mk tz-f ogi0x[a ogatua - cornell universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/mcm1998paper.pdf ·...

29

Upload: others

Post on 17-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

�� ������������������! "�

#%$�&('*)+)-,.�$0/�1!23&�1!46587%905-5+:

; <>=%?A@�B�@�=%CD=%EF@HG�IJ@�K�=�LNM�GPO�Q�=%C

�%R��TSVUW�YXZX[�Y\�]_^`��a[aTbcSdU%]%e�]_f^g^g�Yh��ji(�Y�Yk�a�X[fl\m��i�npogX[aqa[XZr�k��Yi0X[a�XZfpk��YXZ�Y\[�qogi��X[R��Fs%ogi�i��Y\Za�futW�vh��Yi��Y\Zfr�a����w\[ogX%a[xyR�f�^`��\[aZR�ogzjs%R(o{xyRToga|fi�^g}j�!s%�u\Zk��YkTXZf�aZX[r�k��wi~XZa�u�qfi�hqX[R��vXZfz���������di0t�f\[XZr�i+��X[�Y^g}0�Ak�r��vXZfjh�\m��k��vogi0���uXZogfi8�-X[R(���!��Y\y�uh�Fh\y�uk��hog��wij�uX_SdU%]6]_f�^{^g�Yh��doga%�uivS%�Y����\m��k�ogX[ogfi+��^+�P�-SF� a_�u\[��XZR~r(aWi��!�u\[^g}v�q���ui�ogi�h�^g�Ya[a!�a[ogi�xY�Fa[fq�j��i~}vaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[aPR+�!����z�\m��xYX[ogx���^{^g}�X[R(�Pam�����P�P�-S"�(s%ogX[RTaZf��j��i0}vS"� a���i�kS%�Y� adhog���Yi�fr�X!�3�%R��PXZ\m��k�ogX[ogfi+��^8�P�-SH�u^gaZf"z�r(i�oga[R��Ya�aZX[r�k��wi~XZa|t�f\%Xy�un0ogi�h"k(o���xwr�^gXxYfr(\[a[�wa����Ya[z-�YxYo��u^g^g}�s%R��Yi�X[R��Fh\y�uk��F�!��Y\y�uh��o{a|a[fqR�oghR8�d�|i��F^gfusW�w\dh\y�uk���t�\[f����k�o���xYr�^gX%xYf�r�\[aZ�"x���i��j�un����FaZX[r�k��wi~X|t���^g^Ao{i�xY^���a[a%\m��i�n��+�wR�ogi�k�a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a�s%R�fvXy�un�fi�^g}v����a[og�Y\%xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya��_�%R���Xy�ua[nvoga%XZf"k��w�~ogaZ�������wX[R�f0k�XZR+�uX%s%og^g^-a[�Yz+��\m��X[�P�ui�k�\y�ui�nX[R���a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a!�+aZfvX[R+��X%X[R���aZxmR(f^��u\Za[R�ogz��j�!}F�+�|t���og\[^g}��!s���\[k��wk8�

�%R��Fk�����i�f�t�XZR��"xwf^g^g�Yh�FX[R�f�r�hR0X�X[R-�uX�xYf�qz+�u\Zogi�hv���uxyR�a[XZr�k��Yi0XPXZfjXZR��vfXZR��Y\a[XZr�k��Yi0X[aqogip����xmR�xYfr�\Za[��s_fr�^gkp�-�T�ui��y�A�YxYXZo{���Ts%�!}�XZf���r�og^gkJ��\m�ui(n~ogi�h-�p�3��xmRh\y�uk��Ps_fr(^{kq�+��xYf�qz+�u\Z�YkT�uh~��ogi�a[X%f�X[R��Y\|h\y�uk��Ya t�\[f��¡X[R(�PxYfr(\[a[�FX[fvk(�YX[�Y\Z��ogi���o�t��a[XZr�k��Yi0X%s%�uaW���+fu���d�!��Y\y�uh���~�!���Y\m��h���f\¢�+�Y^gfus6�!��w\m�uh��dogivX[R(�%xY^��ua[a!�3]_f�v��ogi�ogi�hX[R���o{i£t�f\Z�j�uXZogfi�t�\[f����u^g^-xYfr�\Za[�Ya�xYf�r�^gkT�u^g^gfusJaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[adXZfv�+��\y�ui�n��YkTogi�k��wxYog^{�wa��

�%R���z�\Zf��^g�Y�¡R-�ua_t�f�r�\%�j�Y¤¥f\3¦0r��YaZX[ogfi(adX[fF�-�"�ui�aZsW�w\[�Yk8§

¨ S|a[aZr���ogi�h�XZR+�uXvXZR��Th\y�uk��wajh�og��Yi�fr(XvR+�!��Tz(^{r(a[�Ya��ui�k���ogi0r�aZ�Ya��_x���i6X[R��k(���ui8� a%ogk����F�-���j��k��dXZfvsWf�\[n�©¨ S|a[aZr���ogi�hPXZR+�uX_X[R(��h�\m��k��Ya%hog���Yi�f�r�X���\[�|s%o{XZR�fr(XWz�^gr�aZ�Yad�ui(k���ogi0r�aZ�Ya���fi�^g}�A�uX%^g�YX[XZ�Y\dh�\m��k��Ya��(x��ui�XZR���k����ui�� a%ogk��!�F�+���j��k��dXZfvsWf�\[n�©¨ ]%��iT�ui0}vfXZR��Y\daZxyR��Y���wa%z�\[f0k�r�xw�"�Fk��YaZo{\Z�YkT\y�ui�n0ogi�h~©¨ S�xYf�i�xY�Y\Zi�oga�X[R+��X�X[R��%h�\m�uk(�%o{iF�daZogi�h^g�_xYfr�\Za[�|xYfr�^gkFxyR+�ui�h��W���ui0}daZX[r�k(�Yi0X�� ak(�YxYog^g�Ya��¢ª«a%X[R�oga%z-fa[aZog��^g��©

��f��!��fogkPxYf�i0t�r�aZogfi8�us_�_s%o{^g^0r�aZ�%X[R��_t�f�^g^{fus%ogi�h%k(�y¬+i�ogX[ogf�i�a�t�f\3�u�v�(o{h�r�fr(aAsWf�\[k�a!�8S­ xw^`��a[a¯®Woga�� h\Zfr�zPf�t+a[XZr�k��Yi0XZa3s%R�fP�u^g^h�\m��k�r+�uXZ����X8XZR��Way�u�q�3X[og�����yt�f�\8�Y°��u�qz�^g��!X[R��xY^��uaZa%fut��!±±�±��AS ­ xYfr(\[a[�¥®�oga%�Ph�\[f�r�z�f�t8a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a|�+�Yogi�hFogi�a[XZ\[r�xwX[�YkT�0}���z�\[f�t��YaZa[f\!�s%R�f��uaZa[oghi(ad�Fh\m��k���X[fF���uxyRTaZX[r�k(�Yi0X��

����h�v��fut3�±

Page 2: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

� ����M8@�K�=%M��NGPE�?����=%M�B�@�wGPE�?

�%R��P�q�YX[R�f0k�a[R(fr�^gk�\[�Ys%�u\ZkTa[XZr�k��Yi0XZa�� h\Z���uXZ�Y\�����fr(i~X¢t�f�\%a[xYf�\[ogi�h�s_�Y^g^Aogi���f\Z�k�o���xYr�^gXdxwfr�\Za[�Ya�X[R-�uiTogiT����a[og�Y\�xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya���ª«X|sWf�r�^gk ��^ga[f��-�Pz-faZo{XZog��PXZf�k�oga[xwfr�\y�uh�h\y�uk��Fogi0���uXZogfi8�%S%X�XZR��"ay�u�q��XZog����(X[R��FxYf^g^g�Yh��P�j�!}qs%o{aZRTX[f��!�f�o{k�k�ogaZxYfr�\y�uh�o{i(ha[XZr�k��Yi0X[a_t�\[f�NXy�un0ogi�h�xYfr(\[a[�wa%fr�XZa[ogk��%X[R(�Yog\3�j�Y¤¥f\[a!�wt�f\�t�����\3futAa[xwf\[ogi�h�sWf�\[a[�%XZR+�uia[XZr�k��Yi0X[a�s%R�fF�j�w¤yf\3ogi�X[R(fa[��xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya�� k��Yz+��\[X[�q�Yi0X[a!�

� � ?�? ��C��q@�!GPE�?NB�E���������G�@�K�=%?8=%?

�%R���t�f�^g^{fus%ogi�hP��a[a[r(��z�XZo{f�i�a_sW�Y\Z�P�j��k��%s%R��Yi�Xm�uxyn0^gogi�hPX[R(�Pz�\[f���^g�Y��§

¨ ª«X_ogaWz-faZa[og��^g�%X[fv�uaZa[oghi���a[ogi�h�^g�%i~r(�v�+�Y\!�f�\ ­ �u�(o{^gogX«}PaZxYf\Z�y®¥�0XZf"�!�uxyR�aZX[r�k��wi~X!�s%R(o{xyR�ogi�k�ogx���X[�YavXZR��Yog\v\[�Y^���X[og��qa[xyR�f^���a[X[ogxT�u�(o{^gogX«}��ui�k8�¢ogipz+��\[X[ogxYr(^`��\��¢X[R��Yog\s_f\ZX[R�ogi��wa[adf�t�XZR��Pa[xyR�f�^��u\[aZR�ogz8��ª«ijf�X[R��w\ds_f\[k(a��0s_�Px��ui�\y�ui�nvaZX[r�k��wi~XZa��

¨ �%R(�P\m��i�n�a[R�f�r�^gkj�-�FX[\m��i�a[ogXZo{������XZR+�uX|oga���o�t��Hoga%\y�ui�n��YkTR�oghR(�Y\dXZR+�ui�� �A��i�k�>o{a�\y�ui�n��Yk�R�oghR��w\�XZR+�ui�����X[R��Yi�� aZR�fr�^gk��+�v\y�ui�n��Yk�R�oghR(�Y\�X[R+��i��������x!�ui�X[R��w\[�yt�f�\[�Fa[f�\[X%X[R(��aZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a��0}v\m�ui(n��

¨ �%R(�Pz+�w\«t�f�\[�j��i�xY�Pf�tW�ui�ogi�k�og�0o{k(r+�u^AaZX[r�k��wi~X�ogiT�u^g^AxYf�r�\[aZ�YaPoga%z+f�a[ogX[og���Y^g}�xYf�\«�\Z�Y^��uXZ�Yk8��aZogi�xY�§

�%R��Y\Z��ogav��k��Yh\Z�Y�Tf�t�h��Yi��Y\y�u^��uz�XZo{XZr�k���xYf�\[\[�wa[z-fi�k�ogi�hlX[f�XZR��T�u��og^gogX«}a[xYf�\[�Fs%R�ogxyR��Y���Y\[}�a[XZr�k��Yi0X|z+f�a[a[�wa[a[�wa�� Sd^g^3z�\Zfut��wa[a[f�\[a!��s%R�og^{�FX[R(�Yog\Ph\y�uk��v�!��Y\y�uh��YaP�j�!}�k�o��A�Y\���\m��i�nTaZX[r�k��wi~XZas%ogX[R�ogi�X[R��wo{\%xwfr�\Za[�Ya��uxYxYf�\[k�ogi�hvXZfva[og��og^��u\�xY\ZogX[�Y\Zo`�(�

¨ ��R�og^{��XZR��Y\[�F�j�!}F�-�"�Fk�o����w\[�Yi�xw�v�+�YX«s_�Y�Yi�h\y�uk��wadogi�xYfr�\Za[�Ya�s%R�ogxyR�\[�y�-�YxYX[aXZR���aZX[r�k(�Yi0X�� a��uz�XZogX[r�k��Ft�f\PXZR���z+��\[XZo{xwr�^��u\PaZr��¤y�YxYXZa��_X[R(o{a�R+�uaFfi�^g}���a[���u^g^�¥���YxwX��-�+�wx��ur�aZ�§

"! X[r(k��Yi0X[a�a[�w^{�wxYXd�Y^g�YxwX[og��Ya�ogij�F���ui�i(�Y\%R�oghR�^g}vogi0�+r(�Yi�xY�Yk��~}qX[R��wo{\|a[n0og^g^�uX�X[R(�"aZr��¤y�YxYXZa"�!��uog^��u�(^{���0o�� ��g�(a[X[r(k��Yi0X[aPXZ�Yi�k�X[f�a[�w^{�wxYX�X[R��vxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya"��Xs%R�ogxyRjXZR��Y}T�u\Z����faZXWXy�u^g�Yi0X[�wk�t�\[f���

Sd^g^3aZX[r�k��wi~XZa"aZR�fr(^{k��j�w¤yf\|o{i��ui��u\Z���qfut%�Y°0z+�w\[X[ogaZ���a[fTXZR+�uX�XZR��Y}��u\[���f�a[X_Xm�u^g�Yi0XZ�YkT�uX%xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya�s%o{XZR�ogi�f�\%xY^gfa[�w^{}v\Z�Y^��uXZ�YkTX[fvXZR��Yog\%�j�w¤yf\Za�� ]_fr�\Za[�Ya�s%R�ogxmR �u\[��\[�w¦~r(o{\Z�Yk �~}�XZR���xwf^g^g�Yh�T\Z�y�+�YxwX��ui6�w��z�R+��a[oga�f�iX[R��Fz+��\[Xdf�tWX[R(�PxYf^g^g�Yh����-o�� ��g�(�Y��Yi�o�t3X[R��F\[�Y¦0r�og\Z�Yk�xwfr�\Za[�Ya"��\[� ­ r�i0t«�uog\«®�+�wx��ur�aZ�TX[R(�Y}J��\[��sW�wo{h�R0X[�YklX[fus%�u\[k(a"f�i���a[r��¤y�wxYX��_�� h+�g��s%\Zo{XZogi�h+��XZR+�uXogadXm��n�Yi�X[f��-�FX[R��PxyR�f�ogxY�"f�t3X[R��FxYf^g^g�Yh����XZR+�uX|R�oghR�^g}�\y�ui�n��YkTaZX[r�k��wi~XZa�vr�a[X_k�fvs_�Y^g^Afi�X[R(��\Z�Y¦0r�og\[�Yk�xYfr�\Za[�Ya!�

¨�# fXW��^g^�xYfr(\[a[�wa%R+�!��%XZR��day�u���_k�o���xYr�^gX«}0�A�%R+��XWoga���o{X¢o{a¢���uaZo{�w\WXZfP���u\Zij��R(o{h�Rh�\m��k���o{i�aZf���|xYfr(\[a[�wadX[R-�ui�ogi�fXZR��Y\Za��

����h�P�Ffut3�±

Page 3: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

¨ �%R(��xYf�\[\Z�Ya[z-fi�k(�Yi�xY�lfut"h�\m�uk(�Ya�X[fph�\m��k��Tz-fogi0X[a�ogaT�ua t�f^g^gfus%a�§���������(��� ��� �(��� ����� �(����������(����� �������S�z�^gr�a�t�f�^{^gfus%ogi�h��Th�\m�uk(��\m��oga[�YaXZR��dh�\m��k��dz-fogi0XW�0}Ffi��¥��XZR�og\[k8�0s%R�og^g�d���qo{i0r�a¢^{fus_�Y\Za3ogXW�0}FX[R��|am�u�q�d�u�qfr�i0Xbco«� ���{����i���������� ���s%R�og^g�P�!�#"�������ew�

¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XZadXy�un�P��¬+°0�Yk�xYf�r�\[aZ�Y^gf~��k�t�f\%����xmR�aZ�Y���YaZX[�Y\ t�f\_�YoghR0X%aZ�Y���YaZX[�Y\Za��¨ �%R(���!���Y\m��h��h\y�uk���h�o{���Yij��X%SdU%] ]_f�^g^{�wh�doga%S �¥���%R0r�a%s_�P�ua[aZr����|X[R+��X%X[R���!���Y\m��h�d�P�-S�f�t�aZX[r�k��wi~XZaWoga3�uX¢^{�!�ua[X%$��&��!X[R(�%a[�j��^g^{�wa[X�i0r��v�+�w\8s%R�ogxyRv\[f�r�i�k�aXZf��ui�S%�Y�

¨ ª«i�h��Yi��Y\y�u^«��aZX[r�k��wi~X �Na[R�f�r�^gk��-�P\m��i�n�wk ��R�����kjf�t�aZX[r�k��wi~X �Ho�tm§

�NR+�ua%�-�YXZX[�Y\�h\y�uk��wa%X[R+��i��v� �NXm��n�Ya��P�qf\[�|xyR+�u^g^g�Yi�h�o{i(h"xYf�r�\[aZ�Y^gf~��kjXZR+�ui��v� b ����\Z�YxYfh�i�o('Y��X[R-�uXTXZR�ogajz-fogi0X�ogajk(�Y�+�uXZ���u�(^{�!e � R+��a��l��f\Z�Ts_�Y^g^��\[f�r�i�k��Yk�xYfr�\Za[�Y^gf0�uk8�

) � E�BPQ ��? �!?NG�I6LNM�GPO�Q�=%C B�E�� L6G�?8? �!O�Q�=�* G ��=%Q!?

+-,/. 02143�576�8�9;:/3=< >@?BA�1 0!6�CED;?FA�?/8�G;CE:IHJ5#KMLNCEG4O-?PG-Q�%R��TXZ\m�uk(o{XZogfi+��^W�q�YX[R�f0klfut�\y�ui�n0ogi�h�a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a!�%xYf�����f�i�^g}Tn0i�fus%iJ��avX[R��T��\y�uk����fogi0XPS8���Y\m��h��¢f\"�P�-SF�AxYf�i�a[oga[XZavfut%Xm��n~ogi�h�X[R��q������i�f�tdX[R��qh\m��k��vz-fogi0X[aPXZR+�uX��aZX[r�k��wi~X����u\Zi�a�o{i����uxyR fut"R�ogaqxYfr�\Za[�Ya!�P�ui�k�X[R��Yi xYf���z+��\[ogi�h�X[R(�Ya[�����^{r(�Ya�XZfk��YXZ�Y\[�qo{i(��xw^`��a[a%\y�ui�nA�

�%R��_og�����wk�o��uX[��z�\Zf��^g�Y� s%ogX[RPXZR��%X[\y�uk�ogX[ogf�i+�u^��P�-S�\m��i�n0ogi�hdoga�X[R+��X3ogX�k�f0�Ya3i�f�Xa[r0��xwo{�wi~XZ^g}�k�oga[XZogi�hr�ogaZRj�-�YX«s_�Y�Yi�a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a!� �6R��Yi�X[R(�"�!��Y\y�uh���h�\m��k��Pogad�ui�S%�Y�+��^g^�u�-fu��y�[�!��w\m�uh���a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a�s%ogX[R�ogiT�ui0}qxY^��ua[a%\Z�YxY�Yog���"XZR��Pam�����|h\m��k���-S"�(�%R0r�a��(s%o{XZRfi�^g}�t�fr(\PX[fTaZog°TxY^��uaZa[�Yavz-�Y\Fa[�Y�q�Ya[XZ�Y\���t�r(^{^g}Tf�i��va[og°0X[Rlfut%X[R��qa[XZr�k��Yi0XF�+f0k�}�x��ui�+�F�Y°0z-�YxYX[�wk�X[fv����\[i��SR+� �Ff\|R�oghR��Y\��P�-S"�UT%�%R�ogad���un��YaWogX��u^g^A��r�X|o{�qz+f�a[aZo{�(^{��XZfk�oga[XZo{i(hr�oga[R��+�YX«s_�Y�Yi�X[R(�P¬+\Za[XP�ui(kTa[�Yxwfi�k�k��YxYog^g�Ya�s%ogX[R���i0}~XZR�ogi�hv\[�wa[�Y�v��^gogi�hv\Z�Y^go���u��og^gogX«}~��V(r�\ZX[R��Y\Z��f�\[��A�ui0}qR�oghR0�«\m��i�n0o{i(h"aZX[r�k��wi~X�����\[i�ogi�h�� �+�w^{fus_�[�!��w\m�uh���h\m��k���t�f\��ui0}�\[����a[f�i8�uoga8��\Zr�Xm��^g^{}|z�r�i�ogaZR��Yk8�uk(\[fz(z�ogi�hdXZfdX[R(�3�+f�X[XZf�Nfut-X[R��3aZ�YxYf�i�kvk��YxYog^g��o�t�i�f�XAt���\[XZR��Y\����%R(o{a�oga3�%\Z�Ya[r�^gX3f�t�XZR��_�Y°0X[\[�w���Y^g}PR�ogh�R"�!��Y\y�uh��Wh�\m�uk(���o�t+XZR��d�!��w\m�uh��h\y�uk���s_�Y\[�P^gfus_�Y\��0XZR��Y\Z�PsWf�r�^gk��-�"�F�j��\[h�o{i�t�f�\%�Y\[\Zf\%t�f\_X[fz�aZX[r�k��wi~XZa��

�di£t�f\ZX[r�i+��X[�Y^g}0�!X[R��%XZ\m�uk(o{XZogfi+��^£���-SJ�w°£��xY�Y\Z�+�uXZ�YaWogXZa�fus%iFz�\Zf��^g�Y�qa��0}P�wi�xYfr(\«��uh�o{i(hPX[R��|h\y�uk��%ogi0����X[ogfivs%R(o{xyRv���un�wa�ogX3aZf"r(a[�Y^g�YaZa�� ! o{i(xY�dogX3k�f0�Ya_i�f�XWxYf�\[\Z�YxYX_t�f�\xYfr(\[a[�qk�o���xYr�^gX«}0�Aa[XZr�k��Yi0X[aFs%og^g^�aZ�Y�Yn�f�r�X����uaZo{^g}�h\y�uk��Yk�xwfr�\Za[�Ya!�7V+��xY�Yk�s%ogX[R�X[R��z�\[f�a[z-�YxYXFfutWk(�YxY^gogi�ogi�h��Yi(\[f^g^g���wi~Xd��i�k�z+f0f\|a[XZr�k��Yi0XP�Y���^gr+�uXZo{f�i�a��-z�\Zfut��wa[a[f�\[aPs%R(fh\y�uk��_a[XZ\[ogxYX[^g}Ps%og^g^�t��Y�Y^0z�\Z�Ya[aZr�\[�|X[f�\[�w^`��°PX[R(�Yog\�h�\m��k�ogi�h%a[Xy�ui�k+��\[k�a!��ª«i�a[XZ\[r�xwX[f\ZaWs%R(fh\y�uk��q���uaZo{^g}Ts%og^g^3�-��\Z�Ys���\[k��wkps%ogX[R�R�ogh�R��Yi(\[f^g^g���wi~XP��i�k��Y°0xY�Y^g^g�Yi0X"�w��u^gr+�uXZogfi�a!�z+f�X[�Yi0XZo`��^g^{}v^g����k�ogi�hFX[fvz�\Zf��f�X[ogfi��A�%R�oga%xY\[�!�uX[�wa��FaZX[\Zfi�hvz�r(a[RTXZfus���\[k�a%h�\m�uk(��ogi0����uXZogfi8�AaZogi�xY�FX[R��vXZ\m�uk(o{XZogfi+��^��P�-S z�r�i�oga[R(�YaP�-fX[R�X[R(�va[X[r(k��Yi0XPXm��n0o{i(hj�vk(o���xwr�^gXxYfr(\[a[�v�ui(k�X[R(�Pz�\[f�t��YaZa[f\%XZ���uxyR�ogi�hvogX!�WYX[Z/\]Z/^`_aZ/b%_dcae^`fgihkj�_almZ=\mcahonPZ/gag�bmZPgdnPcdep]Z/b%eq#rsZ/n/_aeh`q%t�useZ/fb-_almegicdZPgdvmf_Pw

����h�#$Ffut3�±

Page 4: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

Sdi0}la[}0a[XZ�Y�Dogi~XZ�Yi�k��wk6X[fl\[�Yz�^���xY�TX[R(�TX[\y�uk�ogX[ogf�i+�u^d�P�-S aZR�fr(^{k �uk�k�\Z�Ya[aqX[R�ogaz�\[f���^g�Y����a[fvXZR+�uX%h�\m��k���o{i£���uXZo{f�i�s%og^g^+�-�"��\[\[�wa[X[�wk��ui�k�R�f�z+�¥t�r�^g^g}v\[�Y���Y\[aZ�Yk8�

Sdi(fX[R(�Y\Pz-fX[�wi~XZo��u^3xYf�i�xY�Y\Zipoga�X[R+��XPX[R(�vX[\m��k�ogX[ogfi-�u^3�P�-S �Yi�xYf�r�\m��h�Ya�a[z-�YxYo��u^��o('��uXZo{f�i��0}Fa[X[r(k��Yi0X[a!� ! ogi�xY��aZX[r�k��wi~XZa%X[�Yi(kjXZf"z-�Y\¯t�f\Z�¡�+�wX[X[�w\dogivxYfr(\[a[�wad\[�w^`��X[�Yk�XZfX[R��wo{\����Y¤yf\Za��wX[R��%�P�-Sps%og^g^u\[�ws���\[kFa[X[r(k��Yi0X[a3s%R(fdXm��n�W��aAt��wspxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya3fr(X[a[ogk��¢X[R��Yog\­ xwf�vt�f\[X;'Yfi(�y® ��aPz-fa[aZog��^g��8�ui(k�z�r�i�oga[R�a[XZr�k��Yi0XZa"s%R�fT��X[X[�w��z�X|X[fT�Y°0z+��i�k�X[R��Yog\R�f\Zo('Yfi�a!� ���vi�fXZ��3R�fus_�Y���Y\���XZR+�uXFogi�k�og�0o{k(r+�u^�xYf�^{^g�Yh��YaF�j�!}Tf�\"���!}ji(fXF\[�Yh0�u\[kX[R�oga%�ua%�Pz(\[f�(^{�w� �uXZR���\[�Y^��uXZog��%��u^gr��waWf�t8a[z-�YxYo��u^go('��uXZogfi��ui(k�s_�Y^g^��«\[f�r�i�k��wk�i��YaZad�u\[�fz-�YiTXZf"k��w�+�uXZ��

+-,�� 02146�3[3 5 8���� ?P94:P3��-8�:�� A ?P8�G�ª«ij��\m��i�n0o{i(hPfut8aZX[r�k��wi~XZa%�+�uaZ�Yk�fivXZR��Yog\Wz-�Y\¯t�f\Z�j�ui(xY�Ya_\[�Y^��uXZog��dXZfP����xmR�f�X[R��Y\!�0X[R��t�f^g^gfus%ogi�hPxYf�i�a[ogk��w\m�uXZogfi�ad��^{aZf"xwf���|ogi~XZf"z(^`�!}0�

¨ ª«X�oga8i�f�X8z-fa[aZog��^g�3X[f|xYf�qz+�u\Z�3a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a�¤yr(a[X8XZfdf�X[R��Y\Za�o{i�X[R��Yog\�xY^��ua[a!� ! X[r�k��wi~XZaf�t�X[�wijXy�un���xwfr�\Za[�Ya|o{i�s%R�ogxyRT�u^g^-fX[R(�Y\daZX[r�k��wi~XZad�-�Y^gfi�hvXZf ��i�fXZR��Y\|xY^��ua[a!�¨ ����R+�!���dXZfvxYf�qz�r�X[�|\m��i�n0o{i(ha%a[�wz+�u\y�uX[�w^{}q���uxyRTaZ�Y���wa[X[�w\����-�Yx���r�a[�FX[R(��z-f0f^f�t�aZX[r�k��wi~XZa�xmR-�ui�h��Ya%k�r��PXZf"h�\m��k�r+�uXZogfij��i�k��j��X[\[ogxYr(^`��X[ogfi��¨ ª«X%oga%i�f�X%z+f�a[aZo{�(^{��X[fFXm�un��Pogi0X[fv�uxYxYf�r�i0X%ogi�k��Yz-�Yi�k��wi~X�aZX[r�k�og�Ya!���-�Yx���r�a[�FX[R��w\[�oga%i�f��+f0k�}qX[fFxYf�qz+�u\Z�dXZf+�¨ ª«X�o{a�i�f�XPz-fa[aZog��^g�"XZfTXm��n�Fo{i0XZf ��xYxYf�r�i0XPz+�uaZa� t��uog^�xYfr(\[a[�wa"�-�Yx���r�a[��X[R(�Y}�k(fi(fXd�uaZa[oghi�\Z�Y^��uX[og���dh\y�uk��wa��

���P\[�wxYfh�i�o('Y�"XZR�\[�w�vz+f�X[�Yi0X[o���^8a[f�^gr�X[ogfi(adX[fqX[R�oga|z�\[f���^g�Y���_�%R���t�f^g^gfus%ogi�hPaZ�YxYX[ogf�i�as%og^{^Ak(�Ya[xY\Zog�+�PXZR��Y�>ogij�qf\Z�dk��YXy�uog^«�

�%R��|¬+\Za[X%oga%X[R�� ! Xy�ui�k-�u\[k # f\[���u^go('Y�Yk��P�-SF�0ª«X���a[aZr����Ya%XZR+�uX%h�\m��k��Ya%s%ogX[R�ogi��xYfr(\[a[�Fa[R(fr�^gk��+��i�f\Z�j�u^g^g}Fk�oga[X[\Zog��r�X[�wk8�A�ui�k��j��z�a%�u^g^8h�\m�uk(�Yads%ogX[R(o{iq���uxyRTxwfr�\Za[�X[f����+�Y^g^|xYr�\[����N�3�uxyR6aZX[r�k(�Yi0Xjogavh�o{���Yi6��\[�Y�0oga[�wk �P�-S �+��a[�Yk6f�i�R�ogaj�!��w\m�uh��z+f�a[ogX[ogf�ijf�i�XZR��P�-�Y^g^AxYr�\[���Ya%t�f\%����xmR�f�t�R(o{a_xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya��

�%R��PaZ�YxYf�i�k�oga|X[R��Fª«X[�Y\y�uXZ�Yk # f\Z�j�u^go('Y�YkT�P�-SF��ª«X��uX[XZ�Y��z(X[a%X[fqxYf\Z\[�YxwX�t�f\|X[R����u\Z}~ogi�hFk�o���xYr�^gXZo{�wa%fut3xYfr(\[a[�wa��%ª«i�X[R(�Yf\Z}~�(�Y��Y\Z}�h\m��k��Ph�o{���Yi�XZf��Fa[XZr�k��Yi0X�a[R�f�r�^gk�+���uz(z�\[fu°0og�j��X[�Y^g}��Y¦0r+�u^|X[f�R�ogaj���-S"��a[flX[R����!��Y\y�uh��h\m��k��Th�o{���Yi�ogi ��xwfr�\Za[�a[R�f�r�^gk��+���u�-fr�Xv�Y¦0r+��^%X[f�X[R��T�!���Y\m��h�j���-S�f�t�a[XZr�k��Yi0XZa�ogi�X[R+��XvxYfr(\[a[�����%R�ogaa[xyR��Y�q�P\[�wz+����X[�Yk(^{}T��k�¤yr�aZX[a���^g^AX[R��Ph�\m��k���z+f�o{i0XZa%o{i�����xyRTxYfr(\[a[��r�i0X[og^8XZR��"�!��w\m�uh��h\y�uk���ogi��Y��Y\Z}�xYfr�\Za[�P�w¦~r-�u^ga%X[R��P�!���Y\m��h�P�P�-S fut�XZR��P�Yi(\[f^g^g�Yk�a[XZr�k��Yi0XZa��

�%R��3XZR�og\[kPoga�X[R�� � ���uaZX«� ! ¦0r+�u\Z�Ya���ª«X��uaZa[r��q�Ya8XZR+�uX!��f�X[R��w\8X[R(o{i(ha8�-�Yogi�h|�Y¦0r+�u^«�!X[R��k�o����w\[�Yi�xw�v�+�YX«s_�Y�Yi�X«s_f�aZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a�� h\m��k��Ya|s%o{^g^��+�F�Y¦0r+�u^�XZf�X[R(�Pk�o����w\[�Yi�xw�vo{i�X[R��Yog\�u��og^gogX«}�aZxYf\Z�Ya��|ª«XP�uX[XZ�Y��z(X[a%X[f ¬+i�kTXZR��YaZ� ����og^{ogX«}qa[xYf�\[�Ya��0}�a[f^g�0ogi�hvX[R(�Pa[}0a[XZ�Y��f�t�Y¦0r+�uXZogfi�aPh��Yi��Y\y�uXZ�Yk��~}�����xmR�xwfr�\Za[��bgt�f�\P�Y°��u�qz�^g��Ao�t%a[X[r(k��Yi0X � h�YXZa ��i�S¡��r�Xa[XZr�k��Yi0X � h�YXZa ��U���X[R(�Yi������ ����� e ! o{i(xY��3ogip��i~}�i�f�i0��XZ\[og�0o��u^3z-fz�r(^`��X[ogfi��X[R�ogaPaZ}0a[X[�w� R-�uaPi�f�aZf^gr�X[ogf�i8�A���wX[R�f0k�a�fut%^g���uaZX«�«a[¦0r+��\[�Yav�uz�z(\[fu°0og�j�uXZogfiT�u\Z�vr�a[�YkX[fv�uz�z(\[fu°0og�j�uXZ�WXZR��YaZ�P��u^gr��Ya!�8�%R(��aZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a���\[�|X[R��Yi�\y�ui�n��Ykj��xYxYf\Zk�ogi�hFX[fv�u��og^gogX«}a[xYf�\[��

����h� Rvfut3�±

Page 5: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

� � K�=��F@�BPE ��BPM ���VGPM�CDBPQ ���_= �� L��

,/. ��8i> �mA���8�6�O ��%R�� ! Xm��i�k+�u\Zk # f�\[���u^go('Y�YkP�P�-Spoga�z+�Y\ZR+�uz(a�XZR��_a[og��z�^g�YaZX8�q�YX[R�f0k8�!�ui�k�X[R��_���YXZR�f0k��f�a[XFo{i�n��Y�Yz�ogi�h�s%ogX[RlX[R����d�!�ui8� ava[r(hh�wa[X[ogf�i8�JV�f�\vX[R���h�\m�uk(�Ya�ogip�!�uxyR6xYf�r�\[aZ��X[R��v�q���ui��ui(k�XZR��va[Xy�ui�k+��\[k�k��w�~o���X[ogfi��u\Z�vxYf�qz�r�X[�wk8� ���"XZR��Yi�k��YXZ�Y\[�qogi��vR�fus�j��i~}�aZXm��i�k+�u\Zk�k��Y�0o��uX[ogf�i�a��u�-fu���f\v�-�Y^gfus¡XZR��T���!�uip�!�uxyR6a[XZr�k��Yi0X!� aqh\y�uk���oga���%R�ogaPa[Xy�ui�k-�u\[klk��Y�0o��uXZo{f�i��q���uaZr�\[�w���Yi0X�X[R��wip�-�YxYf�q�YaPXZR��va[XZr�k��Yi0X�� a ­ h�\m��k��y®vt�f�\X[R��vxw^`��a[a!���3�uxyR�aZX[r�k��wi~X!� aPa[Xy�ui�k+��\[k�k��w�~o���X[ogfi ­ h\y�uk��wa«®j�u\Z�"XZR��Yip�!���Y\m��h�Yk�t�f�\P�fu��Y\y�u^g^ ­ ���-S%®W�q���uaZr�\[�Y�q�Yi0X��A�%R(�WaZX[r�k��wi~XZa���\[�_X[R��wiv\m�ui(n�YkF�0}PX[R�oga3�!��w\m�uh������-Sz+�w\«t�f�\[�j��i�xY����%R(o{a_oga���¦0r+�ui0XZo�¬-�Yk����Y\[aZo{f�i�f�t8X[R����|���ui�� a_a[r(hh�wa[X[ogf�i�X[fF\m��i�nv����xmRa[XZr�k��Yi0Xj��a��!��Y\y�uh���_�+�Y^gfus �!��Y\y�uh���3f�\��u�-fu��T�!��Y\y�uh��jogil���uxyR6xY^���a[a��%��i�k�X[R��YixYf�v�(o{i(�dX[R(��ogi0t�f\[���uXZo{f�iPt�f\d��\m�ui(n~ogi�h-�

,�� � A�6�3[G-Q�A�1 � C�G;D���3=CEO-G;3 ��� 3 ��%R�oga����YXZR�f0kJR-�ua�a[�Y���Y\m��^"�uk(��ui0Xm��h�Ya!�Hª«Xqo{aqt���og\[^g}p����a[}�X[f�x���^gxYr�^��uXZ��%i�f�XjXZf0f�vr�xyRp�qf\[�qk�o���xYr�^gXFX[R+��iJXZR���a[Xy�ui�k+��\[k ���-S��q���uaZr�\[�Y�q�Yi0X����3�uxyR�xYf�r�\[aZ�Tx��ui�+�vxwfi�aZo{k(�Y\[�Yklogi�k��Yz-�Yi�k��wi~XZ^g}~��s%R�ogxyR�x���i��+���q��oghT�uk(��ui0Xm��h�Ps%R��wi�¬+i+�u^¢h\m��k��Ya�u\Z�"x���^gxYr�^��uXZ�Yk8�Pª«i(a[X[�!�uk�futWs%�uogX[ogi�hFt�f\���^g^�\Z�Ya[r(^{XZaPX[fqxYf�q�Pogi8�-X[R��F\[�whoga[XZ\m�u\����!}x��u^gxYr(^`��X[�_X[R��_a[XZr�k��Yi0XZa������og^{ogX«}|a[xYf�\[��b�s%R�ogxyR"ogiPXZR�oga8x���a[�_oga�XZR��_i~r(�v�+�Y\Af�t+a[Xy�ui�k-�u\[kk��Y�0o��uXZo{f�i�a"���+fu����X[R(�����!�ui+e|t�f\PXZR+�uXFxYfr(\[a[�qog�����wk�o��uX[�w^{}����%R�ogaPx!�uipay�!��qX[og���s%R��Yi�a[�Yi(k�ogi�h�h\m��k��Ya�fr(X���XdXZR��v�Yi�k�futWXZR��Fa[�Y�q�Ya[XZ�Y\����%R��"aZXm��i�k+�u\Zk�k(�Y�0o`��X[ogfi(ak�f�xYf�\[\[�wxYX�t�f�\vk�o����Y\Zogi�h�xYfr(\[a[���!��Y\y�uh�wa��%�� h-�{�¢�j��n~ogi�h���U��Vs%R��Yi�X[R��Txwfr�\Za[��!��Y\y�uh��dogaW�P]�� ^gf0fnP�-�YXZX[�Y\%XZR+�ui��uivS%��s%R��YiqX[R��|xYfr�\Za[�P�!��w\m�uh��%ogaW�uivSF�S%X_X[R��am�����FX[og����-ogX�xYfi0XZo{i0r��waPX[f�\m��i�nTaZX[r�k��wi~XZa"ogi�X[R��vf�\[k��w\Pogi�s%R�ogxyR�X[R��Y}�a[xwf\[�wkpogi���uxyR�xYf�r�\[aZ�� ! XZr�k��Yi0X � ogaWXZR~r(ad�u^gs��!}0a3\y�ui�n��Ykj���+fu��� ! XZr�k��Yi0X �Ho�t �N�ui�k � Xy�un�a[og��og^��u\¢xYfr�\Za[�Ya!�A�ui�k��NR+�ua%�-�YX[XZ�Y\�h\y�uk��Ya!�

�%R�� ! Xy�ui�k+��\[k # f\Z�j�u^go('Y�Yk����-SNa[r0�A�Y\[a|t�\Zf�>�j��i~}Ffut3XZR��Pam�����|z�\[f���^g�Y��a%�uaX[R��|X[\y�uk�ogX[ogf�i+�u^��P�-SF��ª«X¢k�f0�Ya3i�f�X3\[�Ys%�u\Zkva[XZr�k��Yi0X[a_s%R�f�R+�!���d�d�qf\Z�Ws_�Y^g^���\Zfr�i�k(�YkxYfr(\[a[��^{f0�uk8��ª«i�aZX[����k8��aZX[r�k��wi~XZad�u\Z��z(r�i�oga[R��wkjaZ�Y��w\[^g}�o�t�XZR��Y}qz+�Y\¯t�f\Z���uX_^g�Ya[a%XZR+�uiX[R��|xYfr(\[a[�d�!���Y\m��h����%R(o{a�oga�^go{n��Y^g}PX[f�z�r(i�oga[R��|a[XZr�k��Yi0X_s%R�f�Xm�un��YaW�|xYf�r�\[aZ�dfr(X[a[ogk��R�oga3�j�w¤yf\!��aZogi�xY�%R��%oga�^go{n��Y^g}�X[f�a[xYf�\[�|sWf�\[a[�%XZR+�uivXZR�faZ�%a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a_s%R�fP�u\Z�%�j�Y¤¥f\[ogi�hogi�XZR��"xwfr�\Za[�� aPaZr��¤y�YxYX!�P�%R�oga�ogadi�f�X�i����u\Z^g}��ua|�+�uk��ua|X[R��vXZ\[����X[���wi~X|futWk(o���xwr�^gXxYfr(\[a[�wa��3R(fusW�Y���Y\��q�%R��vaZXm�ui(k+�u\Zkp�P�-S �j�un��Ya�i�f�k�oga[XZo{i(xYX[ogfi��-�YX«sW�w�Yi����uaZ} ��i�kk�o���xYr�^gX�xYfr(\[a[�wa����ui(kvX[R0r�a3�Yi(xYfr�\y�uh��Ya3����a[}FxYfr�\Za[�Ya!���ua3z(\[�Y�0ogfr�aZ^g}Pk�oga[xYr(a[a[�wk8�3�%R��! Xm��i�k+��\[k # f�\[�j��^go 'w�Ykj�P�-SN�uXZX[�Y�qz�X[a_X[fvxwf\[\Z�YxYX|X[R�oga��(��r�X%�Yi(k�adr�zqxY^��uog��ogi�h�XZR+�uX�v^gfus �!���Y\m��h�Ph�\m�uk(�Poga%�Y¦0r�og��u^g�Yi0X%X[f��Fk�o���xYr�^gX%xYfr(\[a[���d�%R�oga%ogadi(fXd�u^gs%�!}0a%X[\[r(���ui�kvR-�ua3aZf���_ogi0X[�Y\Z�Ya[XZo{i(h"¦0r�og\[n0a!���|o{h�R��Y\_^g�Y��Y^(xYfr�\Za[�Ya%���!}��+�|z+f�z�r�^��uXZ�Yk"�0}Ffi�^g}a[XZr�k��Yi0X[aqs%R�f��Y°0xY�Y^|�+f�X[R�ogipXZR���a[r��¤y�wxYX�f�t�X[R(�jxwfr�\Za[����i�kpogi�h�Yi(�Y\m��^��_�ui�kla[ffi�^g}TR(o{h�RTh\y�uk��wa"�u\Z�vhog��Yi��PU_r�XPo�t��u^g^�h\y�uk��wa"�u\Z�"R�ogh�R8�AX[R(o{a��q�YX[R�f0k�X[\Z���uXZaPX[R��xYfr(\[a[�F�ua_���uaZ}~���%R�oga_���YXZR�f0kv�+f0f�a[X[a%f�i��daZX[r�k(�Yi0X�� a%h\y�uk���o�t8X[R���f�X[R��Y\_a[XZr�k��Yi0XZadogifi���� a|xYfr(\[a[�FR+�!���P^gfusW�Y\%aZxYf\Z�Ya���S%k(k�ogX[ogfi+��^g^{}0�����og^{ogX«}vaZxYf\Z�YaP�j�!}v�-�PaZo{h�i�o�t�x���i~XZ^g}\m��o{aZ�Yk��0} ��k�k�ogi�h�z+f0f\Fa[XZr�k��Yi0XZavX[f�X[R��qxYfr�\Za[��l�%R�ogaF���YXZR�f0k�R+�uaFi�f�t��Y�Yk��-�uxyn���YxyR+��i�oga[�����ua�ogX�k(f~�wa�i(fX�xYf�qz+�wi�am��X[��t�f�\�X[R��_a[n0og^g^fut-X[R��_a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a_s%R��YiFk��Yxwo{k(o{i(h

����h�#&Ffut3�±

Page 6: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

X[R��vk(o���xwr�^gX«}Tfutd�qxYfr�\Za[��qS¡h�f~f0k�a[XZr�k��Yi0XPs%R�f�Xm�un��YaPxYf�r�\[aZ�YaFs%o{XZR�f�X[R��w\Phf0f0ka[XZr�k��Yi0X[a�s%o{^g^%^gf0fnlsWf�\[a[��X[R+��i ��a[^goghR0X[^g}�^g�YaZa ����^g��a[X[r(k��Yi0X�s%R�fpXy�un�wa�xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya�u�qfi�hFa[oghi(o�¬-x��ui0X[^g}v^g�YaZa��u�(^{��aZX[r�k��wi~XZa��%ª«X%oga%xY^g����\dXZR+�uX%XZR��Pk�o���xYr�^gX«}vf�t¢�Fxwfr�\Za[�oga�k(�YxYogk��Yk�i�f�X�fi�^g}��0}TX[R��Fh\y�uk��waPfutWogXZa�aZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a�����r�XP��^{aZf��~}�XZR����uz�XZogX[r�k��wa�f�tX[R���a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a|o{i�XZR���xYfr�\Za[��

,�� � 8�G � 3�� �43[G��i3 ��%R�� ! Xy�ui�k-�u\[k # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wkp�P�-S��u^ga[fp��a[aZr����YavXZR+�uX��u^g^%X[�!�uxyR��Y\Za ��a[aZo{h�i�h\m��k��Ya�+�uaZ�Yk�fi����+�w^{^Axwr�\[����3ª«XZa�����og^{ogX«}PaZxYf\Z�Ya���\[�|x��u^gxYr�^���X[�Ykqs%o{XZR�XZR�ogaWogiv��ogi�k����6R�og^g����-�Y^g^3xYr�\Z���oga�X[R(�v��faZX�^{ogn��Y^g}jk(o{aZX[\Zo{�(r�X[ogfi��Ai�fXF�u^g^�X[����xmR(�Y\[aFh\y�uk��vf�ip��xwr�\[�����ui�kla[f�����xw^`��a[aZ�Ya��%�uaF���wi~XZogfi��Yk��-�yt�f�\[��¢�j�!}�\[�Y¦0r�og\Z�jh�\m��k��YaFX[f�¬+Xva[f����vfXZR��Y\k�oga[XZ\[og��r�XZo{f�iTogiTf\Zk��Y\�X[fq�+��t���o{\ �-�� h+�g��o�t���^{^�X[R���a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a"��\[�F�Y°0X[\y�uf\Zk�ogi+�u\Zog^{}qXm��^���Yi0X[�Yk�� �|fusW�w��Y\!��X[R(�PxYf^g^g�Yh������!}"\Z�Yh~��\[kTogXd��a%z+f�a[ogX[og���XZfFt�f\ZxY��X[R��Pz(\[fut��Ya[aZf\[a�XZf�uaZa[oghiTh�\m��k��Ya�fi�� �+�w^{^�xYr(\[�����ª«iTX[R�oga|x��uaZ��AX[R(o{a|���YXZR�f0k�sWf�r�^gkT�+�Fr�aZ�yt�r�^«�-a[ogi�xY�ogX[a��u�(o{^gogX«}�a[xYf�\[�Ya��u\[���qf\[�v�q���ui(o{i(hut�r�^¢s%R��Yi�X[R���h�\m�uk(�YaFt�f\���xYf�r�\[aZ���u\Z�ji(f\«��j��^{^g}vk�ogaZX[\[og��r(X[�Yk8���%R(�"xY^gf�a[�Y\�X[R(�"h�\m�uk(�Ya|t�f\��vxYf�r�\[aZ� ��\[�FX[fj� xYr�\Z����X[R�����f\Z�xY^gfaZ�Y^g}pX[R(���u��og^gogX«}�aZxYf\Z�Ya����uXZxmRlX[R���h\m��k��Ya!�6��\m��k�ogi�h�f�i6�TxYr(\[����u^ga[f�t�faZX[�Y\ZaxYr�XZX[R�\Zf~�uX_xYf���z-�YX[ogX[ogf�i ����fi(hda[XZr�k��Yi0XZa���aZogi�xY����i0}"aZX[r�k��wi~X!� a�����og^{ogX«}PaZxYf\Z�d���!}P�+�a[oghi(o�¬-x��ui0X[^g}v\y�uoga[�Yk��0}�^gfus_�Y\[ogi�hFX[R(������og^go{X«}Fa[xwf\[�wa�f�t�f�X[R��Y\|a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a!�

� � K�=�(@�=%M�B�@�= � �VGPM�CDBPQ� �_= � � L��

-,/. ��8i> ?FA ��8�6�O ��d��X[R��Y\�XZR+�uiPk(o{\Z�YxYXZ^{}�xYf���z+��\[ogi�h%aZX[r�k��wi~XZa���X[R�oga��u^ghf�\[ogX[R���xYf�qz+�u\Z�Ya8xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya�� ! r�z0�z+f�a[�_sW�¢R+�!��3�_xYf�r�\[aZ�Ws%R�ogxyRPogaAr�i0r�aZr+�u^g^g}dk�o���xYr(^{X!�A�%R��Yi�a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a�a[R(fr�^gkP�-�3hog���Yi^gfusW�Y\�h�\m�uk(�Ya3ogi"XZR+�uX�xYf�r�\[aZ�d\Z�Y^��uX[og���WXZf�XZR��Yog\3f�X[R��Y\Za����%R��d�!���Y\m��h�_h\y�uk��_t�\Zf�NXZR+�uXxYfr(\[a[�Fa[R(fr�^gk�XZR��Y\Z�yt�f\Z�"�-��^gfusW�Y\%XZR+�ui�XZR��"�!��w\m�uh����P�-SNf�t���^{^AaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[ad�wi�\[f�^{^g�YkogijogX!����3aZR�fr�^gkFX[R��w\[�yt�f�\[�|�+�d����^g�WXZf�xwf\[\Z�YxYX�t�f\�xYfr(\[a[�waWXZR+�uX3�u\Z�%r�i0r�a[r-�u^g^g}�k(o���xwr�^gX

�0} ��k�k�ogi�h���a[�j��^g^~�u�qfr�i0X�X[f�X[R��%z-fogi0X���u^gr��_futA�Y��w\[}Fh\m��k��%hog���Yi"ogiFX[R+��X3xYf�r�\[aZ���Aogn�ws%o{aZ���s_��x��ui�xYf�\[\Z�YxYX%t�f\%����a[}�xwfr�\Za[�Ya��0}va[r��(X[\m��xYX[ogi�h��PaZ�j��^{^A�u�qfr�i0X!�

� tWxYf�r�\[aZ��8f�i�xY�vs_�"R-�!��PxYf�\[\Z�YxYX[�wkp�Y���Y\[}�fi��� aPh�\m��k��Ya�� X[R��Yog\Pi(�Ys �P�-SF� ads%og^g^�+��k�o����Y\Z�Yi0X��A�ui(kj�qfaZXW^gogn�Y^g}vaZf����xYf�r�\[aZ�Yads%og^g^Ai��Y�wk�t�r�\ZX[R��Y\�xYf�\[\Z�YxYX[ogf�i8�_�%R��Pª«X«��Y\m��X[�Yk # f\[���u^go('Y�Yk��P�-S����YXZR�f0k�fut8\y�ui�n0ogi�hF�j��n�Ya�X[�wijxwf\[\Z�YxYXZo{f�i�adXZf ��^g^�h\y�uk��Ya!�X[R��wi�aZf\[XZa�a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a�ogiTf\Zk��Y\�fut3xYf�\[\Z�YxYX[�wkp�P�-S"�(S%xYxYf\Zk�ogi�h�X[fvi0r��q�Y\[ogx���^8�Y°0z-�Y\[o�����Yi0XZa��w°~z(^`��ogi��Ykvogi ! �YxYX[ogf�ivS"�uXZ�YivogX[�Y\y�uX[ogf�i�aW�u\Z�%a[r0��xwo{�wi~X¢X[f���\[ogi�h�XZR��dk�o��A�Y\[�wi�xY��+�wX«sW�Y�wi�XZR��P�!��Y\y�uh�P�P�-SN�ui(kjXZR��P�!��Y\y�uh���h�\m��k���k�fus%i�X[fI'Y�Y\Zf+�

-,�� � A�6�3[G-Q�A�1 � C�G;D���3=CEO-G;3 ��� 3 ��%R�ogaP�u^ghf�\[ogX[R��>oga%t���og\[^g}�¦0r�ogxyn�X[f�xYf�qz�r�XZ��-Xm�un0ogi�hvf�i�^g} �qxYf�r�z�^g�Pf�tW��ogi0r�X[�wa%t�f�\������|a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a!������dxwfr�\Za[�Ya!���ui�k��|xYf�r�\[aZ�d^gf~��k"f�t (�8�%R��%xwf��z(r�Xm��X[ogfiPoga3aZX[\y�uoghR0X«�t�f\Zs���\[k�X[fF�Y°0z�^��uogi8����i�k����uaZog^{}vr(i�k��Y\Za[X[f0f0kT�0}�i(fi0�«�Y°0z+�w\[X[a!�

����h�PFfut3�±

Page 7: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

�dfus_�Y���Y\��-�u^g^8XZR��Ph\y�uk��wa%t�\Zf� �u^g^8xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya��vr�a[X%�-�Pn0i�fus%i�X[fq\[r�i�X[R��Pxwf��z(r0�Xm��X[ogfi8�F�%R��FxYf�\[\[�wxYX[�Yk�h�\m�uk(�YaPx���i�i�fX��-�vxYf�qz�r�XZ�Yk�ogi�k(�Yz+�wi�k��Yi0X[^g}��0}jaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a���%R��Y\Z�"oga%�u^ga[fvi�fvh�r+�u\y�ui0X[�w��XZR+�uX%XZR��PxYf�\[\Z�YxYX[�wk �P�-SF� a%s%o{^g^-�+��xYf�qz+�u\y�u��^g����xY\[f�a[aa[�Y�q�Ya[XZ�Y\[a!�%��fvxYf�qz�r�XZ�dfu��w\m�u^g^AxY^���a[ad\y�ui�n��uX|h\m��k�r+��X[ogfi8�0ogX%s%og^g^+�-�Pi��wxY�Ya[ay�u\Z}�XZf�!��Y\y�uh���XZR��P\y�ui�n0ad�uxw\[faZadaZ�Y���YaZX[�Y\Za��(\m�uXZR��Y\|X[R+��ijxwf\[\Z�YxYXZ�Yk ���-S"� a��

-,�� � 8�G � 3�� �43[G��i3 ��%R���ª«X[�Y\y�uXZ�Yk # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wk �P�-S�a[}0a[XZ�Y�j��X[ogx��u^g^g}PxYf�\[\Z�YxYX[a t�f\_X[�!�uxyR��Y\%��o���aWogivhog�0ogi�hh\y�uk��Ya!�3XZR~r(av�Y^go{�qogi+�uXZo{i(hvX[R���X[�wi�k��Yi�xw}pfutdaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a�XZfTa[�w^{�wxYXv���uaZ}pxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya��%��i�kX[R��w\[�yt�f�\[�F�j��n�Ya3z(\[fh�\[�YaZadXZfus���\[k�\[�Y���Y\[aZogi�hvh\y�uk���ogi0����X[ogfi8���%R���X[f�Xm��^AxYf\Z\[�YxYXZogfi�j��k��%t�f�\%���uxyR�xYf�r�\[aZ�P�j�!}F�+��r�aZ�Yk���ad�ui�ogi�k�ogx��uXZf\_fut�X[R��Pxwfr�\Za[�� adh�\m��k�����o��ua��

�%R�ogaP�u^ghf�\[ogX[R(��XZ�Yi�k�aPXZf ­ z�r(i�oga[R0®va[XZr�k��Yi0X[aFogiTxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya"s%R(�Y\[�vXZR��vh\y�uk��YaF�u\[�r�i0r�a[r-�u^g^g}�R(o{h�R8�Aª«X�a[R(fr�^gkP�-�Wi(fX[�wk"XZR+�uX�o�t�a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a3aZxYf\Z�%R�oghRPogi"� xYfr(\[a[�%\Z�Y^��uXZo{���X[f�XZR��Yog\vfXZR��Y\vh\y�uk��wa��3ogXFxYfr(^{k��-���+�Yx!�ur�aZ�T�YogX[R��w\vX[R���xYf�r�\[aZ�Ts���a"�!�ua[}0�3f�\vX[R��a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a�z�r(X_t�f\ZX[RT�uiq�Y°0X[\m� �y�Af\[X!�3ª�t�X[R��Pxwfr�\Za[�Ps%�ua%����a[}0�0X[R��wiTX[R���z�r(i�oga[R��q�Yi0Xoga�k(r���|ª�tWX[R��Fk�o��A�Y\[�Yi(xY�vs���adk�r(�"XZf��Y°0X[\y�q�y��f�\[X!�AX[R��wi�aZr�xyR��y�Af\ZX�o{a|i�fX|X«}0z�ogx��u^fut3X[R(��aZX[r�k(�Yi0X[adogi�¦0r��YaZX[ogfi8����i�k�X[R���z�r�i�oga[R(���Yi0X_o{a%�u\Zhr+����^g}vk�r���

Sd^gXZR�fr�h�R�X[R��_xYf\Z\[�YxwX[ogfiFx��ui��+�%�uz�z(^{og�Yk�X[fd���Y\[}�aZ�j�u^g^uxY^���a[a[�wa���i�kPogi�k��wz+�Yi(k��Yi0Xa[XZr�k�og�Ya���a[XZ\m��i�h�3XZR�ogi�ha��u\Z�3^go{n��Y^g}dXZfdR+��z�z+�wi8�8ª�tA�_a[X[r(k��Yi0X�o{iF�uiPogi�k��wz+�Yi(k��Yi0X�a[X[r(k�}h�YXZa��Fh�\m�uk(�"�u�-fu���R�ogad�P�-SF�0R��Ph�wX[adz(r�i�oga[R��wkT�0}�X[R(�PxYf\Z\[�YxwX[ogfi8�A��i�k�o�t�R��Ph��YX[a��^gfusW�w\3h\y�uk����R��|h�YXZaW\Z�Ys���\[k��wk8�0s%R�ogxyRvo{a¢xY^g���u\Z^{}Fr�i�k(�Ya[og\m����^g����%R�� ¬+\[aZXW\Zfr�i�kvf�txYf\Z\[�YxwX[ogfi�a%s%og^g^�\Z�Yz�^��uxY�|X[R�� VTs%ogXZRvX[R��|a[X[r(k��Yi0X�� ad�P�-SF�u��r�X3aZogi�xY�dR(o{a_h\y�uk��waWs_�Y\[�sWf�\[aZ�PX[fv�-�Yhogi�s%ogX[R8�0XZR��P�!��Y\y�uh������-SNfut�R(o{a%f�X[R��w\%xYfr�\Za[�Ya�s%og^g^A�+��aZ�j�u^g^g�Y\3XZR+�uio�t8R��� kv�j��k��W���-�YX[XZ�Y\%h\y�uk��%ogivR�oga�ogi�k��Yz-�Yi�k(�Yi0X%a[X[r(k�}~��a[f�X[R��%k�o���xYr(^{X«}�xYf\Z\[�YxYXZogfit�f\vXZR�faZ��o{avaZ�j��^{^g�Y\!���daZogi�h�XZR��Tay�u��z(^{�vk-�uXm��a[�wX�z�\Z�Ya[�Yi0XZ�Yk ogi ! �YxYXZo{f�i6]���a���+�uaZoga��0s_�%�Y°0z+�Y\Zog���Yi0X[�wk�s%ogX[RFogi�k��Yz-�Yi�k��wi~X%aZX[r�k(o{�wa���i�kvk��YXZ�Y\[�qo{i(�Yk�XZR+�uX3XZR��Y}vR+��k��ogi�og�j�!^(o{�qz+�uxwX3fi�X[R(��\y�ui�nqf\Zk��Y\��

�%R��Y\Z�yt�f�\[���X[f��!�fogk�a[r(xmR�aZX[\y�ui�h��"\Z�Ya[r�^gXZa���o{i(k��Yz-�Yi�k��Yi0XPaZX[r�k(o{�waPa[R�f�r�^gkT�-�"oghu�i�f\Z�YkTs%R��wij\Zr�i�i�ogi�hvXZR���xYf�qz�r�Xy�uX[ogf�i8�

� � K�=���=%BP?A@�� ��� ��BPM�=%?"� Q��PGPM �w@�KqC

,/. ��8i> ?FA ��8�6�O ��%R�� �A�!�ua[X¯� ! ¦~r-�u\[�wa"�q�YX[R�f0k���a[aZr����Ya�XZR+�uXPXZR��vk�o��A�Y\[�Yi(xY���-�YX«s_�Y�YipX«s_f�aZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a���u��og^gogX[og�YaAs%og^g^�-�W\Z�y�+�YxwX[�Ykvogi�X[R��_k�o��A�Y\[�Yi(xY�%�+�wX«sW�Y�wivX[R��Yog\�h\m��k��Ya!���|�Yi�xY���o�t�a[X[r(k��Yi0X� �ui(k6a[XZr�k��Yi0X � Xy�un���XZR���ay�u�q�jxwfr�\Za[��P��i�k6h�wXj�ui�S ��i�k6U��_\[�YaZz+�YxwX[og��Y^g}0�� � � � �����¢t�r�\[XZR��Y\W��a[aZr����_X[R+��X�a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a_�j�Y¤¥f\[ogi�h%ogiPR-�u\[kvaZxYog�Yi�xY� ¬+�Y^gk�a�s%og^g^~z-�Y\¯t�f\Z�

�+�wX[X[�w\"ogiTR+��\[kTaZxYog�Yi�xY�qxYfr(\[a[�waPX[R+��i�ogiTR0r����ui�ogXZo{�wa%xYfr�\Za[�Ya!����i�kT�0ogxY�F��Y\Zam��� ����u^ga[fT��a[a[r(���FX[R+��X�XZR�oga�s%o{^g^��-�"\Z�y�+�YxYXZ�Yk��0}��vk�\Zfz�ogiTXZR��Yog\Ph\y�uk����8�ui�k�X[R-�uX�X[R�ogak�\[f�z�ogaPfutd�uz�z(\[fu°0og�j�uXZ�Y^g}�XZR��vam�����F�j�uh�i�ogX[r�k(��t�f\P��^{^¢a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a �3s_�vx��u^g^3ogX� �"��d�Yi(xY���o�tm�-ogi�XZR��"�w°£����z�^g�"���+fu����AaZX[r�k��wi~XZa �D�ui�k ����\[�FXm��n~ogi�h��q�j�uXZR��Y���uX[ogxYa

����h���Ffut3�±

Page 8: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

xYfr(\[a[���d��r(X�a[XZr�k��Yi0X � oga��j�w¤yf\Zo{i(hTogiJz(R~}0aZo{xwa ��i�k�a[XZr�k��Yi0X � oga����Y¤yf\Zogi�hTogi^go{XZ�Y\m��X[r�\Z���s_��R+�!�� � ��� � " ���E� ��

S>xYfr�\Za[�Ts%ogXZR�� a[XZr�k��Yi0X[aqs%og^{^_h�wi��Y\m��X[�������� a[r�xyR�^go{i(���u\v�Y¦0r+��X[ogfi(a�_X[R���u��og^gogX[og�Ya3f�t��!�uxyR�aZX[r�k��wi~X_x���i��-�d�Y°0z-�YxYX[�wkjXZfP�-�dX[R(�da[f�^gr�X[ogfivXZfPX[R(�da[�wXWf�t��u^g^�a[r(xmR�Y¦0r+�uXZogfi�a_t�\Zf�¡�w��Y\Z}jxwfr�\Za[�Pf����Y\Z�YkTk�r(\[ogi�hvX[R(��aZ�Y���wa[X[�w\��

ª«i�z�\m��xYX[ogxY����X[R(�Ya[�F�Y¦0r+�uXZogfi�a%i��w��Y\|R+�!��P��a[f^gr�XZogfi8��SNaZX[r�k��wi~X|�+f0k�}�f�t�����(�t�f\¢�Y°��u��z(^{����s%og^g^�h��Yi��Y\y�uX[�|\[f�r�hR�^g}"�]&�(� ���� �Y¦0r+�uXZo{f�i�a�� _XZR��dxyR+��i�xY�dXZR+�uX¢X[R��Y}Fs%og^g^�+�|xYfi(a[oga[XZ�Yi0X3oga3�Ya[aZ�Yi0X[o��u^g^g}#'Y�w\[f+� �|�Yi�xY�������wX[R�f0k�a�futA^g���uaZX«�«a[¦0r+��\[�Ya%�uz�z(\[fu°0og�j�uXZogfui�vr�a[X%�-�F�Y��z�^gfu}��Yk8�%�%R���a[}0a[XZ�Y��ogadxwfi0��Y\ZX[�Yk�ogi0X[f�XZR��F�j�uXZ\[og°v�Y¦0r+��X[ogfi7��� ���u�s%R��Y\Z�!�Noga%X[R(�P�j��X[\[og°Ffut�X[R��Pxwf~�¥��xYog�Yi0X[adf�t3X[R��P^g�yt�X%R+�ui�k�aZo{k(��f�t3���uxyR��Y¦0r+�uXZogfi8���oga�XZR��F��YxYXZf\Pf�tWX[R(���u��og^gogX[og�Ya%fut%����xmR�a[XZr�k��Yi0X"��i�k�X[R��FxYfi(a[Xm��i0X ��A�ui(k���ogaX[R���\Zo{h�R0X3R+�ui(kva[ogk��df�t8���uxyR��Y¦0r+��X[ogfi8���%R�oga3���uX[\Zog°P�Y¦0r+�uXZogfivR+��aWi�fFa[f�^gr�X[ogfi��u��r�X�vr�^gX[ogz�^gogx��uXZogfiPXZR�\[f�r�hRq�~}FX[R(��XZ\m��i�a[z-faZ��f�t=� }0og�Y^gk�a_X[R��|�Y¦0r+�uXZogfiI�������I�J�����u�s%R��Y\Z��� oga"i�fus XZR���^g����a[X«�«a[¦0r+��\[�Yav�uz(z�\[fu°0og�j��X[ogfiTXZfTX[R(��f\Zoghogi+�u^¢a[}0a[XZ�Y�����%R�oga�j��X[\[og°v�Y¦0r+��X[ogfi���ogi�a[XZ���uk�futWR+�!�0ogi�hFi�f�aZf^gr�XZo{f�i8�0R+��a��vf�i��y�«k�og���Yi(a[ogfi+��^+aZf^gr�XZo{f�ia[�YX ��s%ogX[Rqi0r�^g^{aZz+�uxw�d�Y¦0r+��^AX[fPaZx��u^��u\%�vr(^{XZogz�^g�Ya�fut��/�]���]�����]�(� �(�]�����`��� � �0s%R(�Y\[��X[R(� ��� axYf\Z\[�YaZz+f�i�k�X[fqX[R���a[X[r(k��Yi0X�� aP�u��og^gogX[og�Yad��i�k�X[R��v�vXZfvX[R��FxYfi(a[Xm��i0X � � �%R~r(a��-fi��a[XZr�k��Yi0X�� a��u��og^gogX«}Ta[xYf�\[�T���!}T�-� ��a[aZo{h�i��Yk6�u\Z��ogX[\y�u\[og^g}0����i�kpXZR���\[�YaZX�s%og^g^WXZR��Yi��+�sW�w^{^��«k��YXZ�Y\[�qo{i(�Yk8�P�%R(o{aF�u\[�(o{XZ\m��\[}���a[a[ogh�i����Yi0X|s%o{^g^�o{i�i�f�s%�!} � ���wxYX"XZR��Ff\[k(�Y\[ogi�hfut���i0}�X«s_fva[X[r(k��Yi0X[a!�8�u��og^gogX«}va[xYf�\[�Ya!�Af\|X[R��F�j��hi�ogXZr�k��df�t3X[R��Pk(o��A�Y\Z�Yi�xY�v�-�YX«s_�Y�YiX«sWf�aZX[r�k��wi~XZa���S t�X[�Y\�X[R��YaZ��aZxYf\Z�Ya ��\[�Fk��YXZ�Y\[�qo{i(�Yk8��X[R��vk�o��A�Y\[�wi�xY���-�YX«s_�Y�Yi��j�(� ��ui�k�X[R��F���Yk(o`��i�aZxYf\Z�vo{ad��k�k��Yk�X[fq�Y��w\[}�a[XZr�k��Yi0X�� a�a[xwf\[���Aa[f�X[R-�uXdXZR��PaZxYf\Z�YaPs%og^g^�+������a[og^g}�ogi~XZ�Y\[z(\[�YXy�u��^g�Togi�X[�w\[��avf�tdX[R���XZ\m�uk(o{XZogfi+��^��P�-SF���%R��YaZ�jaZxYf\Z�Ya�x!�ui��+��!��Y\y�uh��Yk�fu��Y\d��^{^���a[�w���YaZX[�Y\Za�XZf"z(\[f0k�r�xY�F�F\m�ui(n~ogi�hv�uX%h�\m��k�r+�uXZogfi8�

,�� � 8�G � 3�� �43[G��i3 �SdiTog�q���Yk�o���X[�%xYf�i�a[�Y¦0r��wi�xY�Ffut3xyR+�ui�h�ogi�hvX[fvXZR�ogad\m��i�n0ogi�hvs%og^{^A�-�PXZR+�uX!��a[fq^gfi�hv�uaX[R����!���Y\m��h�vh�\m�uk(�"\Z�Y�j��o{i(a��ui�S �¥���u^g^3�u��og^gogX«}jaZxYf\Z�YaFs%o{^g^��+�vXZo{h�R0X[^g}Tz+��xmn��Yk�o{i0XZf�q\m�ui(h�v�-�YX«sW�w�YiJ���+f�r�Xv�� ����i�kp�u�-fr�X#$(� � �Ai�f�a[XZr�k��Yi0XFs%og^{^3��z�z+�!�u\�X[fTx!�u\[\Z} ��iSH�!��Y\y�uh�����%R�oga%s%og^{^-^gogn�Y^g}F\[�YaZr�^gXdogi�z�\Zfut��wa[a[f�\[a|s%o{k(�Yi�ogi�hFX[R��Yog\%h�\m�uk(o{i(h"aZx��u^g�Ya!��ogif\Zk��Y\dXZf"\Z�Ys%�u\[k�X[R��Yog\%�-�Ya[X|a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a!��XZR~r(a%\[�Yk�r(xYogi�h�h�\m�uk(��ogi0�A�uX[ogf�ivX[fva[f����YXZR�ogi�h��f�\[�d\Z���uaZfi+����^g��

,�� � A�6�3[G-Q�A�1 ��%R�oga8�q�YX[R�f0k�R+��aAX«sWf%���Y¤yf\-a[XZ\[�Yi(hX[R(a��X[R��¢¬+\[aZX8ogaAX[R-�uX8ogXAxYf�\[\Z�YxYX[a�t�f\AXZR��3k�o���xYr�^gX«}fut��Y���Y\[}�a[XZr�k��Yi0X!� a�xYfr(\[a[�_^gf~��k8�YXZR��3a[�wxYfi�k�X[R+��X8ogX+x!�uiP\Z�Ys���\[kPaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a�t�f\Ax!�u\[\Z}0o{i(h�FsW�w^{^��«\[f�r�i�k��Yk�xYf�r�\[aZ�P^gf~��k8�

�%R�ogaFa[�YxYf�i�k�a[XZ\[�Yi�h�X[R6ogaF�Y°0X[\Z�Y���Y^g}��+�w°~og��^g��_�ui�klk��YaZ�Y\[���Yavt�r(\[X[R(�Y\v�Yi0r����w\m�!�X[ogfi���ª�t���a[xyR�f0f�^ds%oga[R��wavi�fXvXZfp�uxYxYf�r�i0XFt�f\vs_�Y^g^���\Zfr�i(k��Yk�i��wa[a��_XZR���t���xYX[f�\ ��j�!}��+��f���ogX[XZ�Yk�t�\[f�� X[R��T�u^gh�f\[ogXZR�� �u�-fu���¢s%o{XZRpi�f�xYf�i�a[�Y¦0r��wi�xY���Y°0xY�Yz�XvXZR+�uXX[R�������og^go{X«}�aZxYf\Z�Ya"s%og^g^�i�f�^gfi�h��Y\PxYf�i�a[ogk��Y\�X[R��v�+��^��ui�xY�vf�\�a[z-�YxYo��u^go('��uXZogfi�o{i�����xmR�� gdgav��-eq� E^ _ uo\menP^`fonPh`vmcagdZ[lm^`g"!$# ga_dvmbmZPqo_ag�^`qmb-_almZ/caZi^`caZ&%!'#(#En/h vmcdgaZ/g*)(+�ZElm^',`Z.-0/213/5461

/-'4(4678-(9'4;:<4(4(4�\m^`ecagihkj= `ca^`bmZ/gPw

����h�>�Ffut3�±

Page 9: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

a[XZr�k��Yi0X�� a|xYfr�\Za[�F^gf~�uk��8ª�tW�Fa[xyR�f0f�^8s%oga[R��wa%X[fv�Y�qz�R+�uaZo('Y��a[�Y���Y\m��^�k(o��A�Y\Z�Yi0Xd�u\[�!�uadf�ta[z-�YxYo��u^go('���X[ogfi�\y�uX[R(�Y\vX[R+��i�¤yr�aZX"X«s_f+��am�!}0�8S|\[XZa��ui�k�� o{XZ�Y\m��X[r�\Z�� ! f~xwo`��^ ! xYog�Yi(xY�Ya��# ��X[r�\y�u^ ! xYog�Yi�xY�Ya!�8�ui(k ���u\Zk ! xYog�Yi�xY�Ya!�AogX%xYfr(^{k�k�fvaZf��0}�\Z�Yz�^��uxwo{i(h �Ns%o{XZR�a[�Y����Y\m��^Wxwfi�aZXm�ui0XZaP\[�Yz(\[�YaZ�Yi0X[ogi�h�X[R(�vk�o���xYr�^gX«}Tfut%X[R(�vX[\m��i�a[ogXZo{f�i�a��+�wX«sW�Y�wip����xmR�z-�uog\��ogi�XZR�ogaPx��uaZ��E�����[� � �[� �v��� � ��� �v����i�k�� � � S aZxyR�f0f^_�j�!}j��^ga[f�k�ogxYXm��X[�vXZR+�uXxY�Y\ZXm�uogiq�Y��z�R-�ua[o('Y�wkvxYfr�\Za[�Ya!���� h-��|t�\Z�Ya[R����uiFs%\[ogX[ogi�h�xYf�r�\[aZ���i(fX3�-�Yi��y¬-XWaZX[r�k��wi~XZa�j�Y¤¥f\[ogi�h�ogiva[f����|k��Yz+��\[X[�q�Yi0X[a_fu��Y\_fXZR��Y\Za��0ogXW���!}Px���X[�Yh�f\[o('Y��XZR+�uX_xYfr(\[a[�P��aW�-�y�^gfi�h�o{i(hdX[f��Y���Y\[}v�u\Z����f�t�aZz+�Yxwo`��^go '!�uX[ogf�i8�!f\3XZf�i(fi�����a[og�qo{^���\[^g}�Yo�t��|aZxmR(f~f�^+s%ogaZR��Ya3XZfk�ogxYXm��X[�|X[R+��X3xY�Y\ZXm�uogiqk��y�«�Y��z�R-�ua[o('Y�wkvxYfr�\Za[�Ya!���� h-���R0}0a[ogx��u^A��k�r(x��uXZo{f�i8��i�fX3\Z�Ys%�u\[ka[XZr�k��Yi0X[a�s%ogX[R�� ���Y^g^�� �%f�r�i�k��wk�i��YaZa%xYf\Z\[�YxYXZogfi8�AogX%���!}��u^ga[fvk�ogxYXy�uXZ�PX[R+��XdXZR��Y}��+�x��uXZ�Yhf�\[o('Y�Yk�ogi��Y��Y\Z}T�u\[�!�vfut3aZz+�Yxwo`��^go '!�uX[ogf�ijf�\%ogiji(fi��� �8�uaZX[^g}0�0fX[R(�Y\dxYf�\[\Z�YxYX[ogf�i�a�j�!}F�+�����uk��_t�f�\WaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[ads%ogXZR�a[z-�YxYo���^AxYog\[xYr��qa[Xy�ui�xY�wa��0t�f\_�Y°��u��z(^{���o�t���a[X[r(k��Yi0Xk�fr(��^g�y�����Y¤yf�\[a8ogiPX«s_fdk(o��A�Y\Z�Yi0XW�u\Z���ua�fut-a[z-�YxYo��u^go('��uXZogfi8���a8����xyR ���Y^g^�� �%f�r�i�k��wk�i��YaZaxYf\Z\[�YxwX[ogfi���ogh�R~X��-��\[�Yz�^���xY�Yk��0}vX[R����!��Y\y�uh�|fut�X[R��|X«sWfFxYf\Z\[�YxwX[ogfi�a_t�\[f� ���uxyR�f�tR�oga%�j�Y¤¥f\W��\[����a��

,d+ ��3[C�O-G;3 ��� 3 ��%R��F��faZXdh�^`��\[ogi�hvs_���un0i��wa[a�futWXZR�oga����YXZR�f0kTogadX[R-�uX�ogXdogi0�f^g���Ya%R0r�h�v�u�qfr�i0X[a%f�txYf�qz�r�Xy�uX[ogf�i�a����i�k����!}Pa[�w��Y\Z�Y^g}vXm�u°vXZR��dxwf��z(r�X[ogi�h�\[�wa[fr(\[xY�Ya|fut8^��u\Zh�Y\_r�i�og���Y\[aZo��X[og�Ya!��V�f�\��w°£����z�^g����daZxyR�f0f^-s%o{XZR ��a[X[r(k��Yi0XW�-f0k�}Ffut8�u�-fr�X3����|s%og^g^~i(�Y�Ykj��z�z�\Zfu°�og�j�uXZ�Y^g} ��������Yh0�u�0}0X[�Ya%f�t � S�� �ui�k��`RvR�f�r�\[ad��Xd����P�q�Yh~��R��Y\[XP'�X[fvz-�Y\«t�f�\[�>X[R��i��YxY�wa[am��\[}qx��u^gxYr�^���X[ogfi�a!��V(f\3��i~}�a[oghi�o�¬+x!�ui0X[^g}P^��u\Zh�Y\�aZxmR(f~f�^«�XZR��%fz-�Y\m��X[ogfiF¦0r�ogxyn~^g}�+�wxYf�q�Yavogi0t�����a[og��^g��s%o{XZRpxYr(\[\[�wi~XqX[�YxyR�i(f^gfh�}~� ! �Y� ! �YxYX[ogf�iJU t�f�\"XZR���k��YXm��og^{avf�tX[R��wa[�Fx��u^gxYr�^���X[ogfi�a!�

� � �vCDBPQ!Q �p=%? @¡L6G � ��Q�B�@ ��G�E

���Pz-fa[XZr�^��uXZ�"�F��Y\Z}�a[�j��^g^Aa[xyR�f0f^«��s%R(o{xyRTR-�ua��FaZX[r�k(�Yi0X��-f0k�}�futd� ��bca[XZr�k��Yi0X[a�S� �|eY�A�ui�k�f����w\[aPf�i�^g}TX[R��Ft�f^g^gfus%o{i(hvxY^��ua[aZ�Ya�§��T��X[R8����R0}~aZogxYa��3]_f���z�r�XZ�Y\ ! xYog�Yi�xw����R0}0a[ogx��u^_��k�r�x���X[ogfi�� �d����^gX[R8�A��i�h�^go{aZR8�=V(\[�Yi(xmR�� �doga[XZf\Z}~�A��R�og^gfaZfz�R0}0�A��a[}0xyR�f^gf�h}0���r�aZo{x �doga[XZf\[}0��T��X[R8�u��R0}0a[ogxYa!��ui�kF��i�h^goga[RP��\[�3h��Yi��Y\y�u^g^g}��-�Y^gog�Y��wkPX[f|�+�_z�\[f�R�og��ogX[og��w^{}%k(o���xwr�^gX

xYfr(\[a[�wa��Ps%R(o{^g����R~}0aZo{x!�u^P��k�r�x!�uX[ogf�i8� �|���u^gXZR8����i�k���r(a[ogx �|oga[X[f�\[} ��\[��h�Yi(�Y\m��^{^g}xYfi(a[ogk��Y\Z�Yk�XZf"�-�P���Y\[}q���uaZ}~�! XZr�k��Yi0X[a!�XZ\m��i�a[xY\Zogz�X[a%�u\Z�%^{ogaZX[�YkFogi ]���� f~f�n0o{i(h�¤yr�aZXW�uX�XZR��Ya[�|X[\y�ui�aZxY\[ogz�XZa��0s%ogX[R0�fr�Xd��i+�u^g} 'Yogi�hFX[R��w��i0r��q�Y\[ogx���^{^g}0�us_�d¬-i�k�X[R+��X%X[R��|t�f�^{^gfus%ogi�hP�u\Z�Pa[�w^�tc���Y�0ogk��Yi0X!§¨ ! X[r�k��wi~X�SVa[R�f�r�^gk6�+��\m�ui(n�YkN�uR��!�uk�fut ! X[r�k��wi~X�U�� ! XZr�k��Yi0XT] �uR(���uk6f�t! X[r�k��wi~X �"� ! X[r�k(�Yi0X"�N�uR��!�uk�fut4VW���ui�k�a[fTf�i8�A�-�Yx���r�a[�qX[R��Y}�x���\[\[}��-�YX[XZ�Y\h�\m��k��YadogiqxYfr�\Za[�Y^gf0�uk�a|fut�aZog��og^��u\�k�o���xYr�^gX«}0�

¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XZa�� �ui(k ��a[R�f�r�^gkv�+�%\y�ui�n��Yk��uR(���ukvf�t ! XZr�k��Yi0XP�-�Yx��ur(a[�dXZR��Y}vR+�!���aZ^go{h�R0X[^g}v�+�wX[X[�w\dh\y�uk��wadogi��qf\[�|k�o���xYr�^gX_xYfr�\Za[�Y^gf0�uk�a!�¨ ! X[r�k��wi~X�� aZR�fr(^{kl�+�q\m��i�n�Yk��uR��!�ukpf�t ! X[r(k��Yi0X �>�-�Yx���r�a[��R��qR+�uaF�-�YX[XZ�Y\h�\m��k��Yadogi��F��f\Z�%k�o���xYr�^gX%xYf�r�\[aZ�Y^gf~�uk��

����h�P±Ffut3�±

Page 10: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

Sdi0}����^go{kv\y�ui�n0ogi�hvaZ}~aZX[�Y�>�vr�aZXWay�uX[oga¯t�}�XZR��Ya[��xYfi�k(o{XZogfi�a!����W��^{aZfd\Z�YxYfh�i�o('Y�%X[R(�3t�f�^g^{fus%ogi�h_\[�w^`��X[ogfi(a[R�ogz�a3�ua�z�\Z�yt��Y\y�u��^g�_��r�X�i�f�X�����a[f�^gr�X[�Y^g}

i��YxY�wa[am��\[}A§¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XF�HaZR�fr(^{k��-�"\y�ui�n��Yk ��R�����kTfut ! X[r�k��wi~XZa��¡��i�k �P�A��i�k�aZX[r�k(�Yi0X��aZR�fr(^{k��+�F\m��i�n�Yk��uR(���ukTf�tWa[XZr�k��Yi0X �P�(�+�wx��ur�aZ�vX[R��w}TR+�!��F�u^g��f�a[Xd�ua|hf0f0kh�\m��k��Ya���i�k��vr(xmRq��f�\[�dk(o���xwr�^gXWaZxmR(�Yk�r�^g�Ya!�

¨ ! X[r�k��wi~X � aZR�fr(^{kv�-�d\y�ui�n��Ykj��R�����kvfut ! XZr�k��Yi0X��"����i�k ! XZr�k��Yi0X # ��R����ukvf�taZX[r�k(�Yi0X �P�0�-�Yx���r�a[�FX[R(�Y}�R+�!����a[og��og^��u\�h\y�uk��wa%o{iT����f�\[�dk(o���xwr�^gXWaZxmR(�Yk�r�^g��¨ ! X[r�k��wi~X��¡aZR�fr(^{k��+�F\m��i�n�Yk��uR(���uk�fut ! X[r�k��wi~XZa ��� # ���F����i�k �N�-�Yx��ur(a[�R(��R-�ua%a[og�qo{^���\3h\y�uk��Ya%ogiT���vr�xyR���f�\[�|k�o���xYr�^gXWaZxyR��Yk�r�^g��

¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XZa�]����v�u�ui�k��6aZR�fr(^{kv�-�%\m��i�n�wk"i��!�u\3����xyRvfX[R(�Y\3�-�Yx��ur(a[��X[R��w}"R+�!���aZog��og^��u\3h�\m�uk(�Ya%ogi�a[og�qo{^���\3a[xyR��Yk(r�^g�Ya��¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XF� a[R�f�r�^gk��-�v\m��i�n�Ykp��R�����k�fut ! X[r�k(�Yi0X +�A�-�Yx���r�a[�qR��vR+��aPa[og��og^��u\h�\m��k��Ya3�uh0�uogi�a[X8�_aZoghi�o�¬+x���i0X[^g}d�qf\[��k�o���xYr(^{XAaZxyR��Yk�r�^g����ui�kPR-�ua8R(o{h�R��Y\�h\m��k��Yaogi�X[R(��X«s_fFxY^��ua[aZ�Ya�X[R+��XWXZR��Y}�a[R-�u\[���

ª�t�s_�Tz-faZX[r�^��uXZ��X[R+��X�X[R(�js_�Y^g^���\Zfr�i(k��Yk�i��wa[a�� f\�^���xmn�XZR��Y\Z�Yfutm� fut"�TaZX[r�k(�Yi0X�� aa[xyR��Yk(r�^g�Pa[R�f�r�^gkT�!�A�YxYXdR(o{a%\y�ui�nA�0s_�P�u^ga[f�¬+i�k�X[R(��t�f^g^gfus%ogi�h�\[�Y^���X[ogfi�aZR�ogz�a�§

¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XP��aZR�fr(^{k��+�F\m��i�n�Yk��uR(���ukTf�t ! X[r�k(�Yi0X[aP]H��i�k �F���-�Yx���r�a[�vR���R+�ua��^g��faZX3�ua_hf0f0k�h\y�uk��waWogij����f\Z�%k�o���xYr�^gX����vr�xyRv��f�\[�%s_�Y^g^���\Zfr�i�k(�Ykva[xyR��Yk£�r(^{���

¨ ! X[r�k��wi~X�ª�aZR�fr(^{k��-�v\m�ui(n�Yk��uR��!�uk�fut ! XZr�k��Yi0X[a�� ��i�k ���-�Yx��ur(a[��R(�vR+�uaaZog��og^��u\3h�\m�uk(�Yad�uh0�uogi�a[X%�F��f�\[�|sW�Y^g^��«\[fr(i�k��Ykqa[xyR��Yk�r(^{���

���%i�fuslR+�!��%aZf���%�-�ua[oga3XZf"�ui-�u^g} 'Y�%X[R��|�y�A�YxYX[og���Yi��YaZadfut8f�r�\3\y�ui�n0ogi�hPaZ}~aZX[�Y�qa���%R���\m��i�n0ogi�ha_fut3X[R(o{a%ay�u�qz�^g�%z+f�z�r�^��uXZo{f�ij��\[��hog��wijogi ! �YxYXZo{f�i �"�V�og\[a[X!�-sW�Pxwfi�aZo{k(�Y\�X[R��FX[\y�uk�ogX[ogf�i+�u^��P�-S"�(ª«Xdk�f0�Ya�am��X[oga«t�}jXZR��P\Z�Y^��uX[ogf�i�a[R�ogz�a|sW�

R+�uk�\[�Y¦0r�og\[�wk8����i�k6ogXvk�f0�Ya�\m��i�n�a[XZr�k��Yi0X[aT]��_�v�W��i�k�� i�����\j�!�uxyR6fXZR��Y\!����i�kogXP\m��i�n0aPa[XZr�k��Yi0X��R�ogh�R��Y\PXZR+�ui�aZX[r�k��wi~XZa # �ui�k ��� �dfus_�Y��w\���ogX�k�f0�Ya"i(fXP\y�ui�na[XZr�k��Yi0X �D�u�-fu��vaZX[r�k(�Yi0X� ��i�f\�a[X[r(k��Yi0X # �u�-fu��vaZX[r�k(�Yi0X ���8i�f�\Pa[XZr�k��Yi0X��u�-fu��vaZX[r�k��wi~XZa � f�\��F�Ai�f�\Pa[XZr�k��Yi0X[av�>�ui�kp�N���+fu���"aZX[r�k��wi~XZa�����i�k �P�A�%R��X[\y�uk�ogX[ogf�i+�u^8�P�-S z+��a[a[�wadfi(^{}F¬-���fut3X[R(��XZR�og\[XZ�Y�YiTXZ�Ya[XZads_��R-�uk�a[�YX t�f\_ogX��

ª�t8s_���u^gaZfPa[XZo{z(r�^��uX[�|X[R+��X3s_�Y^g^��«\[f�r�i�k��wk�i��YaZa%a[R�f�r�^gk��-���|t���xYX[f�\��0XZR��dXZ\m�uk(o{XZogfi+��^�P�-S>t���o{^gaI$Tf�tPX[R��qt�f�r�\��uk�k(o{XZogfi+��^WXZ�Ya[XZa�s_�jR-�uk�a[�YX!�%fi(^{}�\y�ui�n0ogi�h�a[XZr�k��Yi0Xj�R�oghR��w\%X[R+��ijaZX[r�k(�Yi0X �F�# �w°~X!��s_�PxYf�i�a[ogk��Y\|X[R�� ! Xm��i�k+�u\Zk # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wkj�P�-SF�0ª«Xd�u^ga[fvay�uX[oga¯¬+�Ya���^g^Afut3X[R��\[�Y¦0r�og\Z�Yk6\[�w^`��X[ogfi(a[R�ogz�a!�W�ui(kpam��X[oga«¬-�Yava[XZr�k��Yi0Xj] xY^gfa[��XZf�a[X[r(k��Yi0X��v��a[XZr�k��Yi0X #\m��i�n�Yk��uR(���ukTf�t3a[X[r(k��Yi0X �P�+��i�kTaZX[r�k��wi~X�� \m��i�n�wk ��R����uk�fut3a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a ��� # ���F��ui�k ���0ª«X%z+�uaZa[�Ya|X[R��YaZ�Pa[og°qX[�YaZX[a���i�kqt��uog^ga_X[R���fXZR��Y\|a[�Y���Yi8�ª�t3sW�F�u^ga[fqa[X[ogz�r(^`��X[�PXZR+�uX|sW�w^{^��«\[f�r�i�k��Yk(i��Ya[a�aZR�fr�^gkT�-�"� t��uxYXZf\!�+XZR�� ! Xy�ui�k-�u\[k

# f�\[�j��^go 'w�Yk"�P�-Slz+�uaZa[�Ya3f�i�^g}�X«sWf|futAX[R��¢t�fr(\��uk(k�ogX[ogfi+��^XZ�Ya[XZaWs_�WR-�ukPaZ�YX���\m��i�n0o{i(ha[XZr�k��Yi0X�����R����uk�f�t�aZX[r�k(�Yi0X �H�ui(kjaZX[r�k(�Yi0XdªW��R����uk�f�t ! X[r�k��wi~X � �

����h�v����fut3�±

Page 11: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

�%R�og\[kvs_�dxwfi�aZo{k(�Y\WXZR���ª«X[�Y\y�uXZ�Yk # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wk �P�-SF�uª«X_am�uXZoga«¬+�Yad��^g^�X[R��|\[�Y^���X[ogfi0�a[R�ogz�a�s_�PR+��kT\[�Y¦0r�og\Z�Yk8�A�ui�k��u^ga[fvay�uX[oga¯¬+�Ya��YoghR0Xdf�t3X[R��FX[R�og\ZX[�Y�Yi�X[�wa[X[a�s_�PR+��kTa[�YX!�t��uog^gogi�hvfi(^{}qX[f�\m��i�n�a[XZr�k��Yi0X"� �uR��!�ukTf�tWa[XZr�k��Yi0X[a ��i�k ���+aZX[r�k(�Yi0X"� �uR�����k�f�ta[XZr�k��Yi0X �F�-�ui�k�a[XZr�k��Yi0XZa�] �ui�k��Hi(���u\%aZX[r�k��wi~X �v�

ª�t%sW����^{aZfTa[XZogz�r�^��uXZ�vX[R+��XPsW�w^{^��«\[f�r�i�k��Yk(i��Ya[aFa[R(fr�^gk��+���qt��uxwX[f\!�8XZR��vª«X[�w\m�uXZ�Yk# f�\[�j��^go 'w�Ykp�P�-S¡z+��a[aZ�Ya�X«s_f�f�tdX[R��qt�f�r�\v�uk�k�ogXZo{f�i+�u^¢X[�YaZX[avs_�jR-�ukpaZ�YX��¢\m��i�n0o{i(ha[XZr�k��Yi0X�����R����uk�f�t�aZX[r�k(�Yi0X �H�ui(kjaZX[r�k(�Yi0XdªW��R����uk�f�t�aZX[r�k(�Yi0X �v�

�8��a[XZ^{}0��sW�qxYfi�aZogk��Y\vX[R(� � ���uaZX«� ! ¦0r+�u\Z�Ya�� ª«X ��^{aZfTam��X[oga«¬-�Ya��u^g^_futdX[R(�j\Z�Y¦0r�og\[�Yk\[�Y^���X[ogfi�aZR�ogz�a����ui(k�z+�uaZa[�YaPi(o{i(�vfut%X[R��vXZR�og\[X[�w�YipXZ�Ya[XZa"s_�vR+�uk�aZ�YX�� t���o{^gogi�hqfi�^g}TXZf\m��i�n�aZX[r�k��wi~XZa # �ui�k��J��R�����kjf�t3a[X[r(k��Yi0X � �ui�k�XZfv\m�ui(n�a[XZr�k��Yi0XZa�] �ui�kT�Ni(���u\a[XZr�k��Yi0X �v�

ª�tvsW��t�r(\[X[R(�Y\�aZX[ogz�r�^���X[��X[R-�uXTs_�Y^g^���\Zfr�i�k(�Yk�i��YaZa�aZR�fr(^{k �-�J�lt���xYX[f�\�� � ���uaZX«�! ¦0r+�u\Z�Yaday�uXZo{a¯¬+�Ya��u^g^-t�fr(\Wf�t�X[R(�"�uk�k(o{XZogfi+��^+XZ�Ya[XZa��

� �l=%?A@¡L6G � ��Q!B�@�YG�E <>= �������0EjG��� ��

��f"�ui�aZsW�w\%X[R��|a[�YxYf�i�k�¦0r��Ya[XZogfi8�0s_�dXy�un�|X[R��|ogi�ogX[o��u^�XZ�Ya[X%z-fz(r�^��uX[ogf�i8��ui(k�k�\Zfzj��^g^z�^gr�a[�wa���i�k��qo{i0r�aZ�Ya�t�\[f�� X[R��|\m�ui(n~ogi�h�a����%R�oga3^g���!��wa���aZog��og^��u\Aa[�wX%futA\m�ui(n~ogi�h�a�����r�Xs%ogX[RFt���\3^g�Ya[a_ogi0t�f\Z�j��X[ogfi8� �W�YX3s_����\[�%aZX[og^g^+�u��^g�%XZfPk��YXZ�Y\[�qo{i(�%a[f�q�W�-�ua[ogx%ogi0X[r�ogXZo{���\[�Y^���X[ogfi�aZR�ogzqt�\[f��¡X[R��wa[�PXZ\m�ui(a[xY\Zo{z(X[a�§

¨ SNaZR�fr(^{k��-�P\m��i�n�wk ���+fu����U���] �u�-fu����F���ui�kT� �u�-fu�� �Na[ogi�xY��X[R��Y}�R+�!����-�YXZX[�Y\�h\y�uk��wa%o{iqa[og��og^��u\¢xYfr�\Za[�Ya!�

Sdi0}����^go{kv\y�ui�n0ogi�hvaZ}~aZX[�Y�>�vr�aZXWay�uX[oga¯t�}�XZR��Ya[��xYfi�k(o{XZogfi�a!����W��^{aZf�\[�YxYf�hi�ogaZ�WXZR��_t�f^g^gfus%ogi�h_\[�Y^��uXZogfi�aZR�ogz�a3�ua�z�\[�¥t��Y\m����^g�%��r�X�i�f�X�����a[f�^gr�X[�Y^g}

i��YxY�wa[am��\[}A§

¨ � a[R(fr�^gk��+�v\y�ui�n��Ykp�uR��!�uk�futd�6�-�Yx���r�a[��R��FR+�ua�a[^goghR0X[^g}��+�wX[X[�w\"h�\m�uk(�YaPogiXZR��Pay�u���|xYfr(\[a[�w^{f0�uk8�

¨ �laZR�fr�^gkq�+��\m��i�n�wk ��R�����k�fut�V��+�wx��ur�aZ�PR���R+��a%X[R���am�����%h�\m�uk(�Ya%ogij����f\Z�k(o���xwr�^gXWxYf�r�\[aZ�Y^gf~��k8�¨ � a[R�f�r�^gkT�+�F\m��i�n�wk ��R����uk�fut � �ui(k �N�-�Yx���r�a[�vR��FR+��a���^g��faZXW�w¦~r(o{���^g�Yi0Xh�\m��k��Yadogi��F�vr�xyRv��f\Z�dk�o���xYr(^{X_xYf�r�\[aZ�Y^gf~�uk��

¨ ] aZR�fr(^{k��+�P\y�ui�n��Yk���R����uk�fut3ªd�ui�k��H�-�Yx���r�a[�vR(�PR+�ua|X[R���am�u�q��h\m��k��Ya�ogi�F�qf\Z�dk�o���xYr�^gX_xYfr(\[a[�w^{f0�uk8�

¨ ª¢a[R�f�r�^gk��-�d\m��i�n�wkj�uR(���ukqfut �H��i�k ���+�Yx!�ur�aZ�PR��dR-�ua_X[R���am�����%h�\m�uk(�YaWogi���qf\Z�dk�o���xYr�^gX_xYfr(\[a[�w^{f0�uk8�

¨ �H��i�k ��a[R(fr�^gk��-��\m��i�n�Yk��uR��!�uk�fut �V�ui�k # �-�Yx���r�a[�PXZR��Y}qR+�!��|X[R��|am�u�q�h�\m��k��Yadogi��F��f\Z�%k�o���xYr�^gX%xYf�r�\[aZ�Y^gf~�uk��¨ �V�ui�k # a[R(fr�^gk��-�d\y�ui�n��YkT�uR��!�ukvfut �N�ui�k ���-�Yx��ur(a[��X[R��w}vR+�!��|X[R��|am�u�q�h�\m��k��Yadogi��F��f\Z�%k�o���xYr�^gX%xYf�r�\[aZ�Y^gf~�uk��

����h�v��|fut3�±

Page 12: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

ª�t+s_�Wz-faZX[r�^��uXZ�3X[R-�uX�X[R��_s_�Y^g^��«\[f�r�i�k��wk�i��YaZa��uf�\8^��uxyn�X[R��w\[�Yf�tm�ufutA�%a[XZr�k��Yi0X!� a�aZxmR(�Yk�r�^g�a[R�f�r�^gk��!�A�YxYX�R�oga|\m�ui(n��-s_� ��^ga[fF¬+i�k�X[R+��X�]��A�%�A�v�+��i�kTª%aZR�fr�^gkT�-�F\m�ui(n�YkTi(���u\���uxyRTf�X[R��w\%�+�Yx!�ur�aZ�§

¨ � R+�ua¢a[^goghR0X[^g}FsWf�\[a[�|h\y�uk��Ya_ogi�����f�\[�_k�o���xYr�^gX����-�YX[XZ�Y\«�«\[f�r�i�k��Yk�xYfr�\Za[�Y^gf0�uk8�¨ ]�R+��aWXZR���am�u�q�dh�\m�uk(�Yad�uad� �ui�kqª3ogij�Fa[^goghR0XZ^{}F��f�\[�%k�o���xYr(^{X!�0a[^goghR0X[^g}F^g�Ya[as_�Y^g^���\Zfr�i(k��Yk�xYfr(\[a[�w^{f0�uk8�

�%R��P\y�ui�n0ogi�ha_fut�X[R�oga%ay�u��z(^{�|z+f�z�r�^��uXZogfij��\[��hog���Yi�ogi ! �YxYXZogfi �F�V�og\[a[X�s_�vxYfi(a[ogk��Y\PXZR��FX[\m��k�ogX[ogfi-�u^3�P�-S"�-ª«XPk(f~�waPam��X[oga«t�}�XZR��v\[�Y^���X[ogfi�aZR�ogz�a�sW�R+�uk�\Z�Y¦0r�og\[�Yk8�A��i�k�o{X%k(f~�wad\m��i�nj� �uR��!�uk�futW��� �dfus_�Y���Y\��(o{X_t«�uog^gaW�Y���Y\[}�f�i���fut3X[R��fXZR��Y\dXZ�Ya[XZads_��R+�uk�a[�wX%t�f�\WogX��0z-�ua[aZogi�hvfi�^g}vf�i���fut�X«s_�Y^g����

ª�t8s_���u^gaZfPa[XZo{z(r�^��uX[�|X[R+��X3s_�Y^g^��«\[f�r�i�k��wk�i��YaZa%a[R�f�r�^gk��-���|t���xYX[f�\��0XZR��dXZ\m�uk(o{XZogfi+��^�P�-SNz+��a[a[�wadX[R(\[�Y�Ffut�X[R��PaZog°�X[�wa[X[a|sW��R+��k�a[�YX!��t«�uog^go{i(hPX[fv\y�ui�n��pxw^{f�a[��X[fvªY�-]��0f\�v�# �w°~X|sW�FxYf�i�a[ogk��Y\�XZR�� ! Xm�ui(k+�u\Zk # f�\[�j��^go 'w�YkT�P�-S"�(ª«X��u^gaZf�am��X[oga«¬-�YaP�u^g^8f�tWX[R��\[�Y¦0r�og\Z�Yk�\Z�Y^��uXZo{f�i�a[R(o{z(a��+��i�kT\y�ui�n0a�� ���+fu�������-]N�u�-fu���ªY�-ªWR(o{h�R��Y\|X[R+��i �v���-fX[R

�¡�ui�k ���uR�����k�fut �����ui(kj�-fXZR � ��i�k # �uR��!�uk�fut �H��i�k �P�0ª«X%z+��a[aZ�YadXZR��Ya[�Fa[og°X[�YaZX[a!�8��r(Xdt«�uog^ga%o{i�X[R��Fa[og°�fXZR��Y\[a!�Ai�f�Xd\m��i�n0ogi�hj�6���+fu��� V_�-ªd�uR(���ukTf�t �3�-�-fXZR ��ui�k ��R�ogh�R��Y\%X[R-�ui # ��] �u�-fu����v��� �uR�����k�f�t �F����i�kT�NR�oghR(�Y\%X[R+��i �P�

ª�t3sW��a[X[ogz�r(^`��X[�PXZR+�uX�s_�Y^g^���\Zfr�i�k(�Yk�i��YaZa�a[R�f�r�^gk ��^ga[f��-�"� t��uxYXZf\!�+XZR�� ! Xy�ui�k-�u\[k# f�\[�j��^go 'w�Yk"�P�-S�z+��a[a[�wa3fi�^g}Pf�i��%fut-X[R��%aZo{°F�uk�k�ogXZo{f�i+�u^0XZ�Ya[XZa���\m�ui(n~ogi�h�f�i�^g}���i(���u\]��

�%R�og\[kvs_�dxwfi�aZo{k(�Y\WXZR���ª«X[�Y\y�uXZ�Yk # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wk �P�-SF�uª«X_am�uXZoga«¬+�Yad��^g^�X[R��|\[�Y^���X[ogfi0�a[R�ogz�a�sW�vR+��k�\Z�Y¦0r�og\[�Yk�����i�k ��^ga[f�z+�uaZa[�Ya�i�ogi��vfutWXZR��vX«s_�Y^g��FfX[R(�Y\P\[�wxYf�q���Yi�k(�YkX[�YaZX[a!��t«�uog^go{i(hPfi�^g}vXZfv\m�ui(n�] ��R����uk�f�t��v��] �uR��!�uk�fut�ªY�+�ui(k�ª%�uR�����k�fut �¢�

ª�t�s_�T�u^ga[f�a[XZogz�r�^��uXZ��X[R(�js_�Y^g^���\Zfr�i(k��Yk�i��wa[a�aZR�fr(^{kl�+����t���xYX[f�\��¢X[R���ª«X[�w\m�uXZ�Yk# f�\[�j��^go 'w�Yk��P�-S6ay�uX[oga¯¬+�Ya%X[R(\[�Y��fut8XZR���a[og°v�uk�k�ogXZo{f�i+�u^(X[�YaZX��0t«�uog^go{i(hdX[fF\m��i�n���i(���u\ªY�+]��0f�\d�v�

�8��a[XZ^{}qsW��xYfi�aZogk��Y\dXZR�� �A����a[X«� ! ¦0r+��\[�Ya|���YXZR�f0k8�_ª«X��u^gaZfvam�uXZoga«¬+�Ya��u^g^8f�t3X[R��P\Z�y�¦0r�og\[�YkF\[�Y^���X[ogfi�aZR�ogz�a����ui�k"��k�k�ogX[ogf�i+�u^g^g}day�uX[oga¯¬+�Ya�i�ogi��_fut+XZR��%X[R�og\ZX[�Y�YiF\[�wxYf�q���Yi�k(�Yk\[�Y^���X[ogfi�aZR�ogz�a���t«�uog^go{i(hPX[fv\y�ui�n�] �u�-fu����Hf�\WªY�-�ui�kqX[fv\y�ui�nv�-fXZR � ��i�k # ��R����ukfut �P�

ª�t�s_�|t�r�\ZX[R��Y\|a[XZo{z(r�^��uX[�|X[R���sW�Y^g^��«\[fr(i�k�i��YaZa%X[�YaZX[a!�+XZR��Yi �A�!�ua[X¯� ! ¦~r-�u\[�wadam��X[oga«¬-�Yat�fr(\dfut3XZR��Pa[og°�X[�wa[X[a!�(t��uog^gogi�h"XZfv\m��i�nT�Hi(���u\�]N�ui�kT�Nb��di(�"x���iTa[�w�"XZR+�uX��������voga�Ft�r�'`'Y}�X[�Y\Z���0i�f�XdXZ\m�ui(a[ogX[og�����a[ogi�xw�"� oga%i�����\dªY�+��i�k�ª%oga%i����u\��6�ui(k�]�����r(Xd� ogai�fX%i(���u\d��f�\�]%ew�

;� �"@�BPO ��Q �y@ �

.�-,P. ��8i>��3=:P:!D;8 A 1;3 � 8-D43=: � K Q 6�3=3�����WR-�!���t�f�r�\�s��!}0a�fut+f�\[k��Y\Zogi�h�a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a!§�z�^��uogi"�P�-SF� ! Xy�ui�k+��\[k # f�\[�j��^go 'w�YkP�P�-S"�ª«X[�Y\y�uXZ�Yk # f\[���u^go('Y�Yk��P�-S"�A��i�k��A����a[X¯� ! ¦0r+��\[�Ya!� ! ogi�xY���u^g^�t�fr�\F�u\[�v�qf\Z�"f�\P^g�Ya[a\[����a[f�i+�u��^g��(X[R��w}jaZR�fr(^{k��uh�\[�Y��t«�uog\[^g}FsW�Y^g^As%ogX[R�����xyRjf�X[R��w\��

����h�v����fut3�±

Page 13: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

�|i���s��!}FX[fFX[�wa[X���h\Z�Y�Y���wi~X_ogaWXZf"z(^{f�XW�!�uxyR�aZX[r�k��wi~X!� ad\m��i�nvr�i�k(�Y\%fi��|���YXZR�f0ks%ogX[R�R�oga�\y�ui�nlr�i�k��Y\qX[R���fX[R(�Y\[a!� ª�tPXZR��Tz�^gfXvogavaZx��uXZX[�Y\Z�Yk \y�ui�k(f��^g}0��X[R��wi6X[R��\m��i�n0o{i(haPk�f�i�f�X"�uh�\[�Y�����+f�r�X"��i~}0XZR�ogi�h+�Fª�tdX[R(�vz�^gfX�oga"�qa[X[\y�uoghR0XP^gogi��� X[R��YilX[R��\m��i�n0o{i(had�uh�\[�Y��xYf���z�^g�YXZ�Y^g}~�

��fTh�wX ��ipogk���� t�f\�R�fus¡����xmRl��f0k��Y^_s_f\[n0a!�3�T^��u\Zh�qz+f�z�r�^��uXZo{f�i�futdaZX[r�k��wi~XZa�ui�k�xYfr�\Za[�Ya�s%�ua%xY\Z���uXZ�Yk�r�a[ogi�h��Fi0r��q�Y\[ogx���^+aZo{�vr(^`��X[ogfi��s%ogX[R��!����a[XZr�k��Yi0XZa��A����xYfr(\[a[�wa����ui�k� xYfr(\[a[�waPz+�w\�aZX[r�k(�Yi0X��P�%R(�Pk��YXy�uog^gadfut_X[R��Fa[og�vr�^��uXZf\%�u\Z�"�Y°0z�^���o{i(�Ykogi ! �YxYXZo{f�iJ�%��S|^g^WXZR��j��^{h�f\Zo{XZR���a|sW�w\[�j��z�z�^gog�Yk�X[f�X[R��Y� �Y°0xY�wz�X �A����a[X¯� ! ¦0r+��\[�Ya!�s%R�ogxyRjs%�ua%XZf0fvk�o���xYr�^gXWXZf"og�qz�^g�Y���Yi0X�ogi�X[R��P�!��uog^��u�(^{�%XZog����

����������� ��� ������������������������� �"!#�$�&%��

! �Y�-V�o{h�r�\[�wa����u���u�ui�k#$�t�f\Ah�\m�uz(R�a�fut�X[R��_�uh\Z�Y�Y�q�Yi0X��!r�a[ogi�h|a[og�vr�^��uXZ�YkdaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[aW��i�kxYfr(\[a[�wa��W��i�k��u^g^gfus%o{i(hvz�^gr�a"�ui(k��qo{i0r�a|h\y�uk��Ya!�v�%R��vxYf���z+��\[oga[f�i�adXZfTz�^��uogi����-S\m��i�n0o{i(had�u\Z��\m�uXZR��Y\%aZx��uXZX[�Y\Z�Yk8�A�YaZz+�wxYo��u^g^g}�X[fus%�u\Zk�XZR���^{fus_�Y\%^g�yt�X_xYf�\[i��Y\|s%R��Y\Z�PX[R��R�oghR��wa[X�\y�ui�n0ogi�h�a��u\[���6�%R��Tz(^`��ogiJ�P�-S \y�ui�n0ogi�havk(f�i�fX���z�z+�!�u\�XZfp�uh�\[�Y�Tz-�u\«�X[ogxYr�^���\[^g}�sW�Y^g^�s%o{XZRT�YogX[R(�Y\�X[R��Pª«XZ�Y\m��X[�Yk # f\Z�j�u^go('Y�Ykqf\|X[R�� ! Xm��i�k+��\[k # f\[���u^go('Y�Yk\m��i�n0o{i(ha�� �%R��Y\[���u\[�q^gfX[aFfut�a[x���X[XZ�Y\[�Yk�z+f�o{i0XZa����%R�ogaFoga"k�r(�j�qfaZX[^g}�XZf�XZR��vt«�uxYXX[R+��X%X[R��w\[�v�u\[��^gfXZa%fut�X[og�Yadogiqz�^��uogij�P�-S \m��i�n0ogi�ha!���YaZz+�Yxwo`��^g^{}qi�����\%X[R��PXZfzqfut3X[R��xY^��uaZa��8��i�kTX[og�Yk�a[X[r(k��Yi0X[aP�u\Z�"f�\[k��w\[�Yk���f�\[��f\|^{�wa[aP�uX|\m�ui(k�f���('¢�Y\[}qt��Ys X[og�Ya��u\[�z�\[�wa[�Yi0Xvogi ��i0}�f�t�XZR���f�X[R��Y\����YXZR�f0k�a��q�%R��vª«X[�w\m�uXZ�Yk # f\Z�j�u^go('Y�Yk��ui(k ! Xy�ui�k-�u\[k# f�\[�j��^go 'w�Yk�\y�ui�n0ogi�ha%�u\Z��o{i��-�YX[XZ�Y\���h\Z�Y�Y���wi~X!�0s%ogX[Rqt��Ys_�Y\%fr(X[^g}0o{i(h"z-fogi0X[a!��%R��vX«s_fTi�f�i0��XZ\m��k�ogX[ogfi+��^����YXZR�f0k�a�k�f��uh�\[�Y�q��f�a[X[^g}0�-��r�XPi�f�XPxYf���z�^g�YXZ�Y^g}~�Af�iX[R���¬+\[aZX%k��YxYog^g��3�%R(�Y}j��h\[�w�Pfi8�±Ffut�X[R��v�!���a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a�ogi�XZR��PX[f�z�k��wxYog^{���

S a[ogi�h^g�|\[r�iqfut�XZR���a[og�vr�^��uXZogfiPoga%�ui+��^{} 'Y�wk�R��Y\Z����(r�X%X[R��wa[��\[�YaZr�^gX[a��u\[�|X«}0z�ogx��u^fut3fXZR��Y\%\Zr�i�a��

���������*) ��� �,+��-.�������������������&�/�0�"!#�$�&%��

! �Y��V�oghr�\Z�Ya#R-� &(�8�ui(k t�f\�h\y�uz�R(a�f�tWX[R(���uh\Z�Y�Y�q�Yi0X��-r�a[ogi�h�aZo{�vr(^`��X[�Yk�aZX[r�k��wi~XZa�ui�k�xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya��A��i�k�k�ogam�u^g^gfus%ogi�h�z�^gr�ad�ui(kj�qogi~r(a3h\y�uk��Ya!�S6h�\[����X3k�����^+f�t8o{i£t�f\Z�j�uXZogfi�oga3^gfa[X¢s%o{XZR�fr(X3X[R��|r�a[�|fut8z�^gr�a_�ui�kv�qo{i0r�a�h\y�uk��Ya!�

ª«i�z-�u\[XZogxYr�^��u\|X[R��Y\Z���u\Z�"���ui0}��qf\[��X[og�Ya�ogiTX[R��Fz�^��uogiT�P�-S �+�uaZ�Yk�\m��i�n0o{i(h�s%R�ogxyRa[R�fus r�z��ua�^��u\[h��"aZ¦0r+�u\Z�YaPfut%a[x!�uX[XZ�Y\[�wkpz-fogi0X[a����%R��F^`��\[h��"aZ¦~r-�u\[����XdXZR��v�+f�X[XZf�^g�yt�XFa[R�fus%aFX[R��q�j��a[a[og���vX[og�j����fi(h�z-�Yfz�^g��s%ogX[R R-� ���!��Y\y�uh�wa���Sdh0�uogi8��X[R���z�^��uogi�P�-S ogadi�f�X�ogi�hf0f0k��uh�\[�Y�w���Yi0X�s%ogX[RTXZR��vi�fi£��XZ\m�uk(o{XZogfi+��^8���wX[R�f0k�a|k�r��FX[f�X[R��wa[�X[og�Ya!�PU_fX[R�i��YsH�qf0k��Y^ga���h\[�w�"s%ogX[R����uxyR�fX[R(�Y\�fi ��±vfut_X[R��������va[XZr�k��Yi0XZaPogiTX[R��X[f�zvk��YxYog^g���Sdz(z+�u\Z�Yi0X[^g}~��X[R��%^gfaZa3futAogi0t�f�\[�j��X[ogfi�oga�\[�YaZz+f�i�a[og��^g� t�f\�X[R(�%h\[�!�uX[�w\W^��uxynfutW�uh�\[�Y�w���Yi0X��

.�-, � ��8i> � ����121J8-3 � � 1;C�G Q ?/G Q43 G;3 HJ6�CED43�K65!3 � A A�1;33��-A �i8�< 3 �

ª�tWfi(�"h�\m�uk(�"f�tWfi���a[X[r(k��Yi0XPogadxyR+��i�h�Yk��AR�oga�\m�ui(njx!�ui��+�F�Y°0z+�wxYX[�Yk�XZf�xmR-�ui�h��"�uasW�w^{^«� V(f\Fz�^��uogip�P�-S¡\y�ui�n0ogi�ha!��xyR+�ui�h�ogi�h�f�i���aZX[r�k(�Yi0X�� avh\y�uk��Yavx!�uipf�i�^g}��qfu��X[R+��X�a[X[r(k��Yi0X�t�\Zf� fi(�"z�^���xY�"XZfT�ui�f�X[R��Y\!�Pª«i�X[R��vi(fi0�«X[\y�uk�ogX[ogf�i+�u^A\y�ui�n0ogi�ha!�A����xmR

����h�v�o$�fut3�±

Page 14: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Sta

ndar

d N

orm

aliz

ed G

PA

Ran

k

Plain GPA Rank

V�o{h�r�\[�F�§���^��uogi��P�-S6\y�ui�n0ogi�h�a3z�^gfXZX[�Yk���h~�uogi�aZX ! Xy�ui�k+��\[k # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wk �P�-S�\m�ui(n�ogi�ha!�0r�a[ogi�hvaZo{�vr(^`��X[�YkvaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a��

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Itera

ted

Nor

mal

ized

GP

A R

ank

Plain GPA Rank

V�o{h�r�\[�F��§%��^��uogij���-SN\m�ui(n~ogi�h�adz�^gf�X[X[�wk��uh0�uogi�a[X%ª«XZ�Y\m��X[�Yk # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wk ���-SN\m�ui(n�ogi�ha!�0r�a[ogi�hvaZo{�vr(^`��X[�YkvaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a��

����h�v�`RFfut3�±

Page 15: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Itera

ted

Nor

mal

ized

GP

A

Standard Normalized GPA

V�o{h�r�\[� $�§ ! Xm��i�k+��\[k # f�\[���u^go('Y�Ykv�P�-S6\m��i�n0ogi�ha3z(^{f�X[XZ�Yk��uh0�uogi�a[X¢ª«X[�Y\y�uX[�wk # f\Z�j�u^��o('Y�Yk��P�-S \m��i�n0ogi�ha!�0r�a[ogi�hvaZo{�vr(^`��X[�YkvaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a��

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Sta

ndar

d N

orm

aliz

ed G

PA

Ran

k

Plain GPA Rank

V�o{h�r�\[�;R+§���^��uogi��P�-S6\y�ui�n0ogi�h�a3z�^gfXZX[�Yk���h~�uogi�aZX ! Xy�ui�k+��\[k # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wk �P�-S�\m�ui(n�ogi�ha!�0r�a[ogi�hvaZo{�vr(^`��X[�YkvaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a��A��i�k�i�f"z(^{r(a%f\%��ogi0r�a3h�\m��k��Ya��

����h�v�o&�fut3�±

Page 16: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Itera

ted

Nor

mal

ized

GP

A R

ank

Plain GPA Rank

V�o{h�r�\[�S&�§%��^��uogij���-SN\m�ui(n~ogi�h�adz�^gf�X[X[�wk��uh0�uogi�a[X%ª«XZ�Y\m��X[�Yk # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wk ���-SN\m�ui(n�ogi�ha!�0r�a[ogi�hvaZo{�vr(^`��X[�YkvaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a��A��i�k�i�f"z(^{r(a%f\%��ogi0r�a3h�\m��k��Ya��

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Itera

ted

Nor

mal

ized

GP

A R

ank

Standard Normalied GPA Rank

V�o{h�r�\[���§ ! Xm��i�k+��\[k # f�\[���u^go('Y�Ykv�P�-S6\m��i�n0ogi�ha3z(^{f�X[XZ�Yk��uh0�uogi�a[X¢ª«X[�Y\y�uX[�wk # f\Z�j�u^��o('Y�Yk��P�-S \m��i�n0ogi�ha!�0r�a[ogi�hvaZo{�vr(^`��X[�YkvaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a��A��i�k�i�fvz(^{r(a%f\%��ogi0r�a3h�\m��k��Ya��

����h�v���fut3�±

Page 17: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

a[XZr�k��Yi0X�� a_z+f�a[ogX[ogf�ivo{a¢k��YX[�w\[��ogi��wkv\[�Y^��uXZog��_X[fPXZR��df�X[R��Y\_a[XZr�k��Yi0XZa����ui(kvfi��%xyR+��i�h�Ykh\y�uk�����ogh�R~X�XZ\[oghh��Y\d�PxyR+��ogi�fut�\m��i�nvxyR+�ui�h��Ya�����fFX[�YaZXdXZR���a[�Yi�aZogX[og�0o{X«}0��X[R���am����z�^g�z+f�z�r�^��uXZogfiFs���a3��f0k�o�¬+�Yk�a[^goghR0X[^g}0� ��i�kva[XZr�k��Yi0X �F� a3h�\m�uk(�%fut8S ��ogi � r�a[ogx��dogaZX[f\Z}s���a%xyR+�ui�h��Yk�X[f��v]¢�Y���P���Y\[}�k�\y�uaZX[ogx�xmR-�ui�h���

�%R��_xyR+�ui�h��Ws%�ua�X[�YaZX[�Ykqogi�xY^gr�k�ogi�h%z�^gr�a3��i�k"�qogi~r(aAh\m��k��Ya3�ui(kPr�a[ogi�h�f�i�^g}�s%R(f^g�^g�YX[XZ�Y\�h\m��k��Ya!� �6R(�YiPfi(^{}|^g�YX[XZ�Y\�h\m��k��Ya��u\[�¢xYfi�aZogk��Y\[�wk8�XZR��3xyR+��i�h�3ogaAXZf��%]��!�daZo{i(hX[R��F�P�-S \y�ui�n0ogi�hv�ui�kqz�^gr�ad�ui(kj�qogi~r(a3h\y�uk��Ya!� � k�\[f�z�z+�wk�t�\[f�V�Ya[X%XZfT�`R�X[R8����i�kX[R��w\[��s_�Y\Z�vi�f�fX[R(�Y\PxyR+�ui(h�Ya!� �6ogX[RTf�i�^g}Ts%R�f�^{�F^g�YX[XZ�Y\Ph�\m�uk(�Ya�� � k�\Zfz�z-�Yk�t�\Zf��ui�k�XZfT��uXZR8���ui(kjXZR��Y\Z�PsW�w\[�Pi�fFfXZR��Y\|xmR-�ui�h��Ya%�Y°0xY�Yz�X|X[fv���un�|\[f0f� t�f\��F�

V(f\_X[R�� ! Xm�ui(k+�u\Zk # f\Z�j�u^go('Y�Yk����-SNs%o{XZR�z�^gr�ad��i�k���ogi0r�a3h�\m�uk(�Ya�� �Hk(\[fz(z+�Ykt�\[f�� $u\[kqX[f��!�uXZR8� �¢� # �~��i�k�Fo{�qz�\[fu���YkFa[�Y���Y\m��^Az�^��uxY�Ya!���uz�z-�u\[�wi~XZ^g}"�-�Yx���r�a[��X[R(�Y}�u^ga[f%XZf0fn�� r�a[ogx �|o{aZX[f�\[}���i�k��+�wi��y¬+XZX[�Yk�t�\[f�� XZR��3k�\Zfz�ogi�������idh\y�uk���� ��og��z�\Zfu��Ykfi��|a[z-fX!�~��z�z+�u\Z�Yi0X[^g}�t�f\3XZR��day�u�q�W\Z���uaZfi8� � k�\[f�z�z-�Yk��0}Ffi��� ��o{XZR�fr(X�z(^{r(a���i�k��ogi0r�a�h\y�uk��Ya!� � k�\[f�z�z-�Yk ��z�^��uxY�wa��0�ui�k +���3�0�ui�k # og��z�\Zfu��YkFfi��|z+f�a[ogX[ogf�i"����xyR8�! X[r(k��Yi0XvªPk�\Zfz�z-�YkpXZR�\[�w�Tz�^��uxY�wa��3z-�Y\ZR+�uz�av�-�Yx���r�a[��f�tdR�fus # �ui�k �V�+�Yi(�y¬+X[XZ�Ykt�\[f�� ��r�aZogx��doga[XZf\Z}~�

�%R��Pª«XZ�Y\m��X[�Yk # f\Z�j�u^go('Y�YkT�P�-SNogi�xw^{r(k�ogi�hvz�^gr�aP�ui�k���ogi0r�a%h\y�uk��Ya|s���a�\m�uXZR��Y\a[Xy�u��^g���� k�\[f�z�z+�wk ±�z�^��uxw�Ya��%�ui(k ��ui(k ��og��z�\Zfu��Ykp��xYf�r�z�^g��fut�z(^`��xY�Yav����xyR8��+�wi��y¬+XZX[ogi�h�t�\[f� X[R(� ��z�z+��\[�Yi0X�ogi�xw\[����a[�Togi�X[R���k�o���xYr(^{X«}lfut ��r�a[ogx �|oga[X[f�\[}0�6�k�\[f�z�z-�Yk�X«sWf�z�^��uxY�wa��3z-faZa[og��^g}��-�Yx��ur(a[��R���a[xYf�\[�Yk�^gfus_�Y\"ogi �|���u^gX[R����6R��Yilfi�^g}s%R�f^g�v^g�YXZX[�Y\Ph�\m��k��Ya"��\[�vr�aZ�Yk8� �¡k�\Zfz�a�t�\[f�� �o$�X[R�X[f����X[R8� ���i�k ��og��z(\[fu��F�xYfr(z�^g�%fut+z�^���xY�Ya����-�Yi��y¬+XZX[ogi�h�t�\[f� X[R��_ogi�xY\Z���uaZ�Yk�k�o���xYr(^{X«}�f�t ��r(a[ogx �|oga[X[f�\[}0�us%R�og^g�� k�\Zfz�a��uh~��ogi8�0X[R�\Z�Y�Fz�^��uxY�Ya|X[R�oga|X[og����_� �ui�k7Vla[s%ogX[xyR��wkTz�^��uxY�wadt�f\%i�fvf��~�0ogfr(a\[����a[f�i8�

�daZogi�h �A����a[X«� ! ¦0r+��\[�Yav�ui�k�z(^{r(a���i�k���ogi0r�a|h\m��k��Ya!� �¡k�\Zfz�aF±�z(^`��xY�Ya!�j�|X[R(�Y\���Y�v�-�Y\Zadfut_X[R�� ��r(a[ogx �|oga[X[f�\[}Txwfr�\Za[� T��i�k � o{�qz�\[fu���P���(o{X!�A�ui�k �lo{�qz�\[fu���Ya�T^gf�X�� ��o{XZR�^g�YX[XZ�Y\vh\y�uk��YaFfi(^{}0� �>k�\[f�z�aPt�\[f�D�s&uX[RlX[fp�!uXZR8�3�ui�k +� �v�3�ui�k��og��z�\Zfu��� V�f�\di�fqf�0�0ogfr�a|\[����a[fi��8� ��i�k�] a[s%ogX[xyR��Yk�z�^��uxw�Ya��P� k(\[fz(z+�Yk��0}�X«s_f�+�wx��ur�aZ�"f�t�og��z(\[fu��w���Yi0X[a¢�~}�� �ui�k �¢�

�%R0r�a��¢ogXPsWf�r�^gkpaZ�Y�Y� XZR+�uXvz�^���o{i��P�-S>\m��i�n0o{i(hToga"XZR�����faZXPa[Xy�u��^g��¢a[ogi�xY�T��X��f�a[Xdf�i��vz-�Y\[aZfi�xyR+�ui(h�YaPz-faZogX[ogfi��ui�k�X[R(�v\[�YaZX"�qfu���r�z�f\�k�fus%i��uX��qfa[X|fi��X[fTxwf��z-�Yi�ay�uXZ��F�%R��vi��Y°0XP�qfa[X|a[Xy�u��^g�va[�w�Y��aPXZf��+� � ���uaZX«� ! ¦0r+�u\Z�Ya���t�f�^g^{fus_�YkT�0}ª«X[�Y\y�uXZ�Yk # f\Z�j�u^go('Y�Yk��W�ui(kp¬-i+�u^g^g} ! Xm��i�k+��\[k # f�\[�j��^go 'w�Yk8��ª«i6����xyRJaZxyR��Y�����%X[R��xY^��uaZa[�j��X[�Ya�f�t�XZR��vz-�Y\[aZfi�s%R�faZ�"h�\m�uk(�"xyR+��i�h�Yk��u\Z�P��f�a[X|^{ogn��Y^g}�X[fqxyR+�ui�h��"\y�ui�nA��%R��Y\Z�ds_�Y\[�d�|t��YspxyR+��o{i£��\Z���uxYXZogfiF\[�y�«f\Zk��Y\[ogi�h�a��0s%R�ogxyRv�u\[�%R-�u\[k(�Y\3X[f��Y°0z�^��uogi8�AS|^{aZf+�R+�!�0ogi�h"z(^{r(ad�ui�k���ogi0r�a3h�\m��k��Yad�uz(z+����\[a|X[fvog��z�\Zfu��%aZXm�u�(o{^gogX«}Fo{i�h��Yi��Y\y�u^«�

.�-, � ��8i>21J8-3 � � 8 �46 � 3 � ?��i3 K65!3�� A A�143 3 � A �i8�< 3 �Sdi�f�X[R��w\%a[og�vr�^��uXZo{f�i"s%�ua_\[r(ijs%ogXZR��������aZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a�� &���PxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya��A��i�kj��xYfr(\[a[��^gf~��kfut��z-�Y\PaZX[r�k(�Yi0X���]_f�r�\[aZ�YaFx��u�q�"f�r�XPa[���u^g^g�Y\����ui�k�XZR���xYf�\[\Z�Y^��uX[ogf�i��-�YX«s_�Y�Yi�X[R��! Xm��i�k+��\[k # f\Z�j�u^go('Y�Yk�\m�ui(n~ogi�hF�ui�kFX[R��|ª«X[�Y\y�uXZ�Yk # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wkP\m��i�n0o{i(h�s%�ua_s_���un��Y\���%R�oga%oga%z�\[f��+�u��^g}vk�r(��XZfvX[R���t��uxYX_X[R-�uX%a[Xy�ui�k-�u\[k�k��Y�0o��uX[ogf�i�aWxwf��z(r�X[�Ykqfi�a[���u^g^g�Y\k+�uXy�Fa[�YXZadXZ�Yi�kTXZf"�-�P^g�Ya[a%\Z�Y^go��u��^g�����ad�u\[�P�!���Y\m��h��h\y�uk��Ya��ui�k��!��Y\y�uh������-S"� a��

����h�v� ��fut3�±

Page 18: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

;P; �"@�M�=%E ��@�K�?�BPE ��� =%B��vE�=%?8?8=%?lG�I��6B���K * G ��=%QqBPE �<�=��_GPCDCD=%E ��B�@�!GPE�?

�|r�\P\[�wxYf�q���Yi�k-�uX[ogf�ijR(o{i(h�Ya�fi�X[R(���ui�aZsW�Y\ZaPX[f�X«s_f�¦~r(�Ya[XZo{f�i�a�� s%R�ogxmR�s%og^g^����\[}xYf^g^g�Yh����0}qxYf^g^g�Yh���

ª�t8X[R(��xwf^g^g�Yh�|s%o{aZR��Ya_X[fFz�\[f���f�X[�%s_�Y^g^��«\[f�r�i�k��wk�i��YaZa%fu��Y\_a[z-�YxYo��u^go('���X[ogfiTbcs%R�ogxmRsW��aZr�hh��Ya[XyeY�A�ui�kqR+�uad��t���o{\Z^g}va[�j��^g^�z+f�z�r�^��uXZogfi�bc^g�Ya[a%XZR+�uiT�u�-fr(Xd�����a[XZr�k��Yi0XZameY�sW��\Z�YxYf�q���Yi(k�X[R(� � ���uaZX«� ! ¦0r+�u\Z�Ya����YXZR�f0k8��|X[R��w\[s%oga[��(sW��\[�YxYf����q�Yi�kvX[R(�Pª«X[�Y\y�uXZ�Yk # f�\[���u^go('Y�Yk��P�-S ���YXZR�f0k8����_t��Y�w^+XZR+�uX_X[R�� �A����a[X¯� ! ¦0r+��\[�Ya%�q�YX[R(f~kFogaWaZr�z-�Y\[ogf\_X[f�X[R��|fX[R(�Y\WX«s_fP�-�Yx���r�a[�§¨ ª«X%k(f~�wadi�f�XWz�r(i�oga[R�a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a|t�f�\���X[XZ�Y��z�XZogi�h"XZf"�w°~z-�ui�kTXZR��Yog\%R�f�\[o('Yfi(a��¨ ª«X_z�\Zf~k(r�xY�Ya%\Z�Ya[r�^gXZa%��f\Z�%xYfi(a[oga[XZ�Yi0XWs%ogX[Rqogi~XZr�ogX[og��_f�(a[�Y\Z��uX[ogf�i�X[R-�uivk�fFX[R��ª«XZ�Y\m��X[�Yk�f\ ! Xy�ui�k+��\[k # f�\[���u^go('Y�Yk��P�-SF�¨ ª«X%oga%�qf\[� �+�Y°0og��^g�dXZR+�ui��YogX[R(�Y\dXZR��Pª«X[�w\m�uXZ�YkTf�\ ! Xy�ui�k-�u\[k # f\[���u^go('Y�Yk��P�-S"�¨ ª«X%oga%xY^g����\d�ui�k�����a[og^g}vr�i�k��w\[a[XZf0f~k���%R��%ª«XZ�Y\m��X[�Yk # f\Z�j��^{o('Y�wk"�P�-S����YXZR�f0k"R-�uaW� t��Ys�k��¥¬+i�ogX[���uk����i~Xy�uh��Ya3�ua3s_�Y^g^«§¨ ª«X%oga%aZo{h�i�o�¬+x���i~XZ^g}Ft��uaZX[�Y\%XZR+�ui�X[R(� � ���uaZX«� ! ¦0r+�u\Z�Ya����YXZR�f0k8�¨ ª�tFX[R���sW�w^{^��«\[f�r�i�k��Yk(i��Ya[a�f�t"a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a�oga�i�fX���xYf�i�a[ogk��w\m�uXZogfi8�%ogXqz�\[f0k�r�xw�Ya\Z�Ya[r(^{XZa"s%R(o{xyR��u\Z�v\[fr(hR�^g}T�uaPxwfi�aZo{aZX[�Yi0XPs%ogXZR�ogi0X[r�ogXZo{���Pf�(a[�Y\Z��uX[ogf�i ��aPX[R��� ���uaZX«� ! ¦0r+�u\Z�Yad�q�YX[R(f~k��

���Ft��Y�w^%X[R+��X"XZR�� ! Xm��i�k+�u\Zk # f\[���u^go('Y�Ykp�P�-S ���YXZR�f0k�o{aFk��Yxwo{k(�Yk�^g}�ogi0t��Y\Zo{f�\���ui�k�aZR�fr�^gk�i�f�XW�-�P\[�wxYf�q���Yi�k(�Yk8���+�Yx!�ur�aZ�§

¨ ª«X¢�j�un��Ya�i�f"��X[X[�w��z�X3XZfPxYf�\[\[�wxYX3t�f\3aZxmR(�Yk�r�^g��k�o���xYr�^gX«}Pf�\3sW�w^{^��«\[f�r�i�k��Yk(i��Ya[a!�¨ ª«X���a[aZr����YaFX[R-�uXv�u^g^Wxwfr�\Za[�YaqR+�!��qX[R���am�����v\y�ui�h��jf�t��u��og^gogX«} ����f�i�h�X[R��Yog\aZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a��¨ ª«X�z�\Zf0k�r�xY�Ya¢\[�YaZr�^gX[a3s%R�ogxyRv�u\[�_i�f|��f\Z�3xYf�i�a[oga[XZ�Yi0X3s%ogX[RPogi0X[r(o{XZog��3f���a[�Y\Z��uXZo{f�iXZR+�ui�XZR�faZ�Pz�\[f0k�r(xY�YkT�0}vX[R(�PX[\y�uk�ogX[ogf�i+�u^A�P�-S"�¨ ª«X t�f\ZxY�YaT�u^g^|h\m��k��Ya�X[f��-��o{i0XZ�Y\[z�\Z�YX[�wkH�ua�z-�u\[Xqfut"���-�Y^g^�xYr�\Z���|s%R�ogxyR6ogaogi+��z�z�\Zfz�\Zo`��X[�|t�f�\WaZ�j�u^g^A�ui�kqR�oghR�^g}vaZz+�Yxwo`��^go 'w�YkTxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya��

; � ����M�@�K�=%MH<>=��WG�CDCD=%E���B�@ ��G�Ej?

. � ,P. 0S6�CEG� ?FA�?P8�G�o6�8 < HJ5#KMLNCEG4O-?PG-Q�%R��PXZR�\[�Y�����YXZR�f0k�aWh�og��YiqR��Y\[�F�u^g^A\m��i�n��ui��Yi0X[og\Z��aZX[r�k(�Yi0Xd�-f~k(}vt�f�\Wf�i���a[�Y�q�Ya[XZ�Y\futdxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya�� �%R~r(a��3XZfT\m��i�n�a[XZr�k��Yi0XZad¤yr�a[XFs%ogX[R�ogip��aZogi�h^g��xw^`��a[a!��sW�q�vr�a[XP�wo{XZR��Y\�!��Y\y�uh��jXZR��Yog\j����og^go{X«}�a[xwf\[�wa bc\[�Y�0oga[�wk �P�-S"� ayeFf\vX[R(�Yog\�\m��i�n0avs%ogX[R�ogi�X[R��wo{\vxw^`��a[afu��Y\%�!�uxyRTa[�w���YaZX[�Y\!�

����h�v� ��fut3�±

Page 19: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

�%R��vi��ws aZ}0a[X[�w� xwfr�^gk��+�qz�R+�uaZ�Yk�ogi ��X"�ui0}TXZog���Po�t%h\m��k��Ya�t�f\��Yi�f�r�hR�z�\Z�y�xY�Yk�ogi�h�}����u\Za���\[�Fn�Yz(X�f�i�\Z�YxYf�\[k8���%R��"i(�Ys \m�ui(n~ogi�h���^ghf\ZogX[R��>xYfr(^{k��-� ��z�z�^gog�YkX[fla[X[r(k��Yi0X[a�s%R�flR+�!���h\y�uk�r-�uX[�wk6X[flk��YX[�w\[��ogi�ogi�h�\m��i�n0ogi�ha t�f\vXZR��Ti��Y°0X�xY^��uaZa���dfus_�Y��w\���s_��\[�Yxwf���q�Yi�kvx���\[�yt�r�^AX[�YaZX[ogi�hvf�i�a[�w��Y\y�u^8z-�ua[X%}����u\Za%fut�k+�uXy�"��a%sW�Y^g^A�uaxYr�\Z\[�Yi0X�h\y�uk��Ya!�

�%R��W��k���ogi�ogaZX[\m��X[ogfi%aZR�fr(^{k��+�3z(\[�Yz+��\[�Yk�t�f�\��%h�\[����X8k��!�u^f�t+a[XZr�k��Yi0X��ui�k�t«�uxYr�^gX«}fz�z-faZogX[ogfiv�-�Yx���r�a[�PogX3oga%��i��YsP�0r(i~XZ�Ya[XZ�Yk�a[}0a[XZ�Y�����%R(� ! Xy�ui�k+��\[k # f\[���u^go('Y�Yk���i�kª«X[�Y\y�uXZ�Yk # f�\[�j��^go 'w�Yk�a[xyR��Y�q�Ya"�u\Z�"�qfaZX%^{ogn��Y^g}jXZf�x���r�a[�vf�z�z-fa[ogXZo{f�iT�-�Yx��ur(a[�vX[R(�Y}k�og\[�YxwX[^g} ��^gX[�Y\3XZR��%z-fogi0X����^gr��Ya�futAh\y�uk��Ya¢k�r�\[ogi�h�xYf���z�r(Xm�uXZogfi8�-�%R��� ���uaZX«� ! ¦0r+�u\Z�Ya���YXZR�f0k�aZog��z�^g}�\Z�y�«o{i0XZ�Y\[z�\Z�YX[aFX[R(�Y� ��i�k�oga�^g�Ya[a�^gogn�Y^g}�X[f����un��X[����xmR(�Y\[a�t��Y�Y^3XZR+�uXX[R��wo{\��ur�XZR�f\ZogX«}vR+�ua%�-�Y�YiT�0ogf^���X[�Yk8�

. � , � 0S6�CEG� �o3=6 � A �;D43=G A �SdU%]�]_f^g^g�Yh�_s%og^{^0R+�!���%X[f�xYf����_r�z"s%ogXZR"ogX[a¢fus%i"z-f^gogxY}PxYf�i�xY�Y\Zi�ogi�hPXZR��%\m��i�n0o{i(h�f�tX[\y�ui�a¯t��Y\_a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a!�W�|i��df�z�X[ogf�i"oga3XZfPX[\y�ui�aZ^`��X[�|X[\m��i�a«t��Y\[\Z�Yk�h\m��k��Ya3XZf"�uiv�w¦~r(o{���^g�Yi0Xh\y�uk���ogi � z+�u\ZX[ogxYr�^���\�xYf�r�\[aZ� ��X�SdU%]��_�%R+�uX��u^g^gfus%avX[R���\m��i�n0ogi�hp�u^ghf�\[ogX[R(� XZf\[r�i�f�i�X[R��v���u°0og�"r(� ����fr(i~X|fut%ogi0t�f\Z�j��X[ogfi8� �|fusW�w��Y\!��a[f�q�Yfi(�"s%og^g^�R+�!��vXZfxYf�qz+�u\Z�W�u^g^0fXZR��Y\�xYf�^{^g�Yh��Ya�X[f�SdU%]����Y\[}�x��u\Z�yt�r�^g^g}PX[f|xY\[�!�uX[�%XZR��%fu��xwo`��^XZ\m�ui(a[^��uXZo{f�iz+f�^go{xw}~�¢Sdi�f�X[R��Y\|z+f�a[aZo{�(o{^gogX«}�oga%XZfvo{h�i�f\Z�PX[\y�ui�a¯t��Y\Z\[�Yk�h\y�uk��Ya|s%R��YiTxwf��z(r�X[ogi�hFX[R��\m��i�n0o{i(ha�� �%R+�uXP�!�f�ogk�adXZR��vz�\[f���^g�Y��f�t��wa[X[og���uX[ogi�hqR�fusHh�\m��k��Ya"��X�f�X[R��w\Pa[xyR�f0f^gaxYf�qz+�u\Z�dXZfvSdU%]�� a!����r(Xd�uX%X[R(���w°~z-�Yi�aZ�"f�t�XZR�\[fus%ogi�hFfr�Xd�F^gf�XWf�t�ogi0t�f�\[�j��X[ogfi��

. � , � �]< � 8�6 A�CEG��i3N8 �757:�� �@CEG4D � ?/G ��NHJ6�CED43 �ª«X%a[�Y�w��a%X[R-�uX%z�^gr�ad��i�k���ogi0r�a3h\y�uk��wad�u\[���Y°0XZ\[�Y�q�Y^g}�R��Y^gz0t�r�^Aogi�k��YXZ�Y\[�qogi�ogi�h"xw^`��a[a\m��i�nA�A�Ya[z-�YxYo���^{^g}�a[ogi�xY�Fh\y�uk��wa"�u\Z�va[f�R����!�0og^g}jogi0�A�uX[�wk8� �6ogXZR�fr�X�XZR��Y���-S|U�] R+�uaX[fq\m�ui(njogXZada[XZr�k��Yi0XZaPz�\[og���u\[og^g}FfiTXZR��"�-�ua[oga|fut+¤yr�aZX�X«s_fvh\y�uk��wa��AS �ui�kTU��A�ui�k��xYfi(a[ogk��Y\y�u��^g�%t�\m�uxwX[ogfivf�t8X[R��|a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a_R+�!��%�w°£��xYX[^g}vXZR��day�u���_h\y�uk��wa�� �6ogX[Rvz(^{r(a[�Ya�ui�k���ogi0r�aZ�Ya��-X[R(�Y\[����\[�Fa[og°�k�o����Y\Z�Yi0XPh\y�uk��wa��AS �"� S"�AS �¥�-U��"��U�����i�k�U3�Y�As%R�ogxyRxYf�q�vogi~XZf�z�^��!}~��X[R0r�aPk(o��A�Y\Z�Yi0X[o��uXZo{i(hTa[XZr�k��Yi0X[av�qf\Z�"z�\Z�YxYoga[�w^{}0�TS|^g^�t�fr(\P\m��i�n0o{i(ha[}0a[XZ�Y��a���z�z-���u\vXZf�sWf�\[n��-�YX[XZ�Y\�s%R��wiJz(^{r(a��ui�kl��ogi0r�a"h�\m��k��Ya��u\Z��r�a[�Yk���SdU%]a[R�f�r�^gk��Yi�xYf�r�\m��h�PogX[a%XZ���uxyR��w\[adXZfvr�a[��X[R��Y�>s%ogX[Rqx��u\Z��

����h�v��±�fut3�±

Page 20: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

�������%���j���%���

� � � GPM � � O�G �q@��NGPE�"=%M �P=%E �_=

�%R��3ª«XZ�Y\m��X[�Yk # f�\[�j��^go 'w�Yk��P�-S�\y�ui�n0ogi�h%aZxmR(�Y�����j��n�YaAxwf\[\Z�YxYXZo{f�i�a8XZfdh�\m�uk(�Ya8�+��a[�Ykfi�ogX[a%�YaZX[og�j��X[�|fut�R(fus R+��\[k�f\%�!�ua[}��FxYfr(\[a[��o{a!�S%xYxYf�\[k�ogi�h|X[f|i~r(���Y\Zo{x!�u^u�Y°0z-�Y\[og���wi~XZa��uXZR��_xYf\Z\[�YxYXZogfi�a�xYf�i~���Y\[h��W���Y\[}�¦0r�ogxyn0^{}�XZf

'Y�Y\Zf+� �d�Y\Z��(t�f\%�w°£����z�^g��0�u\Z��X[R��Pxwf\[\Z�YxYXZo{f�i�a��j��n�_t�f�\%X«sWfvxYf�r�\[aZ�Yadh��Yi��Y\y�uXZ�Yk��0}X[R��|a[og�vr�^��uXZogfi�k��YaZxY\[og�-�Yk�ogi ! �YxwX[ogfi��%���%R(�%z+�u\y�u���wX[�Y\Za�8� �����i�k��|�u\Z�dk��YaZxY\[og�-�YkogiPX[R+��X�a[�YxYXZogfiv�ua8s_�Y^g^«�A�%R��_og��z-f\[Xy�ui0X-i~r(�v�+�Y\Za���\[�_X[R��_^��ua[X�X[R�\Z�Y�%xYf�^{r(��i�a!�+�%R(�Y}k��Y�qfi�aZX[\m��X[�vXZR+�uXPXZR���k(o��A�Y\Z�Yi�xY���-�YX«sW�w�YipXZR����!��Y\y�uh��vxYf\Z\[�YxYXZ�Yk�h\y�uk��vh�o{���Yi�ogiX[R��FxYf�r�\[aZ���ui�kTXZR��v�!��Y\y�uh�FxYf�\[\[�wxYX[�Ykp���-SHfut_a[X[r(k��Yi0X[aPogiTXZR��FxYfr�\Za[�FxYfi0���Y\[h��YaX[fI'Y�w\[f+�

�%R��|¬+\Za[Xdf�i���oga���ij�w°~XZ\[�Y�q��x��uaZ�Pfut3�Fk�o���xYr�^gXWxwfr�\Za[�§����������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)8�9,*:2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)9�*��=7�>�?�?�!�#�$)8�#�@����������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)9�*��2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)*�8��=7�>�?�?�!�#�$)#�9�#����������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)*�8��2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)*�@"�A7�>�?�?�!�#�$)#��B@����������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)*�@"�:2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)*�@"CA7�>�?�?�!�#�$)#�#�@����������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)*�@"C:2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)*��,#A7�>�?�?�!�#�$)#�#������������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)*��,#:2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)*��,#A7�>�?�?�!�#�$)#�#�#����������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)*��,#:2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)*��,#A7�>�?�?�!�#�$)#�#�#����������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)*��,#:2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)*��,#A7�>�?�?�!�#�$)#�#�#����������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)*��,#:2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)*��,#A7�>�?�?�!�#�$)#�#�#����������������� �"!�#�$&%�%�%(')��!�#�$&*�*,+�')��!�-�#�$)%,*�+/.1032�4�5�6���2�7���!�8($)*��,#:2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$)*��,#A7�>�?�?�!�#�$)#�#�#

�%R���a[�wxYfi�k�fi���ogad�uiq�Y°0X[\[�w����x��uaZ�PfutW��i�����a[}�xwfr�\Za[�§���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$&+�+�CF2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @�+�#G7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$&@�#�+���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$ @�+�#F2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @�%�@F7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$)#���9���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$ @�%�@H2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @D��9G7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$)#�#�+���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$ @D��9F2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @D�B@F7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$)#�#�%���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$ @D�B@H2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @D�B@F7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$)#�#�#���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$ @D�B@H2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @D�B@F7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$)#�#�#���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$ @D�B@H2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @D�B@F7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$)#�#�#���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$ @D�B@H2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @D�B@F7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$)#�#�#���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$ @D�B@H2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @D�B@F7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$)#�#�#���������������D� �"!�#�$&C�#�@�')��!�#�$&#�C,9�')��!�#($&@�#�@�.D0E2�4�5�6���2�7���!"8�$ @D�B@H2�4�5�6�;�<�!�8�$ @D�B@F7�>�?�?�!�-,#�$)#�#�#

���Yi�ogXZ�Y\m��X[ogfi�a_�u\[�P��z�z+�u\Z�Yi0X[^g}va[r£��xYog�Yi0XWXZf"��\Zogi�hPX[R(��k(o��A�Y\Z�Yi�xY�Pk(fus%ivX[fS'Y�Y\[f-�s%ogX[R�ogi�XZR�\[�w�"k��wxYog�j�u^-z�^��uxw�Ya��

I �"�!CD= BPE � <>=%?8G �jM �_=%? <>= � � ��M�= � IGPM @�Kj= ��=%BP? @ ���� ��BPM�=%?"� Q��PGPM �Y@�K�C

SdaZa[r��qo{i(hd����_a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a�s%R�f|���uxyRPXy�un���R%xYfr(\[a[�wa3ogi�� a[�Y�q�Ya[XZ�Y\����ui�kv������_xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya�����uxyRTxwfr�\Za[�v�!��Y\y�uh�wa ���EJ �s�#� ���s�Fz+�uog\[a%f�t3h\m��k��Ya!�+aZfvX[R��w\[�v�u\[�F�u�-fr�Xd�]&��� ����

����h�P���fut3�±

Page 21: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

z+�uog\Za�f�tWh\y�uk��wa�XZfXy�u^«���%R��Y\Z�yt�f\Z��AXZR��va[o('Y�FfutWXZR��S� ���uXZ\[og°voga��]&�(� ����F\Zfus%a��-fi��t�f\|���uxyR�z+�uog\|fut3h\y�uk��Ya!�8�ui(k�����FxYf�^{r(��i�a!��fi(�Pt�f�\d����xyRTa[XZr�k��Yi0X����%R(�"aZo 'w�"f�t �oga%fi���xYf�^{r(��i��ui(k �]&�(� �����\Zfus%a���6ogX[R(fr�X3aZf�q�dxY^g�Y���Y\%z�\[f�h\y�u���qogi�h+�!X[R(�Y\[�Poga_i�fFs��!}vXZf"���ui�ogz�r�^���X[�-� s%o{XZR�ogi

X[R����q�Y��f�\[}�fut���xwfi0��Yi0XZo{f�i+�u^-xYf���z�r�XZ�Y\�� �dfus_�Y���Y\�� � �j�!}P�-�daZX[f�\[�YkT�ua%��aZz+�u\Za[��j��X[\[og°A��s%R��Y\Z��XZR���i�fi£�Y'Y�w\[fp�wi~XZ\[og�Ya��u\[��aZX[f\Z�Yk6ogi�^go{i(n�Ykl^{ogaZX[a�� �3�uxyR�i�f�i0�Y'w�Y\[fi0r��v�+�w\�Xy�un��Ya�r�zJ�!�v�0}0X[�Yaqb Rqt�f\|X[R��F�-f~�uXZogi�h�z-fogi0Xdi0r��v�-�Y\�� Rvt�f�\�� z+f�ogi~XZ�Y\PXZfX[R��Fi��Y°0X|i�fi0�F'Y�Y\Zf��Y^g�Y�q�Yi0X��-�ui�k7R t�f\d��iTogi�k��Y°qa[z-�YxYo�t�}0ogi�h�XZR��PxYf�^gr���i�i0r��v�-�Y\mew��3�uxyR�\[fus futE�NR+�uad��XW�qfaZX RFi�fi£�Y'Y�w\[fv�Yi0X[\Zog�Ya��(t�f�\���X[f�Xm�u^Af�t����+f�r�X-R ���0}~XZ�Yadz-�Y\\[fusP�0f�\��!�P�q�Yh~���~}0XZ�Ya3X[f�Xm��^��E��� x!�ui��-�|t��un��Yk��0}v\Z�yt��Y\Z�Yi�xYogi�hq�Y^g�Y���Yi0XZaWf�t=�Ns%o{XZRX[R��_\[fus��ui(k�xwf^gr���i|ogi�k�ogxY�Ya�a[s%ogX[xyR��Yk��uX[R0r�a�\[�Y¦0r�og\[ogi�h%�qogi�og�j�!^Y�Y°0XZ\m�%�q�Y��f�\[}0���%R����YxwX[f\ �Fx���i�i�fX��+� ­ t��un��Yk8� ®��ui�k��vr�aZX�Xm�un��vr�z R��0}~XZ�YaFz+�Y\F\[fusP��X[og�q�Ya��]&��� ����\[fus%a!�0t�f�\���i�fXZR��Y\d�q�Yh~���0}~XZ�%fut3���w��f\Z}~�

�%R��P\Z���u^��q�Y��f�\[}Fz�\[f���^g�Y� ogadX[R-�uX4����� x��ui�i(fX��+��t��un��Yk8�A�ui�k��vr�aZX%Xm��n�Pr�zRT�0}0X[�YaFz+�w\"�Yi0XZ\[}�X[og�q�Ya#$�� ������ ����F�Yi0X[\Zog�Ya���f�\��`R]RT���Yh0�u�0}0X[�Ya!���%R-�uXPogaP�+��\[�Y^g}s%ogX[R�ogiFX[R��|\m�ui(h�%futA���wk�ogr��v�«a[o('Y�Yk�xYr(\[\[�wi~X%xwf��z(r�X[�Y\Za���]_f�qz�r�X[ogi�h-�����6Xm��n�Ya3f�iX[R���f\[k(�Y\%fut�������� �]��� J��]���]� � ���=J �s�� � �vr�^gXZo{z(^{ogx���X[ogfi(a��A]_f�qz�r�X[ogi�h � � � Xm��n�Yafi�^g}����+f�r�XI����J@�s�����vr�^gX[ogz�^gogx��uXZo{f�i�a�� ! f�^{�0ogi�hvXZR��v^go{i(���u\�a[}0aZX[�Y�����E���2� �����Xm��n�Ya|fi�XZR��Pf�\[k��Y\%f�t������]�� -� ���� J2�o� ��� fz-�Y\y�uX[ogf�i�a��

�%R0r�a���XZR���X[og���FX[f�a[f�^g���XZR���aZ}0a[X[�w� oga"���+f�r�X �s� � �f�z+�w\m�uXZogfi�a!��s%R�ogxmRlXm��n�Ya&�(� �����aZ�YxYf�i�k�a�f\P� R"R�f�r�\[a%XZfv\[r�i�f�i �F����F���Yh0�uR��w\[X/'|xYf�qz�r�XZ�Y\��

ª�tWXZR��vz+f�z�r�^��uXZogfiTf�t�XZR��"aZxyR�f0f^3oga��vr�xyRT^��u\Zh�Y\!�AX[R��vaZX[f�\m�uh��v\[�Y¦0r�og\Z�Y���Yi0X|t�f�\X[R��%xwf��z(r�Xm��X[ogfi�bcfiFX[R��%f�\[k��w\3fut+XZR��%a[¦0r+��\[�%f�t�XZR��Wi0r��v�-�Y\�fut-a[X[r(k��Yi0X[aye3�-�YxYf����Yar�i�\Z���uaZfi+����^g}�^��u\Zh��

� � K�= � ��K�= � ��Q�=%? BPE � � M�B ��=%?�G�I �F@� ��=%EF@�? ��E @�Kj=�vCDBPQ!Q �vBPC���Q!= L6G � ��Q�B�@ ��G�E

! Xm��\[a|o{i(k�ogx��uXZ�dX[R(�����Y¤yf�\3fut����uxyR�a[XZr�k��Yi0X�� ­ ]%� ! ®��q���ui�a%]_f�qz�r�XZ�Y\ ! xYog�Yi�xY��A��i�k­ ��R~}0ay��k0®P������i�a%��R0}~aZogx��u^���k�r�x���X[ogfi��

����h�P���|fut3�±

Page 22: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

! XZr�k��Yi0X ]_f�r�\[aZ�YaS ��R~}0ay��k7R+�$(� �|���u^gX[R R-� �(��� �doga[XZf\Z} $�� �(� �T��X[RT���$U ��R~}0ay��k7R+�$(� �|���u^gX[R7$(� $(���u��a[}0xyR�f�^{f�h}��(� �(��]%� ! ��� �] ���uX[R R-� �(���u��R0}0a[ogxYa4R-�$��0]%� ! R+� ������R(o{^gf�a[fz(R~}�$(� �� � �T�uXZR R+� ���0��R0}0a[ogxYa $(� ���0]%� ! R+� ����V(\[�Yi(xmR7$(� �� � �T�uXZR R+�$��0��R0}0a[ogxYa4R-� ���0��i�h^goga[R $��$�� �|oga[X[f�\[} $�� �V ��R~}0aZo{xwa $�� �(���u]%� ! R+� ��� V�\Z�Yi�xyR $(� �(� �|oga[X[f�\[} $�� �� ���uX[R R-� �(���u]%� ! R+�$�� �|���u^gXZR�R+� �(����i�h^goga[R $�� �� ]%� ! $(� ����� ��R~}0aZo{xwa-R+� ���0��R0}0am��k7R-� ���0��a[}0xyR�f^gf�h} $(� �ª ��i�h^goga[R R+� �(� V(\[�Yi(xmR R-� $(��]%� ! $�� ����� ��R�og^{f�a[f�z�R0}IR+�$ ��i�h^goga[R7$�� �(���mV�\Z�Yi�xyR R+� ��� ��r(a[ogx �doga[XZf\[} R+� ��� �T��X[RT��� �� �u��i�h�^{ogaZR�R+�$(����R�og^gfa[f�z�R0}IR+� ���0��aZ}~xyR�f�^gfh}IR-� ��� ��r�aZogx �|oga[X[f�\[} R+�$� ��i�h^goga[R7$�� �(��� �doga[XZf\[} R+� ���0��aZ}~xyR�f�^gfh}IR-� ��� ��r�aZogx �|oga[X[f�\[} R+� �� � r�a[ogx �doga[XZf\Z}�R+�$(����a[}0xyR�f^gf�h}IR+�$(���mV�\Z�Yi�xyR7R+�$(�~��R0}0am��k7R+� �# � ��r�aZo{x �|o{aZX[f�\[}�R-� ���0��a[}0xyR�f^gf�h}�R-� ��� V�\Z�Yi�xyR7R+� �(� �|���u^gX[R R-� �� ��R~}0aZo{xwa4R+� �(�~��i(h^goga[R7$��$���� ���uX[R R+� ������R�og^{f�a[f�z�R0}IR+� �� ��R~}0aZo{xwa $�� �(���u��i�h^goga[R $�� ��� ���uX[R $��$�����R�og^{f�a[f�z�R0}IR+� �� ��R~}0ay��k7R+� �(� �|���u^gX[R R-� $(� � r�a[ogx��|o{aZX[f�\[}�R-�$���� ��aZ}~xyR�f�^gfh}IR-�$� ��R~}0ay��k7R+� �(� �|���u^gX[R R-� �(� � r�a[ogx��|o{aZX[f�\[}�R-� ����� ]%� ! R+� �

�%R�oga_o{a%XZR��Pay�u���|Xm����^g��0fi�^g}vs%ogX[R(fr�X%�u^g^gfus%ogi�h �H��i�kq�3h\m��k��Ya!�! XZr�k��Yi0X ]_f�r�\[aZ�Ya

S ��R~}0ay��k7R+� �(� �|���u^gX[R R-� �(��� �doga[XZf\Z} $�� �(� �T��X[RT��� �U ��R~}0ay��k7R+� �(� �|���u^gX[R7$(� �(���u��a[}0xyR�f�^{f�h}��(� �(��]%� ! ��� �] ���uX[R R-� �(���u��R0}0a[ogxYa4R-� ���0]%� ! R+� ������R(o{^gf�a[fz(R~}IR-� �� � �T�uXZR R+� ���0��R0}0a[ogxYa4R-� ���0]%� ! R+� ����V(\[�Yi(xmR7$(� �� � �T�uXZR R+� ���0��R0}0a[ogxYa4R-� ���0��i�h^goga[R $�� ��� �|oga[X[f�\[} R+� �V ��R~}0aZo{xwa4R+� �(���u]%� ! R+� ��� V�\Z�Yi�xyR7R-� �(� �|oga[X[f�\[} $�� �� ���uX[R R-� �(���u]%� ! R+� ��� �|���u^gXZR�R+� �(����i�h^goga[R R+� �� ]%� ! $(� ����� ��R~}0aZo{xwa-R+� ���0��R0}0am��k7R-� ���0��a[}0xyR�f^gf�h} $(� �ª ��i�h^goga[R R+� �(� V(\[�Yi(xmR R-� �(��]%� ! R+� ����� ��R�og^{f�a[f�z�R0}IR+� � ��i�h^goga[R R+� �(���mV�\Z�Yi�xyR R+� ��� ��r(a[ogx �doga[XZf\[} R+� ��� �T��X[R7$�� �� �u��i�h�^{ogaZR�R+� �(����R�og^gfa[f�z�R0}IR+� ���0��aZ}~xyR�f�^gfh}IR-� ��� ��r�aZogx �|oga[X[f�\[} R+� �� ��i�h^goga[R R+� �(��� �doga[XZf\[} R+� ���0��aZ}~xyR�f�^gfh}IR-� ��� ��r�aZogx �|oga[X[f�\[} R+� �� � r�a[ogx �doga[XZf\Z}�R+� �(����a[}0xyR�f^gf�h}IR+� �(���mV�\Z�Yi�xyR7R+� �(�~��R0}0am��k7R+� �# � ��r�aZo{x �|o{aZX[f�\[}�R-� ���0��a[}0xyR�f^gf�h}�R-� ��� V�\Z�Yi�xyR7R+� �(� �|���u^gX[R R-� �� ��R~}0aZo{xwa4R+� �(�~��i(h^goga[R7$�� ����� ���uX[R R+� ������R�og^{f�a[f�z�R0}IR+� �� ��R~}0aZo{xwa $�� �(���u��i�h^goga[R R+� ��� ���uX[R $�� ������R�og^{f�a[f�z�R0}IR+� �� ��R~}0ay��k7R+� �(� �|���u^gX[R R-� �(� � r�a[ogx��|o{aZX[f�\[}�R-� ����� ��aZ}~xyR�f�^gfh}IR-� �� ��R~}0ay��k7R+� �(� �|���u^gX[R R-� �(� � r�a[ogx��|o{aZX[f�\[}�R-� ����� ]%� ! R+� �

����h�P���fut3�±

Page 23: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

� � Kj= <>BPE � ��E �P?NG�IJ@�K�=��vBPC���Q�=>L6G � ��Q!B�@�!GPE

1 ,/. ��G �i:��;D4?/G Q 57: �� C�G;D � ?/G ���H�6�C�D;3 �� ���$� � � � +�! �&% ! +����-������� � ������� ����� �-���/��������� ����������!#�$�&%��

�������������������� "!�#�$�%'&�(�)+*�������������-,.���� "!�#�$�%'&�(�)+*�������������0/1���� "!�#�$�%3234�5+*�������������768���� "!�#�$�%')�9�:+*�������������0;1���� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*�������������0<1���� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*��������������=����� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*��������������>����� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*�������������-?.���� "!�#�:@%'AB2C5+*�������������-D.���� "!�#�:@%'9�:�:+*��������������E����� "!�#�:@%'9�:�:+*�������������0F1���� "!�#�:@%'4�4�5+*��������������G����� "!�#�:@%'(�9�:+*�������������-H.���� "!�#�:@%'(�9�:+*�������������0I1���� "!�#�:@%'(�)�)+*�������������-J.���� "!�#�:@%'(�)�)+*�������������-K.���� "!�#�:@%L$M2C5+*�������������-N.���� "!�#�&@%'AB2C5+*

� ���$� ) � � +�! �&% !.+O�QP �����&��! �SR +�!T� �����VU %��6� ���&�/� ���W�X�,����� ������� ���������!#�$�&%��

�������������0/1���� "!�#�)@%'9�:�5+*�������������768���� "!�#�)@%'9�)�A+*�������������������� "!�#�)@%'(�A�4+*�������������-,.���� "!�#�)@%'(�&Y2�*��������������>����� "!�#�)@%':�9�(+*��������������=����� "!�#�)@%'&�&Y2�*�������������-D.���� "!�#�)@%'&B2�2�*�������������-?.���� "!�#�)@%323(�5+*�������������0<1���� "!�#+ZT)@%[)�)�4+*��������������E����� "!�#+ZT)@%[)�&�A+*�������������0;1���� "!�#+ZT)@%\2CA�5+*�������������0F1���� "!�#+ZT)@%[&�4�&+*�������������-K.���� "!�#+ZT)@%[&�5�&+*�������������-H.���� "!�#+ZT)@%[&�9Y2�*�������������0I1���� "!�#+ZT)@%]$�$�5+*��������������G����� "!�#+ZT)@%]$�AY2�*�������������-J.���� "!�#+ZT)@%[(�A�$Y*�������������-N.���� "!�#+Z�2M%\2C(�A+*

����h�P��$�fut3�±

Page 24: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

� ���$��� � % !#�� ����% ��� R"+�!T� ����� U %���� ���-��� ����� �-�����������0� ������� �$!#�$�&%��

�������������0/1���� "!�#�$�%'&B2C9+*�������������768���� "!�#�$�%3234�A+*�������������-,.���� "!�#�$�%')�A�:+*��������������=����� "!�#�$�%')�5�4+*��������������>����� "!�#�$�%')�5Y2�*�������������-?.���� "!�#�$�%')�(�9+*�������������-D.���� "!�#�$�%') $�4+*�������������������� "!�#�$�%')�&Y2�*��������������E����� "!�#�:@%'A�(�(+*�������������0<1���� "!�#�:@%'A�)�$Y*�������������0;1���� "!�#�:@%'5�4�$Y*�������������0F1���� "!�#�:@%'5�:�5+*�������������-H.���� "!�#�:@%'4�9�A+*��������������G����� "!�#�:@%'4�(�9+*�������������-J.���� "!�#�:@%'4�&�&+*�������������0I1���� "!�#�:@%L$")�9+*�������������-K.���� "!�#�:@%':�(�4+*�������������-N.���� "!�#�&@%'5�(�(+*

� ���$��� � % �$� �CP���-��!#%�� �/� ���W�X�,����������� � ���&������!#�$�&%��

�������������-D.���� "!�#�&@%':�&�:+*�������������768���� "!�#�&@%'&�4�$Y*��������������>����� "!�#�&@%'& $�)+*��������������=����� "!�#�&@%'&�:�4+*��������������E����� "!�#�&@%3239�)+*�������������0/1���� "!�#�&@%323:�5+*�������������-,.���� "!�#�&@%') $�5+*�������������������� "!�#�&@%')�&�A+*�������������-H.���� "!�#�&@%')�)�A+*�������������0;1���� "!�#Y2M%'A�AY2�*�������������-J.���� "!�#Y2M%'A $�$Y*�������������0F1���� "!�#Y2M%'A�:�:+*�������������-?.���� "!�#Y2M%'A�&�$Y*�������������0<1���� "!�#Y2M%'9�5�&+*��������������G����� "!�#Y2M%'5 $�)+*�������������0I1���� "!�#Y2M%'4�)�&+*�������������-K.���� "!�#Y2M%L$":�9+*�������������-N.���� "!�#�)@%'9�A�)+*I�I #7ZT)@%'4�&�&

����h�P�mRFfut3�±

Page 25: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

1 ,�� � � ?/G Q��S3iA A�3=6 HJ6�CED43 ��3@G4:��� �*) � � � � +�! �&% ! +����-������� � ������� ������� �-+$��% ��% % ! �$!#�$�&%�� +$�-� �

�������������0;1���� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*�������������������� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*��������������=����� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*�������������0<1���� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*�������������-,.���� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*��������������>����� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*�������������0/1���� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*�������������768���� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*�������������-?.���� "!�#�$�%')�)�)+*��������������E����� "!�#�:@%'5�(�)+*��������������G����� "!�#�:@%'5�(�)+*�������������-H.���� "!�#�:@%'5�(�)+*�������������-D.���� "!�#�:@%'5�(�)+*�������������0F1���� "!�#�:@%'5�(�)+*�������������0I1���� "!�#�:@%'(�)�)+*�������������-J.���� "!�#�:@%'(�)�)+*�������������-K.���� "!�#�:@%'&�(�)+*�������������-N.���� "!�#�&@%'5�(�)+*

� �*) � ) � � +$! �&% ! +O��P �����&��! �.R +�!T� ����� U %�� � ��� �/� ���W���.�-+���% ��% % !��!#�$�&%��

��������������>����� "!�#�)@%'(�&�9+*�������������-?.���� "!�#�)@%L$"9�9+*��������������=����� "!�#�)@%':�9�4+*�������������768���� "!�#�)@%':�4�:+*�������������0<1���� "!�#�)@%': $�)+*�������������0/1���� "!�#�)@%'&�5Y2�*�������������-,.���� "!�#�)@%'&�:�9+*�������������������� "!�#�)@%'&�:�9+*�������������0;1���� "!�#�)@%'&�&�9+*�������������-H.���� "!�#�)@%323)�4+*��������������G����� "!�#�)@%')�5�&+*�������������-D.���� "!�#�)@%')�5Y2�*�������������0F1���� "!�#+ZT)@%\2C&�$Y*��������������E����� "!�#+ZT)@%\2\$�(+*�������������0I1���� "!�#+ZT)@%[&�A�5+*�������������-J.���� "!�#+ZT)@%[(�A�5+*�������������-K.���� "!�#+ZT)@%[4Y2�2�*�������������-N.���� "!�#+Z�2M%[(�(�4+*

����h�P��&�fut3�±

Page 26: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

� �*) ��� � % !#�� ����% ��� R"+�!T� ����� U %���� ���-��� ����� � �-+$��% ��% % ! �$!#����%��

�������������-?.���� "!�#�$�%323&�:+*��������������>����� "!�#�$�%')�5�$Y*�������������768���� "!�#�$�%')�4�$Y*��������������=����� "!�#�$�%')�(Y2�*�������������0/1���� "!�#�$�%')�:�$Y*�������������0<1���� "!�#�:@%'A�4�:+*�������������-D.���� "!�#�:@%'AB2C4+*�������������-,.���� "!�#�:@%'9�A�)+*��������������G����� "!�#�:@%'9�5Y2�*�������������0F1���� "!�#�:@%'9 $�:+*�������������-H.���� "!�#�:@%'9�:�4+*��������������E����� "!�#�:@%'9�&�5+*�������������������� "!�#�:@%'9�)�(+*�������������0;1���� "!�#�:@%'5�A�4+*�������������-J.���� "!�#�:@%'(�5�5+*�������������0I1���� "!�#�:@%':�9�A+*�������������-K.���� "!�#�:@%3239�$Y*�������������-N.���� "!�#�&@%'(�A�:+*

� �*) ��� � % �$� �CP���-��!#%�� �/� ���W� �.�-+���% ��% % ! �$!#�$�&%��

��������������>����� "!�#�&@%'& $�A+*�������������768���� "!�#�&@%323A�&+*�������������-D.���� "!�#�&@%3235�&+*��������������=����� "!�#�&@%3235�)+*�������������-H.���� "!�#�&@%32 $�:+*��������������E����� "!�#�&@%') $�&+*�������������-?.���� "!�#�&@%')�:�(+*�������������0F1���� "!�#�&@%')�:�&+*�������������0;1���� "!�#�&@%')B2C4+*�������������0/1���� "!�#Y2M%'A�9�$Y*��������������G����� "!�#Y2M%'A $�9+*�������������0<1���� "!�#Y2M%'A�)�)+*�������������-,.���� "!�#Y2M%'9�9�:+*�������������-J.���� "!�#Y2M%'9�5Y2�*�������������������� "!�#Y2M%'9 $�4+*�������������0I1���� "!�#Y2M%'(�5�9+*�������������-K.���� "!�#Y2M%'&�4�$Y*�������������-N.���� "!�#Y2M%'( $�:+*I�I #7ZT)@%'(�(�4

����h�P��fut3�±

Page 27: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

� �l=%?A@ � B�@�B IGPM @�K�=V<�BPE � �!E � � ��K�=%CD=%?

�%R��P�-�Ya[X|s��!}qX[fvXZ�Ya[X|X[R��P\y�ui�n0ogi�hFa[xyR��Y�q�Yadoga%XZf��uz�z�^g}vXZR��Y� X[f���i��Y°0o{aZX[ogi�hvz-fz0�r�^��uXZo{f�i�f�tda[XZr�k��Yi0X[a!� ! ogi�xw��X[R-�uXPogi0t�f�\[���uX[ogf�ijogaPi(fXPh�o{���Yi8��X[R����u^gX[�w\[i+��X[og��vogaPXZfogi~���Yi0X%a[f����d\Z���uaZfi+����^g��k+�uXy�v�ui�kqa[�Y�Ps%R-�uX%X[R(�P\m��i�n0o{i(h"aZxmR(�Y���Ya%k(fvs%o{XZR�ogX��

� ,/. � ?/< �4:PC=A�?PG-Q � 8��;6 � 3 �����s���i~X_X[fvXy�un���XZR��|t�f^g^gfus%ogi�hPXZR�ogi�ha_ogi~XZfvxYfi(a[ogk��Y\y�uX[ogf�i�s%R��Yi�xY\[����X[ogi�hvxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya�§

¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XZaPX[�wi�k�X[f�z�ogxyn���f\Z�PxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya"ogi���\[����aPX[R(�Y}��u\Z�"xwf�vt�f\[Xy�u��^g�Pogi8��ª«iz-�u\[XZogxYr�^��u\!�0X[R��Y}T��\[��\[�Y¦0r�og\Z�YkTX[fFa[�w^{�wxYX�xYfr�\Za[�Ya|ogijXZR��Yog\%�j�w¤yf\Za��¨ ]_f�r�\[aZ�Yav��u\Z}�ogi�aZr��¤y�YxYXv���uXZX[�Y\!� ! f�q�"\Z�Y¦0r�og\[�T��^gfXPf�td�j��X[R��ui�k�aZxYog�Yi0�XZo�¬+xv�Y°0z+�w\[og�Yi�xY���Ws%R(o{^g�vf�X[R��Y\ZaPt�f~xwr�aP��f�\[�Ffi�R0r����ui�i+�uXZr�\[���R(o{aZX[f�\[}0����i�k^gogX[�w\m�uXZr�\[���

¨ ]_f�r�\[aZ�Ya3���\[}PogiPk�o���xYr(^{X«}0� �|�Y\[���s_����\[�_i�fX�xYf�i�a[ogk��Y\Zogi�h�X[R��%k�o���xYr(^{X«}�f�t+X[R�����uXZ�Y\[o��u^«�0��r(Xd\m��X[R��w\�R(fusNk�o���xYr�^gX%ogXdogadXZfvh�YXP�vh�f0f~k�h�\m�uk(�PogiTX[R��FxYf�r�\[aZ��! X[r�k��wi~XZadh��Yi��Y\y�u^g^g}�z�\Z�yt��Y\|xYfr�\Za[�Ya|s%R��Y\Z�PX[R��w}j�w°~z-�YxYX|X[fvh��YX%�+�wX[X[�w\dh\y�uk��wa��

¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XZa���\[�P�u��^g��X[fv�wa[X[og���uX[�|X[R��wo{\%h�\m��k���o{iT��xYfr(\[a[��t��uog\[^g}���xYxYr�\y�uX[�w^{}0��3��xmRla[og�vr�^��uXZ�Yk�xYfr�\Za[���vXZR��Y\Z�yt�f\Z��R+�uaFX[R�\Z�Y����X[X[\Zog��r�X[�wa����%R�� ¬+\[aZXvX«sWf��u\[�

t�\m��xYX[ogf�i�a������P��i�k����(�-s%R�ogxmR�\[�Yz�\Z�Ya[�wi~XFR�fus �vr�xyR�X[R��FxYfr(\[a[�F�Y�qz�R+�uaZo('Y�Ya�X[R���a[xYo���Yi�xY�waj�ui(k�X[R���R0r��j��i�ogX[og�Ya!�A\[�YaZz+�wxYX[og��w^{}0� ! ogi�xw��X[R(�Ya[����\[� t�\m��xYX[ogfi(a"f�tdX[R��qX[fXy�u^�y�Af\[X|\[�Y¦0r�og\Z�Yk�t�f�\��FxYf�r�\[aZ��-sW��R+�!����� � "� � � ���ª«i�X[R���a[og�vr�^��uXZo{f�i8�� � ogaWk��wX[�Y\¯���ogi��Yk��~}�h��Yi��Y\y�uX[ogi�h�r�i(o�t�f\[�q^g}vk�oga[X[\Zog��r�X[�wk�\y�ui�k�f�� i0r��v�+�w\[ad�-�YX«s_�Y�Yip���ui(kp���ui�k�� � � �%��� � �

�%R���X[R(o{\Zk��uXZX[\Zo{�(r�X[���� doga%XZR�� ­ ���uaZo{i(�Ya[a¯®"fut3X[R(�PxYfr(\[a[���+XZR+�uX|oga���R(fus ����a[}�ogX%ogaX[fPh��YXW��h�f0f~kFh\y�uk������%R�oga�i0r��v�-�Y\�\[�wz�\[�YaZ�Yi0X[a|X[R��%XZ�Yi�k��Yi(xY}�f�t�XZR��%X[����xyR��Y\_X[fPh�o{���R�oghR��w\�f�\8^gfus_�Y\�h\m��k��Ya!�8ª«iFX[R��_a[og�vr�^���X[ogfi8���� �oga8k��YXZ�Y\[�qogi��YkF�~}�Xy�un0ogi�h�� r�i�o�t�f\Z��^g}k�oga[XZ\[og��r�XZ�Yk�\y�ui�k�f��Hi0r��v�-�Y\8�-�YX«s_�Y�Yi�� �������i�k�����(��ogi�k(o{x!�uX[ogi�h�XZR+�uX�X[�!�uxyR��Y\ZaW���!}a[n��YspXZR��Yog\8h�\m�uk(�Ya��~}�r�z�X[fdR-�u^�t+�%^g�YX[XZ�Y\�h\y�uk��3r(zPf\�k�fus%i8� Spr�i�o�t�f�\[� k�oga[XZ\[og��r�XZo{f�ioga%r�a[�Yk�\m�uXZR��Y\%XZR+�uiT��i�f\Z�j�u^-k�oga[XZ\[og��r�XZogfi�XZfv�j��n�%X[R(��xwfr�\Za[�Ya���u\Z}vogi�k�o���xYr�^gX«}fu��Y\%XZR��P�Yi0XZo{\Z�YX«}�f�t��FaZ�j�u^g^-\m��i�h��

� ,�� � ?/< �4:PC=A�?PG-Q � A �;D43=G A ����Ws%�ui0X�X[f�Xm��n�_X[R��¢t�f^g^gfus%ogi�h%X[R(o{i(ha8ogi0X[f�xYf�i�a[ogk��w\m�uXZogfiFs%R��YiFxY\[����X[ogi�h�a[og�vr�^���X[�Yka[XZr�k��Yi0X[a!§

¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XZa%R+�!��|��u\Z}~ogi�h�a[X[\Z�Yi�h�X[R�a��ui�kqsW����n0i��Ya[aZ�Ya��_ª«iqz+�u\ZX[ogxYr�^��u\!�0a[f����%a[XZr0�k(�Yi0X[a_R+�!��_k�o����w\[�Yi0XW����og^{ogX«}�^g�Y��w^{a¢o{iFX[R(�%a[xYog�Yi�xw�Ya���i�kvR0r��j��i�ogX[og�Ya!� ! X[r�k��wi~XZaz(\[�yt��w\dxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya�s%o{XZR�ogi�XZR��Yog\%xYf� t�f\ZX�'Yf�i��Ya��¨ ! X[r�k��wi~XZadz�\Z�yt��Y\|h�YXZX[ogi�hvR�ogh�R��Y\%h\y�uk��wa��

����h�P� ��fut3�±

Page 28: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

�3��xmR�a[og�vr�^���X[�Ykqa[X[r(k��Yi0X �FR+��a�X«s_fj��X[XZ\[og��r�XZ�Ya�� � �F�ui�k � �-��UWf�X[R�futWXZR��YaZ���u\[�i0r��v�+�w\[a8\Z�Yz�\Z�Ya[�Yi0XZo{i(hPh\y�uk��Ya�s%R�ogxyRPogi�k�ogx��uXZ�3X[R(�3a[XZr�k��Yi0X�� a3�u�(o{^gogX[og�YaAogiPXZR��3aZxYog�Yi�xY�Ya�ui�k�R0r����ui�ogX[og�Ya!�u\[�wa[z-�YxYX[og���Y^g}~�¢UWf�X[R�\m��i�h�|t�\Zf� �FX[f ������� �0s%R�ogxmRqoga%�YogX[R��Y\-� ���f\�����k��Yz-�Yi�k�ogi�hqfi�XZR��Ph�\m�uk(o{i(h"aZx��u^g��

��og��wij�vxwfr�\Za[���P��i�kT�Fa[XZr�k��Yi0X ���-X[R���h\m��k���t�f�\%X[R+��X%a[XZr�k��Yi0X�ogijXZR+�uX%xwfr�\Za[�oga%hog��Yiq�0}

� ��� � �&� �����E" � � ���-"� � � ����� � bZ��eª«i6XZR��Ta[og�vr�^���X[ogfi8� � ���ui�k � �J��\[��k��YXZ�Y\[�qo{i(�Yk6�0}pXy�un0ogi�h�\m��i�k�f�Di0r��v�-�Y\Za

t�\[f�� �qi�f�\[�j��^�k�oga[X[\Zog��r�X[ogf�iTs%ogX[R����!�ui $(� &q�ui�k�aZXm��i�k+�u\Zk�k(�Y�0o`��X[ogfi��� �(�As%ogX[R���j��°~og�vr��Nf�t � ����� �� ,�� H�3[G43=6�C=A�?PG-Q C �-?/< �4:/C[A�3=D 5�8 � �4:/C[A�?/8 G�%R��%a[og�vr�^���X[�YkPz-fz(r�^��uX[ogf�i"oga�xY\[�!�uX[�wk��0}P¬-\[a[X¢h�Yi��w\m�uXZogi�h"�|i0r��v�+�w\�f�t�xwfr�\Za[�Yad��i�k�Pi0r��v�-�Y\_fut�a[X[r(k��Yi0X[a!�3S xYfr�\Za[�P^gf0�ukvoga%a[�Y^g�YxwX[�Yk�t�f\_���uxyR�a[XZr�k��Yi0X3���0}v\[�wz+����X[ogi�hX[R���t�f^g^gfus%ogi�h+§=V�og\[aZX��-�FxYfr�\Za[� �|o{a%aZ�Y^g�YxYXZ�Yk ��X%\m��i�k�f���8ª�t3XZR��Pa[XZr�k��Yi0X|o{a%s_����n�ogia[xYog�Yi(xY��b � ��� ��� ��e3�ui(k�X[R(�dxYf�r�\[aZ��oga3R(���!�0}vo{ivaZxYog�Yi�xY�vb �����J��� �e�XZR��Yi�XZR��dxwfr�\Za[�oga"\Z��¤y�YxYXZ�Yk8� ! og�qo{^���\[^�}0�-o�tdX[R���a[XZr�k��Yi0XvogaFsW����n�ogipR0r��j��i�ogX[og�YaP�ui(kpX[R(��xYf�r�\[aZ�TogaR����!�0}�ogijR0r����ui�ogXZo{�wa��0X[R(�PxYfr(\[a[�Fogad\Z��¤y�YxYXZ�Yk8�|ª�t3X[R��PaZX[r�k(�Yi0X��wa[X[og���uX[�wadR�oga%f\|R��Y\fu��Y\y�u^g^�h\y�uk��v�uX�^g�Ya[a�XZR+�ui����&��-XZR��"xwfr�\Za[��oga|\[��¤y�wxYX[�Yk��v�%R�oga�z�\[f0xY�YaZa"f�tWa[�w^{�wxYX[ogfi�ui�k�\[��¤y�wxYX[ogfi�ogad\Z�Yz+�!�uX[�wk�r�i0X[og^3�vxYf�r�\[aZ�"ogadi(fXd\Z��¤y�YxwX[�Yk8����r�XP��Xd��f�a[X%XZ�Yi�XZog���Ya!��ui�k�X[R��Yi�X[R(�"^��uaZXdxYf�r�\[aZ�vogadXm��n�Yi�i�f����uX[XZ�Y\ds%R-�uX�� �%R��"aZ�Y^g�YxYXZ�Yk�xYfr(\[a[�voga|X[R��Yi�uk�k(�YkTX[fFX[R(�Pa[XZr�k��Yi0X�� a%aZxmR(�Yk�r�^g�v�ui�kqX[R��Ph�\m��k���xYf�qz�r�X[�wkj�ua%aZXm��X[�YkTogi���¦0r+�uXZo{f�i��0\Zfr�i�k(�YkTX[fvXZR���i�����\[�YaZXdz-fa[aZog��^g�Ph\y�uk���

�%R��3\Z��¤y�YxwX[ogfiFz�\[f0xY�wa[aW��^{^gfus%a-t�f�\8XZR��WaZX[r�k(�Yi0X[a���z�\[�yt��Y\[�Yi(xY�Ya_o{i�aZ�Y^g�YxYX[ogi�h�xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya���ui�klX[R��qt���xYXFX[R+��X ��XP��f�a[XPXZ�Yi�xYfr�\Za[�Yavx!�uip�-��\[��¤¥�YxYX[�wk �u^g^gfus%a|t�f\Fk�oga[XZ\[og��r�XZo{f�i\[�Y¦0r�og\Z�Y���Yi0XZa��

� ,d+ K G;CE: �� ?�� 8 � A�143 � ?/< �4:PC=A�3[D 1JC[A�C�%R��_a[og�vr�^��uXZo{f�iWz(\[fh�\m��� s%�ua�r�a[�YkFX[f%xw\[����X[��������_a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a3��i�k"����_xYfr(\[a[�wa��us%R��w\[�X[R���xYfr�\Za[�F^gf~�uk�s%�ua%aZo{°A�_�%R0r�a��(X[R��w\[�FsW�Y\Z� ��\[f�r�i�k �o�]���J ���]����� � �]�Fz+�Yf�z�^g�Pogi���uxyRlxYfr�\Za[��_s%R�ogxyR�oga"\Z���uaZfi+����^g��T��s_fT\[r(i�a"s_�Y\Z�j���uk����8f�i���s%ogX[R�f�i�^g}�s%R(f^g�h\y�uk��Ya!�+��i�k�fi���s%ogX[R7"H��i�k7�Nh�\m�uk(�Yad�u^g^gfusW�wk8�����x��ui�k��YX[�w\[��ogi�����^gfusW�w\��-fr�i�k t�f\vXZR�� �!���Y\m��h�����-S��uX�S|U�]V]_f^g^g�Yh���

! r�z�z-faZ��sW�%R+�!��� �>a[XZr�k��Yi0X[a!������xyR�fut8s%R(o{xyRvXy�un�wa�� xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya�� �d�wi�fXZ�%�~} ����� X[R��h\y�uk��|fut8a[XZr�k��Yi0X���ogivX[R+��X3a[XZr�k��Yi0X!� a��uX[RqxYfr(\[a[���3�%R��YiqX[R����!��Y\y�uh��%h\m��k��%t�f\3XZR+�uX�Yi0X[og\[��xY^��ua[a%oga%h�o{���Yi��0} �

���� ��! �"� � ������#� b��e

�%R��"�!���Y\m��h�P�P�-S o{a%h�og��Yiq�~}���$� �

�&%')(+*�,.- '

� ba$e

����h�P� ��fut3�±

Page 29: mk Tz-f ogi0X[a ogaTua - Cornell Universitypi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM1998paper.pdf · %R PqYX[R f0k a[R(f r ^gk \[Ys%u\ZkTa[XZr k Yi0XZa h \ZuXZY\ f r(i~X¢t f \%a[xYf

�����������

�%R��_X«sWf��u\[�¢�Y¦0r+�u^«�!a[f�o�t�X[R��%�!��Y\y�uh��3h\y�uk��W��X8S|U�]l]_f^g^g�Yh��oga�S%�Y��XZR��YiFX[R��%�!��w\m�uh���P�-S a[R�f�r�^gk��-��i(fv��f\Z�%X[R+��i $(� &(�8S|i0}��P�-S ^g�YaZa%X[R+��i7$��&�s_fr�^gk��-��\[f�r�i�k��Yk�XZf�vU�� f\%^g�Ya[a!�A�ui�kTXZR�faZ�Ph\Z���uXZ�Y\dXZR+�ui2$��&Ps_fr(^{k��-�P\[f�r�i�k��wkTX[fqS%�Wf�\d�-�YX[XZ�Y\��%ª«iX[R��v�-fXZR�k+�uXy�qa[�YXZa���X[R(�v���Yk�o���i��P�-S s���a#$��&��As%R(o{xyR�ogaPogi ��h\[�w�Y���Yi0X�s%ogX[R�X[R��ogi0t�f\Z�j��X[ogfiFhog��wi ���+f�r�X_SdU%]N]_f^g^g�Yh��

� , � A�6�3=G Q�A�1� CEG4D���3=CEO-G43 � � 3 � 8 � A�143 � ?P< �;:/C[A�?/8�G�%R���xwf��z(r�Xm��X[ogfi�\[r�i(av��Y\Z}�¦~r(o{xyn0^g}���o{ip�jt��Ys¡�qo{i0r�XZ�Ya�� �w��YilX[R�f�r�hR�ogXFs���as%\[ogX[XZ�Yipogi��qR�oghR0�«^g�Y��Y^¢o{i0XZ�Y\[z�\Z�YX[�wkp^��ui�h�r+�uh��jb���}0X[R�f�i+eY�qª«X�ogaP��Y\Z}T�-�Y°0o{�(^{������i�kx��ui��-�"�uk�¤¥r�a[XZ�Yk�XZfv\[�y�-�YxYXPk�o��A�Y\[�wi~X�h�\m�uk(�Pk�oga[XZ\[og��r�XZo{f�i�a���ad���!}v�+��t�fr�i�k�o{i�k�o�t��t��Y\Z�Yi0XdxYf�^{^g�Yh��Ya���ª«X%Xy�un��Ya%ogi~XZf"�uxwxYfr�i0X%���\[o��uXZo{f�ivogi�a[XZr�k��Yi0X|o{i0XZ�Y\[�YaZX���i�k�ogi�xwfr�\Za[��j��X[�Y\Zo`��^«��dfus_�Y���Y\�����f�a[X3f�t8X[R��|xYfr�\Za[�Ya|X[r�\Zi�f�r�XWXZR��d\Zfr�h�R�^g}"ay�u�q�%a[o('Y�� �T��i0}"xYf�^g^{�wh�Ya

R+�!����TR(o{h�R�z�\[f�z+f�\[XZo{f�ipf�t�a[���u^g^«�Aa[�w��ogi+�u\�a[X«}0^g��xYf�r�\[aZ�Ya��d��i�kpXZR��Y\Z� ��\[���u^g��f�a[X�u^gs%�!}~a�a[f����3���Y\[}F^��u\[h��W^g�YxwX[r�\Z�Ya����%R��%aZog�vr�^��uX[ogf�id\m��i�n0a�X[R��%s%R�f�^g�WaZxmR(f~f�^�X[f�h�YXZR��Y\�ui�k�k�f0�Ya�i�fX�k�oga[XZogi�hr�ogaZR ����f�i�h�XZR���xY^��ua[aZ�Ya�� �%R��Y\Z� ��\[��fi�^g}pX«s_fp���Y¤yf�\[avogiX[R��vaZog�vr�^��uX[ogf�i8�aZxYog�Yi�xY�wa ��i�k�R0r����ui�ogXZo{�wa��+��i�kTs%R�og^g�PXZR��Y\[����\[��t�f\ZxY�YaPs%ogXZR�ogiTX[R��a[og�vr�^��uXZogfi�XZR+�uX|z�r�aZR�aZX[r�k��wi~XZaPogi0X[fvXm��n0o{i(hv��f\Z�PxYf�r�\[aZ�YaPogiTX[R(�Yog\dz�\Z�yt��Y\Z\[�Ykp��\[���futdn0i�fus%^g�Yk�h����X[R��Y\Z�T�u\[�vi(fThr+��\m��i~XZ�Y�YaFX[R+��XPX[R(��\[�wa[r�^gX[ogi�h�a[xyR��Yk�r(^{�wa��uxYxYr(\m�uXZ�Y^g}\[�y�-�YxYXP���Y¤yf\%\Z�Y¦0r�og\[�Y�q�Yi0X[a!�d�%R��w\[���u\Z�"�u^gaZf�i�fqz�\[�Y\Z�Y¦0r�oga[ogX[�waP�Yi0t�f�\[xY�wk8�8�ui(kTX[R0r�ai�fPxYf�r�\[aZ�Ya_s%R�ogxmRv�u\Z�%z�\[�wk�f�qo{i-�ui0X[^g}%t�\[�YaZR����Yiv�ui(kva[�Yi�ogf�\[a����%R(o{a3��^{aZf�������i�a8XZR+�uXX[R���a[og�vr�^��uXZf\�x��ui(i�fX|\[����^{ogaZX[ogx��u^g^g}FxY\[����X[�Pxwfr�\Za[�Ya|t�f�\W�qf\[�|X[R+��i�fi���}�!�u\��

�%R��Fogk����u^�xYf�r�\[aZ�vfut���xYX[ogf�iToga�XZfq¬+i�k�a[f�q��\[����^3h\y�uk��YaP��i�k�XZ�Ya[X�X[R��F\m��i�n0o{i(ha[xyR��Y�q�Ya3f�ivX[R��Y���8�|i�xY�%S|U�]�]_f^g^g�Yh��WR+��a3��f�\[�3n0i�fus%^g�Yk(h�_futAs%R�ogxmRFa[xyR��w���%X[R(�Y}s%oga[RpXZf�r(a[��_X[R(�Y}paZR�fr�^gkl�j�un��"h�\m��k��YaFt�\Zf� \[�Yxw�Yi0X�}�!�u\[a��!���og^`����^g�Pt�f\�t�r�\[XZR��Y\X[�YaZX[ogi�h-�

����h�P�±�fut3�±