intrefugeelaw-finalpaper-egutiérrez

7/31/2019 IntRefugeeLaw-FinalPaper-EGutirrez

1/12

!

!"#$%'()*$+,-.$*/$0)1(*.2$-.3$1"#$

4#5#11,#6#.1$7#457#)1(8#$(.$9-1(.$06#4()-$

!

"#$%!&'()*++,-!.%/()##0!!

12345674!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

89):,+/)(;!0/(,+?%>!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

@9(,+9%()09%#!A,


2/12

! !

!

"#$%&!'(!)'*+&*+,!

-*+.'/01+2'* :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ;!

3&,&++%&4&*+!1'*+&5+!#*/!6#+2*!74&.21# :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

7/'8+2'*!'(!+9&!:;7::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: =!

"9&!19#*!

)'*1%0,2'*, ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ?@!

=2$%2':::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ?A!

!


3/12

! !

!

-*+.'/01+2'*!

$%&%''(%)%*'!+&!,*%!,-!'.%!/0123(%!4,(0'+,*&5!2*6!2*!+)7,1'2*'!',,(!-,1!

'.%! 8*'%1*2'+,*2(! 91,'%:'+,*;! 8'! 6,%&! +*!&,0=.'!2&>(0)!',!2*,'.%1!4'2'%!'.2'!.2&!

2=1%%6! ',!'2@%!'.%)!2&!1%-0=%%&A! ',!=12*'!'.%)!7%1)2*%*'! &%''(%)%*'!2*6! '.%!

,77,1'0*+'>! -,1! %


4/12

! !

:,*&'10:'+,*!,-!2*!+*&'+'0'+,*2(+B%6!1%=+,*2(!-12)%?,1@!1%=216+*=! 1%&%''(%)%*'!

1%-0=%&;!8*!,16%1!',!2*&?%1!'.2'A!?.2'!'.%!:,*:%7'+,*!,-!1%&%''(%)%*'!?2&!?+'.+*!

'.%!1%=+,*!?2&!3%-,1%!'.%!+)7(%)%*'2'+,*!,-!'.%!N9H!?2&!2*6!2*!2&&%&&)%*'!,-!

'.%!&0::%&&!,-!+'!?+((!3%!6,*%;!

3&,&++%&4&*+!1'*+&5+!#*/!6#+2*!74&.21#!

C.%!T,(,)3+2*!2*6!T%*'12(!H)%1+:2*!:,*-(+:'&!)0&'!3%!:,*&+6%1%6!%!2&! +*'%1*2'+,*2(!&077,1'! '.2*!'.%!,'.%1!F2'+*!

:,0*'1+%&;!T,&'2!$+:2!2*6!P:026,1!21%!:,0*'1+%&!?+'.!'.%!.+=.%1!12'%&!,-!2&>(0)!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!#!UNHCR, UNHCR 2009 Global Trends: Refugees, Asylum-Seekers, Returnees, Internally Displaced

and Stateless Persons (Geneva, 10 de June de 2010).!L!UNHCR, UNHCR, 2007 Global Trends: Refugees, Asylum-Seekers, Returnees, Internally Displacedand Stateless Persons (Geneva, 2 de June de 2008).!


5/12

! !

+*!'.%!1%=+,*a;!C.%!+&&0%!?2&!'.%*!&%%*!2&!2!71,3(%)!2*6!3016%*!:,*&%E0%*:%!,-!

-,1:%6!)+=12'+,*! ,1+=+*2'%6! 3>! +*&'23(%! =,!7,(+:+%&;!U*!'.%!,'.%1!.2*6A!2*!+)7,1'2*'!-%2'01%!,-!'.%!1%-0=%%&!

:,)+*=!-1,)!'.%&%!:,*-(+:'&!+&!2!:.2*=+*=!71,-+(%;!/0%!',!'.%!:,*-(+:'&!?%1%!32&%6!

,*!=0%11+((2!'%:.*+E0%&A!'.%1%!?2&!2!:,*&'2*'!3(011+*=!3%'?%%*!:,)32'2*'&!2*6!

*,*G:,)32'2*'&! 601+*=! '.%! :,*-(+:'A! +*! :(%21! !'.%!5X]X!H)%1+:2*!T,*


6/12

! !

3,16%1!21%2&;!8'!:2*!3%!:.212:'%1+B%6!2&!2!1%2--+1)2'+,*!,-!'.%!:,))+')%*'!-1,)!

'.%!F2'+*!H)%1+:2*!:,0*'1+%&!',!'.%!&,G:2((%6!M&7+1+'!,-!T21'2=%*2OA!&+*:%!+'!6,%&!

,--%1! 2!.0)2*+'21+2*! 2771,2:.!1%7(2:+*=! '.%!:,)),*!7,(+:>!,-!:(,&%6!3,16%1&!

',?216&!'.%!1%-0=%%&!&+'02'+,*;!!

C.%!N9H! +&!:,)71+&%6!,-!'?,!)2+*!:,)7,*%*'&c!5J!71,'%:'+,*!2*6!"J!2!

60123(%! &,(0'+,*&! ?.+:.A! +*! '01*A! +&! 6+OA! M3,16%1&! ,-! &,(+621+'>OA! 2*6! M1%&%''(%)%*'! +*! &,(+621+'>O;! MT+'+%&! ,-!

4,(+621+'>O!32&+:2((>!.26!'.%!2+)!,-!+)71,!-,1!2*>!F2'+*!

H)%1+:2*!:,0*'1>A!2'!'.%!,77,1'0*%!'+)%A!',!721'+:+72'%!2*6!',!1%:%+


7/12

! !

'.%! 71,'%:'+,*! 1%=+)%! +*!'.%! 1%=+,*55;!8'!6,%&!2((,?!)2+*'2+*!2!,7%*!&72:%!-,1!

2&>(0)! +*! '.%! '.1%%! :,0*'1+%&! ?.+:.! .+=.%&'! 12'%&! ,-! 2&>(0)G&%%@%1&! 2*6!

1%-0=%%&5"A! 30'! 2(&,! '.%! :1%2'+,*! ,-! 2! &077,1'! *%'?,1@! 3%'?%%*! :,0*'1+%&! 3>!

-+*2*:+2(! )%2*&;! C.%! 71,=12))%! +&! &077,1'%6! -1,)! %&'23(+&.%6! 1%&%''(%)%*'!

:,0*'1+%&!',!:,*&,(+62'%!'.%!71,=12))%!+'&%(-!2*6!',!30+(6!'.%!:272:+'>!,-!*%?!

1%&%''(%)%*'! :,0*'1+%&5#;! C.+&A! +*! ,'.%1! ?,16&A! +)7(+%&! +*'%1G=,


8/12

! !

C.%! )2+*! :.2*=%! '.2'! '.%! N9H! %&'23(+&.%&! +&! '.%! :,*:%7'+,*! ,-!

8*'%1*2'+,*2(!&,(+621+'>;!d.%*!%D7(2+*+*=!'.%!M4,(+621+'>!$%&%''(%)%*'O!+'!7,+*'&!

,0'!'.2'!'.+&!71,=12))%!+&!*,'!2!M3016%*G&.21+*=O!30'!2&!2!60'>!6%1+5L;! 8*!'.%! -+%(6!,-!8*'%1*2'+,*2(!$%-0=%%!F2?A! &,(+621+'>! +&!

7212),0*'! &+*:%! :,*&'+'0'%&! '.%! :,1%! ,-! '.%! 1%&7,*&+3+(+'>! 2&&0)%6! 3>! '.%!

+*'%1*2'+,*2(! :,))0*+'>! ',?216&! 1%-0=%%&5a;! 8*&'+'0'+,*2(+B+*=A! '.1,0=.! 2!

1%=+,*2(! 6,:0)%*'A! '.+&! +**,! ,-! 1%-0=%%! 71,'%:'+,*! 2*6! '.%! 1%-0=%%&!

'.%)&%(+*=!'.%!32&+:!1%E0+1%)%*'&5YA!:,*'121>!

',!'.%!'126+'+,*2(!712:'+:%!'.%>!6,!*,'!6%-+*%!E0,'2&;!d.+:.!)%2*&!'.2'!'.%!7,(+:>!

,-! M,7%*!3,216%1&O! +&! +*! +'&! ','2(!%D'%*&+,*A! ,*(>! (+)+'%6!3>! '.%! 2!'.%!QRST$!2*6!"J!'.%!71,&7%:'&!-,1!2!60123(%!&,('+,*&! ?%1%! 2&&%&&%6! 2*6!1%&%''(%)%*'! ?2&! +6%*'+-+%6!2&! '.%! ),&'! 2771,71+2'%! ,*%!2*6! -2((!0*6%1!,*%!,1!),1%!,-!'.%!QRST$!1%&%''(%)%*'!:2'%=,1+%&;!UNHCR, Note 2.!92=%!#];!


9/12

! !

2661%&&%6! &+*:%! '.%! &,(+621+'>! +*! '.%! 91,=12))%! 2(&,! +&! 6+1%:'%6! ',?216&!

&077,1'!3%'?%%*!=,! ,-! 2:',1&c!

=,!)%)3%1&A!2:26%)+:&A!:,))0*+'>!(%26%1&!2*6!

,'.%1&5X;!C.+&!+)7(+%&!'.2'!'.%!'2&@!,-!+)7(%)%*'+*=!2!60123(%!&,(0'+,*!6,%&!*,'!

-2((! 2*>),1%! ,*(>! 0*6%1! '.%! &:,7%! ,-! '.%! '126+'+,*2(! 3,6+%&;! C.%! &7+1+'! ,-!

&,(+621+'>!.2&!'.%*!=,*%!3%>,*6!'.%!4'2'%(>!&7.%1%!2*6!.2&!+)72:'%6!'.%!(,?%1!

,1=2*+B2'+,*2(! :+1:(%&A! ?.+:.! +*! 2*>! :2&%! :2*! .2!=,OA!'.%!7,(+'+:2(!+)7(+:2'+,*&!,-!'.+&!*%?!1%&%''(%)%*'!),6%(!6%1+


10/12

! !

?.+:.! 1%71%&%*'&! 2! &+=*+-+:2*'! :.2*=%! +*! '.%! (%=2(! -12)%?,1@! -,1! 1%-0=%%!

71,'%:'+,*"K;!!!

H&!:2*!3%!&%%*!-1,)!'.%!6%


11/12

! !

2661%&&%&!)%1%(>!1%=+,*2(!71,3(%)&A!&0:.!2&!'.%!:.2*=+*=!71,-+(%!,-!1%-0=%%&!2*6!

'.%!(21=%!*0)3%1&!,-!6+&7(2:%6!7%,7(%;!!

f,01! 21%! '.%!)2+*! :,*'1+30'+,*&! ,-! '.%!N9H! ',! '.%!*%?!7%1&7%:'+!,-!'.,&%!+*!*%%6;!8'!6,%&!%&'23(+&.!:.2*=%&!+*!'.%!:1+'%1+2!,-!1%&%''(%)%*'A!

%*:,012=%6! '.%! :,*&'10:'+,*! ,-! 71,'%:'+,*! *%'?,1@&! +*A!2! &'%7! +*!2! &.+-'! +*! '.%! 1%&%''(%)%*'! 72126+=)!

',?216&!'.%!:,*&'10:'+,*!,-!2*! +*&'+'0'+,*2(+B%6! 1%=+,*2(! -12)%?,1@! 1%=216+*=!

1%&%''(%)%*'! 1%-0=%&;! 8*! :2*! 3%! :,*&+6%1! ',! 3%! &,! ',! '.%! %D'%*'! ',! 3%! '1+==%1!

)%:.2*+&)! ,-! !

2*6!:,,7%12'+,*!',?216&!2!1%=+,*2(!71,3(%)A!+*!2!1%=+,*!'.2'!:,)7212'+!',!

,'.%1&!+&!%2&+%1!',!2661%&&!60%!',!'.%!(2:@!,-!+)7,1'2*'!:0('012(!6+--%1%*:%&A!+&!'.%!

@%>! *,'! ,*(>! 1%=216+*=!)+=12',1>A! 1%-0=%%! 2*6! 1%&%''(%)%*'! +&&0%&;! C.%&%! '?,!

-2:',1&!:2*!.2!'.,&%!+*!*%%6A!30'!2(&,!

'.%!1%:%7'+!,-!'.+*@+*=;!

H*!+**,!-1,)!'.%!'.%,1%'+:2(!+)72:'A!30'!2(?2>&!:,)%!

3>!'.%!&,:+2(!%--%:'&!'.2'!6+:'2'%!703(+:!7,(+:+%&;!

!

!


12/12

! !

=2$%2'!

!F>212!W03+0'A!F+(+2*2!2*6!d%((+*=',*!9%1%+12!T21*%+1,;!M$%&%''(%)%*'!+*!

4,(+621+'>c!2!*%?!1%=+,(2*!2771,2:.!',?216&!2!),1%!.0)2*%!60123(%!&,(0'+,*;O!

$%-0=%%!F2?!#K;#!I"K55Jc!]#G_];!

MN%D+:,!/%:(212'+,*!2*6!9(2*!,-!H:'+,*!',!4'1%*='.%*!'.%!8*'%1*2'+,*2(!

91,'%:'+,*!,-!$%-0=%%&!+*!F2'+*!H)%1+:2;O!N%D+:,A!"KKL!ghi!5]GR,;!

k;!$%&%''(%)%*'!S2*63,,@;!T.27'%1!88!G!C.%!%

intrefugeelaw-finalpaper-egutiérrez

Documents