=5(=#<"del siglo XIX"</<"54/#41%(5<"5*;5F#7%("#"<57"5(<5$#3#<";%7"0%<";7%E5<%75<"35"*#=5*Q=14#<"35"0#"`(1K57<13#3"35"@#*6713G5!"T/5"0#<"U#6>#("1(=7%3/413%"5("</<"(/5K%<"4/7<%<"35"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%";%7"</"/=1013#3";#7#"50"=5*#"35"0#"=505G7#E>#"</6*#71(#+"^0";7%;1%"B#CD500"354131L"5(=%(45<"5<471617"A Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism,"yCE%73!"@0#75(3%("h75<<!",no:!"5C;75<#*5(=5";#7#"<57K17"4%*%"0167%"35"=5C=%"t50";71*57%"<%675"50"=5*#u";#7#"</<"#0/*(%<"5("@#*6713G5+

En-Claves14-book.indb 29 04/11/13 14:54

Page 21: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

:9" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

WU%*;<%(!"T/5"U#<=#"5(=%(45<"U#6>#"<13%"#*1G%"35"B#CD500"M"</"4%05G#"5("50"*1<*%"4#*;%"35"1(K5<=1G#41L(!"<5"4%(K17=1L"5("/(%"35"</<"47>=14%<"*Q<"<5K57%<+"h#7#"5*;5F#7!"(%"05";573%(#6#"U#657"#6#(3%(#3%"</"5C;014#41L("*5­4Q(14#"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"5("E#K%7"35"/(#"=5%7>#"5054=7%31(Q*14#"6#<#3#"5("#6<=7#4=#<"54/#41%(5<"#0G567#14#<+"h#7#"WU%*;<%(!"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#"35"0#"0/F"35"B#CD500"75;75<5(=#6#"r/("75=7%45<%!"*Q<"T/5"/(";#<%"#350#(=5s!"<1"(%"5<"T/5"/("=1;%"35"r(1U101<*%s+"^(",nn-!"4/#(3%"B#CD500"M#"005K#6#"41(4%"#$%<"35"U#657"*/57=%"#"4#/<#"35"/("4Q(457!"WU%*;<%("<5G/>#"31415(3%"350"=7#6#.%"35"</"71K#0V

a/(4#"*5"5(4/5(=7%"<#=1<E54U%"U#<=#"T/5";/53%"U#457"/("*%350%"*54Q(14%"35"#0G%+"S1";/53%"U#457"/("*%350%"*54Q(14%!";/53%"5(=5(3570%+"̂ ("=#(=%"T/5"(%";/53%"U#457"/("*%350%"*54Q(14%"4%*;05=%!"(%";/53%"4%*;75(357|"M"5<";%7"5<=%";%7"0%"T/5"(%";/53%"5(=5(357"/(#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#"v4%*%"0#"35"B#CD500x+"@75%"R7*5*5(=5"5("/(#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#"35"0#"0/F!"M"T/5"4/#(3%"4%*;75(3#*%<"0#"5054=71413#3!"50"*#G(5=1<*%"M"0#"0/F!"0%<"K575*%<"=%3%<"./(=%<"4%*%";#7=5"35"/("=%3%+"h57%"T/157%"4%*;75(357"0#"0/F"=%3%"0%"615("T/5";/53#"<1("1(=7%3/417"4%<#<"T/5"5(=15(3%"=%3#K>#"*5(%<+:-

P!"#0"*1<*%"=15*;%"T/5"U#4>#"3540#7#41%(5<"4%*%"H<=#!"<%<=5(>#";)6014#­*5(=5!"M"35"*#(57#"4%(=7#314=%71#!"T/5"5("75#013#3"H0"M#"<#6>#"=%3%"<%675"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#"35"0#"0/F"35<35"#(=5<"T/5"B#CD500"0#";/6014#7#!"G7#41#<"#"</<";7%;1%<"5<=/31%<"<%675"0#";7%;#G#41L("35"0#<"<5$#05<"=505G7QR4#<"5("0%<"4#605<"</6*#71(%<+:i^("4/#(=%"#"r0#<"54/#41%(5<"35"B#CD500s!"T/5"<1(=5=1F#("</"=5%7>#"35"*#(57#"

=#("505G#(=5"M"T/5"U%M"5("3>#"#;#7545("5("4#<1"=%3%<"0%<"0167%<"35"=5C=%"35"E><14#!"3565"754%73#7<5"T/5"(%"E/57%("U54U#<";%7"H0"5("</"E%7*/0#41L("K54=%71#0"#4=/#0+"]#<"54/#41%(5<"#;#754157%("5(",nmi"5("50"4#;>=/0%"III de K+;<#)0%!).+8/'"(<+of the Electromagnetic Field+"^("5<=5"4#;>=/0%!"B#CD500"E%7*/0L"%4U%"54/#41%­(5<"tT/5"(%*67L"35"0#"05=7#"Z"#"0#"pu!"M"35"5<#<"%4U%"54/#41%(5<")(14#*5(=5"/(#!"0#"35"0#"]5M"35"e#/<<"tT/5"5("50"4%(./(=%"35"54/#41%(5<"4%775<;%(3>#"#"

:-  Thompson dio este discurso en una conferencia que impartió durante las Baltimore Lectures. ]#"41=#"4%*;05=#";/535"4%(</0=#7<5"5("h+"g#7G%("M"h+"Z4U1(<=51(!"53<+!"Kelvin’s Baltimore Lectures and Modern Theoretical Physics!"B#<<#4U/<5==<!"WU5"MIT"h75<<!",lno!";+"89m+

:i" S+"S4U#EE57!"op. cit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

En-Claves14-book.indb 30 04/11/13 14:54

Page 22: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" :,

0#"05=7#"eu"U#"<%675K1K13%"5("</"E%7*#"%71G1(#0"5("0%<"0167%<"35"=5C=%"#4=/#05<+"^0"*H71=%"35"U#657"753/413%"5<#<"%4U%"54/#41%(5<"#0G567#14#<"%71G1(#05<"#"0#<"505G#(=5<"4/#=7%"54/#41%(5<"K54=%71#05<"#4=/#05<!"4%775<;%(31L"#"/("67100#(=5"=505G7#R<=#"35"]%(375<!"y01K57"p5#K1<135!"T/5" 0#<";/6014L"5(",nni" t8,"#$%<"35<;/H<"35"0#";/6014#41L("35"K+;<#)0%!).+8/'"(<+"9+3/'+=.'!3("0)1#'3%!+L%'.&u"en The Electrician!"T/5"(%"57#"/(#"75K1<=#"415(=>R4#"<1(%"/(#";/6014#41L(";#7#"1(G5(157%<"M"U%*675<"35"(5G%41%<+"\5"*#(57#"<1*/0=Q(5#"5"1(35;5(315(=5!"5("Z05*#(1#!"50"E><14%"p51(714U"p57=F"005GL"#"0#"*1<*#"5C;75<1L("K54=%71#0"<1*;01R­4#3#"35"0#<"54/#41%(5<"35"B#CD500+"h%7"5<=#"7#FL(!"5<=#<"4/#=7%"54/#41%(5<"(%"E/57%("4%(%413#<"1(141#0*5(=5"4%*%"r0#<"54/#41%(5<"35"B#CD500s!"<1(%"4%*%"r0#<"54/#41%(5<"p57=F2p5#K1<135s+^("</"K57<1L("%71G1(#0"35"%4U%"54/#41%(5<!"B#CD500"5*;05#6#"/("<1<=5*#"35"

cuaterniones:m"M"</";0#(=5#*15(=%"57#"5<5(41#0*5(=5"#0G567#14%+"P"5("0#"%;1(1L("35"#0G/(%<"#/=%75<!"#/(T/5"0#<"EL7*/0#<"T/5"0%G7#7%("p5#K1<135"M"p57=F"<%("/("*%350%"35"4%*;#413#3"M"<>(=5<1<!"50"=7#=#*15(=%"5("4/#=57(1%(5<"35"B#CD500"75</0=#"*Q<"1(=/1=1K%"M";57*1=5"353/417"*5.%7"0%<"E5(L*5(%<"T/5"35<47165(!"M#"T/5"0%<"4/#=57(1%(5<"<5";75<=#("*/M"615(";#7#"75;75<5(=#7"0%<"4#*;%<"*#G(H=14%<"M"0#<"%715(=#41%(5<"M"7%=#41%(5<"5("50"5<;#41%"35"%6.5=%<"5("=75<"31*5(<1%(5<+h57%"0%"*Q<"1*;%7=#(=5"35"0#<"54/#41%(5<"35"B#CD500"tM#"<5#"5("</"E%7*/­

0#41L("%71G1(#0"5("4/#=57(1%(5<!"%"5("0#"*%357(#"E%7*/0#41L("K54=%71#0u"5<"T/5"=7#<415(35(" 0#" E><14#"40Q<14#"5" 1(=7%3/45(" 0#"5C1<=5(41#"350"4#*;%"4%*%"#0G%"75#0+"^(";#0#67#<"35"^1(<=51(V

]#"E%7*/0#41L("35"5<=#<"54/#41%(5<"5<"50"#4%(=541*15(=%"*Q<"1*;%7=#(­=5"35"0#"E><14#"35<35"50"=15*;%"35"a5D=%(!"(%"<L0%";%7" 0#"71T/5F#"35"</"4%(=5(13%!"<1(%";%7T/5" 75;75<5(=#("/("*%350%"%";#=7L(";#7#"/("(/5K%"=1;%"35"05M"vwxS5G)("0#"5C;5715(41#"35"X#7#3#M!"=15(5"T/5"U#657"/("4%(3/4=%7"T/5"75K505"

0#"5C1<=5(41#"350"4#*;%"50H4=714%!"1G/#0"T/5"75</0=#"1(31<;5(<#605"0#";75<5(41#"35"/(";%0%"%"35"/(#"#G/.#"*#G(H=14#";#7#";7%6#7" 0#"5C1<=5(41#"350"4#*;%"*#G(H=14%"5(" 0#"5C;5715(41#"35"y57<=53+" ]#"(/5K#"4%(45;41L(" =5L714#"35"B#CD500"K#"*Q<"#00Q"35"0%<"75</0=#3%<"35"314U%<"5C;571*5(=%<+"vwx"50"4#*;%"5054=7%*#G(H=14%"5<!"5("0#"=5%7>#"35"B#CD500!"#0G%"75#0+"̂ 0"4#*;%"50H4=714%"5<"475#3%";%7"/("4#*;%"*#G(H=14%"K#71#605"1(35;5(315(=5*5(=5"35"0#"5C1<=5(­41#"35"/("4%(3/4=%7!"M"<5"475#"/("4#*;%"*#G(H=14%";%7"/("4#*;%"50H4=714%"K#71#605!"U#M#"%"(%"/(";%0%"*#G(H=14%+

:m" ]%<"4/#=57(1%(5<"<%("/(#"5C=5(<1L("35" 0%<"()*57%<" 75#05<!"<1*10#7"#" 0#"35" 0%<"()*57%<"4%*;05.%<+"Z<>!"*15(=7#<"T/5"5("0%<"()*57%<"4%*;05.%<"<5"5*;05#"50"()*57%"i!"=#0"T/5"i2 �"2,!"0%<"4/#=57(1%(5<"<5"G5(57#("35"*#(57#"#(Q0%G#"#$#315(3%" 0#<"/(13#35<" 1*#G1(#71#<V" i,  j"M"D a  los ()*57%<"75#05<!"4%(";7%;153#35<"=#05<"T/5"i2=j2MD2M%NDM+OP+

En-Claves14-book.indb 31 04/11/13 14:54

Page 23: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

:8" &0#31*17"@#4UL("e/100H(

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

vwx"50"4#*;%"5054=7%*#G(H=14%"/(#"K5F"475#3%"5C1<=5!"#4=)#"M"K#7>#"<5G)("0#<"05M5<"35"B#CD500+"vwx"</"K#0135F"<5"5C=15(35"#"=%3%"50"5<;#41%"4%(=7#71#­*5(=5"#"0#<"05M5<"35"=1;%"*54Q(14%!"T/5"K#05("=#("<L0%";#7#"#T/500%<"0/G#75<"3%(35"U#M#"*#=571#"%"4#7G#<"50H4=714#<"%"*#G(H=14#<+" vwx"a%" 750#41%(#(!"4%*%"0#<"05M5<"35"a5D=%(!"3%<"</45<%<"31<=#(=5<|"(%"754%(%45("0#"r#441L("#"31<=#(41#s+"^0"4#*;%"r#T/>s"M"r#U%7#s"35;5(35"350"4#*;%"T/5"U#6>#"5("50"5(=%7(%"1(*531#=%"5("/("1(<=#(=5"1(*531#=#*5(=5"#(=571%7+"]#<"54/#41%(5<";57*1=5(";7535417"0%"T/5";#<#7Q"/(";%4%"*Q<"#00Q"35"/("4157=%"0/G#7"350"5<;#41%!"/("1(<=#(=5"35<;/H<!"<1"4%(%45*%<"0%"T/5";#<#"r#U%7#s"M"r#T/>s+:o

Discusión

]#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#"35"0#"0/F"E/5"/("5(%7*5"0%G7%"1(=5054=/#0"M"4%(<=1=/M5!";7%6#605*5(=5!"0#"=5%7>#"/(1R4#3%7#"35"0#"E><14#"*Q<"1*;%7=#(=5"U#<=#"0#"475#41L("350"*%350%"5<=Q(3#7"#"*531#3%<"350"<1G0%"XX+"B#CD500"0%G7L"5<=#"U#F#$#"475#=1K#"#";#7=17"35"/(#"4%(./(41L("35"4174/(<=#(41#<"M"4/#013#35<+"^(=75"0#<"4174/(<=#(­41#<"T/5"0%"1(N/M57%("3565*%<"35<=#4#7!"5(";71*57"0/G#7!"0%<"5C;571*5(=%<"5"U1;L=5<1<"35"X#7#3#M"T/15(!"#/("<1(";%<557"/("5(=75(#*15(=%"*#=5*Q=14%"E%7*#0!"4%*%"50"35"B#CD500"j;%7"0%"T/5"31E>410*5(=5";%3>#"U#657"0%G7#3%"0%"T/5"U1F%"5<=5")0=1*%j!"57#"/("5C;571*5(=#3%7"*/M"UQ610"M"4%("/(#"1(=/141L("67100#(=5+"X#7#3#M"(%"<L0%";7%;%741%(L"/(#"6#<5"5C;571*5(=#0"<%675"0#"4/#0"B#CD500!"WU%*;<%("M"%=7%<";/3157%("=7#6#.#7!"<1(%"T/5";7%K5ML"1(=/141%(5<"475#=1K#<"T/5!"5("0#"*5(=5"*#=5*Q=14#"35"B#CD500!";7%3/.57%("U1;L=5<1<"E7/4=>E57#<+^(" <5G/(3%" 0/G#7!" 50" /<%"5(%7*5*5(=5" 475#=1K%"35"B#CD500" 350"*H=%3%"

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­

;#7=>#"4%("WU%*;<%("M"T/5" 05" 005KL"#"4%*;7%*5=57<5"4%("</;/5<=%<"T/5!"#"0#";%<=75!"75</0=#7%("5C;571*5(=#0*5(=5"4%(R7*#3%<!"4%*%"0#"K50%413#3"R(1=#"

:o" Z+"^1(<=51("M"]+"'(E503!"r]#"5K%0/41L("5("0#"E><14#+"@#*;%"M"750#=1K13#3s!"5("S=5;U5("p#DA1(G!"53+!"La gran ilusión. Las grandes obras de Albert Einstein+"_#7450%(#!"@7>=14#!"89,9!";;+":no2:l9+

En-Claves14-book.indb 32 04/11/13 14:54

Page 24: 1. Las Analogías en La Formulación de La Teoría Electromagnética de La Luz de Maxwell

EN­CLAVES del pensamiento, año VII, núm. 14, julio­diciembre 2013, pp. 11­33.

]#<"#(#0%G>#<"5("0#"E%7*/0#41L("35"0#"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#" ::

35"0#"1(3/441L("5054=7%*#G(H=14#"M"0#"(%"#441L("#"31<=#(41#"35"0#<"#=7#441%(5<"5054=7%*#G(H=14#<+X1(#0*5(=5!"0#<"4%(3141%(5<"=54(%0LG14#<"M";%0>=14#<"35"0#"H;%4#"1(N/M57%("

5("</"1(=57H<";%7"50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"M"5("0#"4#(=13#3"35"3#=%<"#"0%<"T/5"=/K%"#445<%";#7#"=7#6#.#7"4%("500%<+"]#"(#415(=5"(545<13#3"35"/(#"4%*;75(<1L("=5L714#"35"0#"4%(3/441L("35"<5$#05<"5("0%<"4#605<"=505G7QR4%<"</6*#71(%<"4%(<­=1=/ML"/("#01415(=5"M"/(#"E/5(=5"35"3#=%<"*/M"1*;%7=#(=5!"=#(=%";#7#"B#CD500"como para los colegas con quienes competía por comprender los fenómenos 

5054=7%*#G(H=14%<!"4%*%"WU%*;<%(+"̂ ("50";75E#41%"35"</"Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism!"35",no:!"B#CD500"#3*1=5"</"35/3#"4%("0#"=505G7#E>#!"M"#R7*#"T/5"G7#41#<"#"500#"<5"#<1G(L"r/("K#0%7"4%*5741#0"#"U#457"*5313#<"50H4=714#<"4%("5C#4=1=/3s"M"T/5"=#*61H(";57*1=1L"75#01F#7";7/56#<"M"5C;571*5(=%<"r5("/(#"5<4#0#"T/5"=7#<45(3>#";%7"*/4U%"0#"35"0%<"0#6%7#=%71%<"%731(#71%<s!";71K#3%<"%";)6014%<+"\5"U54U%"jM"4%*%"<5$#0#"S4U#EE57j"0#"=505G7#E>#";7%K5ML!"=#*61H(!"/("#;%M%"5*;>714%"47/41#0"#"0#"=5%7>#"35"B#CD500"#"=7#KH<"35"0#<"*53141%(5<"T/5"<5"U14157%("35" 0#"5054=7%<=Q=14#"M"50"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"5(" 0#<" 0>(5#<"35"4%(3/441L("5(=75",nmn"M",nml+@%(" =%3#<"5<=#<" 1(N/5(41#<"M"</"G7#("4#;#413#3" 1(=5054=/#0!"B#CD500" E/5"

4#;#F"35"/(#"U#F#$#"5(%7*5"T/5"K#"1(40/<%"*Q<"#00Q"35"0#"/(1R4#41L("=5L714#"T/5"75;75<5(=#"</"=5%7>#"5054=7%*#G(H=14#"35"0#"0/F+"P"5<"T/5"B#CD500"0%G7L!"#<1*1<*%!" =7#<45(357" 0#" E><14#"35" 0#"*54Q(14#"(5D=%(1#(#"j35" E/57F#<"T/5"#4=)#("<%675"%6.5=%<"4%("*#<#j!"M"#";5<#7"35"U#657"=7#6#.#3%"4%("#(#0%G>#<"*54Q(14#<!"E/5"4#;#F"35"17"*Q<"#00Q"5"1*#G1(#7"/(#"(/5K#"E><14#"5("0#"T/5"0%<"4#*;%<"5054=7%*#G(H=14%<!"/(#"K5F"475#3%<!"<%("#0G%"75#0!"T/5"5C1<=5("M"#4=)#("<5G)("0#<"05M5<"T/5"35<47161L"5("</<"54/#41%(5<+h%7")0=1*%!"/(#"(%=#"<%675"50"4%*5(=#71%"T/5"U141*%<"5("0#"1(=7%3/441L("35"

5<=5"#7=>4/0%!"<%675"<1"0#"415(41#"#K#(F#";71*57%"4%*%"415(41#";/7#!"M"35<;/H<"4%*%"415(41#"#;014#3#+"^0"4#<%"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%!"M"5<;54>R4#*5(=5"</"1(=57750#41L("4%("0#"=54(%0%G>#"35"0%<"4#605<"=505G7QR4%<"</6*#71(%<!"*/5<=7#"T/5"(%"5C1<=5"/("%735("40#7%!"M"T/5"0#"=54(%0%G>#"M"0#"=5%7>#"<5"75E/57F#("#0=57­(#=1K#*5(=5!"5("/(#"5<;17#0"5("0#"T/5"#*6#<"<5"#01*5(=#("</45<1K#*5(=5"35"0#"%=7#+"a%"U#M"415(41#";/7#";71*57%"M"35<;/H<"415(41#"#;014#3#+"^0"4#<%"350"5054=7%*#G(5=1<*%"*/5<=7#"T/5"0#<"3%<"<5"K#("475#(3%"5(";#<%<"</45<1K%<!"1*;/0<Q(3%<5"*/=/#*5(=5+

X54U#"35"7545;41L(V"89�9o�89,8X54U#"35"#45;=#41L(V"9i�98�89,:

En-Claves14-book.indb 33 04/11/13 14:54